6 ms·
I can tell you from experience the trains in the UK are expensive and miserable. The common theory for why is because of the mess made of privatising British R
by rwmj 7y ago
I can tell you from experience the trains in the UK are expensive and miserable.
The common theory for why is because of the mess made of privatising British Rail in the 1990s. The government did it in a way which managed to create monopolies while at the same time splitting out responsibility between different companies in such a way that millions are drained away on legal costs while the companies argue with each other about who is responsible for each problem.
There are many articles analysing the problems you can find online, here's one that turned up at the top of search: https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/jan/07/railways-privatisation-nationalisation https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/jan/07/railways-pri... Edit: Better article: https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/09/why-britains-railway-privatization-failed/3378/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/09/why-britains-...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoIt's a well worn topic. Had they not achieved the weird corporate separation, such that track, train, station building and ticket can all be separate companies putting on a new service, or adjusting timetabling and even putting up new posters could have been achievable things. As is they spend months, and millions going nowhere. [Edit: Not forgetting that station hotels, ferries and hospitality were separated out to yet more companies. Just because.] Had they just gone back to the big 4 of 1921-1947, or created a "medium 8" with extra rights to run charters on the tracks we might have rail that works by now. Then there's the 50+ year story of line and infrastructure upgrades... Each time we update, we seem to update to the previous generation's capability.
- simplesleeper 7y agoBritain runs 20% of Europe's rail journeys. It has the least accidents and deaths of passengers and staff. It is considered the most improved rail network year on year since 1997. It has some of the lowest fares if you book far in advance (and count the cost of subsidisation for foreign fares).
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoHow many decades did it take to electrify Europe's busiest line, the West Coast Main Line? Did it become modern? No. It used last generation signalling such that when we had 125mph HST they were limited to 80 and 100, when we bought back BR's APT as 150mph Pendolino they were limited to 1980s HST speeds as the tracks were electrified and upgraded to 125mph. In 2010. The "negotiations" between train operators wanting better rolling stock, railtrack (government), station upgrades and the inconvenient length of franchises made the whole process suitable for a Laurel and Hardy or Buster Keaton movie. Little wonder they're most improved, they gave themselves so much scope...
- lentil_soup 7y agoDo you have any sources where I can read more about this? I find it surprising
- cirrus-clouds 7y agoThe Office of Rail and Road publish annual safety statistics for UK rail. Here is a link to the 2019 edition. The page linked states: "2018-19 is the twelfth year in a row with no passenger fatalities as a result of a train accident." https://dataportal.orr.gov.uk/statistics/health-and-safety/rail-safety/ https://dataportal.orr.gov.uk/statistics/health-and-safety/r... The European Union Agency for Railways (ERAIL) collects statistics for EU countries: https://erail.era.europa.eu/safety-indicators.aspx https://erail.era.europa.eu/safety-indicators.aspx
- the_mitsuhiko 7y ago> It has the least accidents and deaths of passengers and staff. I think this is largely only an effect of a lot of rails being third rail and as a result there are fewer crossings.
- vertex-four 7y agoLots of rail is third rail... in London. The entire rest of the country uses overhead lines. We have been phasing out level crossings wherever possible though.
- makomk 7y agoWe should have plenty of tests of that theory in the upcoming years, since the EU decided that this weird seperation is such a good idea they're going to mandate all members do it. If I remember rightly, currently track and train have to be run by totally independent management structures (though as a sop to Germany and co, both can be part of nominally the same umbrella organisation), other companies have to have the right to run passenger services, and in a few years public passenger services will have to be put up for competitive tender UK-style. I'm not sure off-hand what they're doing with station ownership. This was something of an issue in the recent UK election. Obviously, EU membership was a major issue, and one of the main parties also wanted to renationize the railways... which is technically allowed by EU rules, it's just that there's very little point since we wouldn't be able to undo the weird structuring created by privatization.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoThat seems... well, beyond idiotic. Have to confess I've not been paying much attention to EU plans for continental railways, I just visit Netherlands and France from time to time and remind myself we could have done so much better. Netherlands has proper integration, France actually stumped up for a proper modernisation and high speed rail. UK had BR's (actually very good) plan that no one paid for... With the number of failed and failing franchises, there's a lot to be said for a new approach, perhaps via a period nationalised to draw a line and start again. It seems patently clear that the post-Beeching nationalised years, decades as under-funded political football, and UK's privatisation were all absolute disasters for passengers... Seems like the EU should look, shake their head, and mutter "definitely not". If it were me, I'd go back to the pre-war big 4 era, where there were a dozen or two smaller companies running parallel competition on some routes, or running goods and charters on big 4 lines. I probably wouldn't reinvent the pre-1921 situation that gave Manchester four stations all essentially overlapping - Central, Victoria, Oxford Road and Exchange. Pre-big 4 company history detangles that! Manchester Piccadilly was lucky in having less parallel competition. What we've lost, and totally forgotten, is just how much those pre-war railway companies did to feed the railways. Hotel stations that were not the manky unloved budget rooms of the seventies through today, but often a premium offering. The railways bought into early bus, ferry and tram services to develop those, and ensure services fed the stations. Integrated transport and travel! Compatible timetabling! Now I have to go to the Netherlands to experience that.
- jonwinstanley 7y agoI commute on British trains every day and have done for years. They’re not perfect but I am rarely delayed by more than a minute or two. Agree that a massive issue is the price, my train is close to £30 a day for a 50 minute ride into the city and it goes up by 3-5% every year. The only proper delays I see are caused by unusual weather, as it’s the UK - flooding or snow.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoCan I hazard a guess you are doing so in the South East? Try the trains the rest (most) of us experience. Northern Rail, Transpennine, West Coast, ScotRail, East Coast (there already) etc that have or are about to be given to "operator of last resort", i.e. renationalised -- under a Tory government --for having failed badly.
- zimpenfish 7y agoI commuted in the South East (particularly South East London which means SouthEastern trains) and it was a miracle if I was only delayed by 1 minute on a 12-20 minute journey. Coming to down the Charlton line into London Bridge almost always involved a 5-10 minute delay at (the crossover junction just outside the station that I forget the name of).
- alias_neo 7y agoI commute there now, the past weeks have been a nightmare of cancelled trains 2 minutes before they're due while I stand at an open air station freezing my nuts off or getting rained on. If we had a little more notice id stay home where it's warm for an extra 15 minutes. The delay you speak of is still there, and it's now worsened by the fact that the new Thameslink trains are given priority to pass as we sit and wait.
- vidarh 7y agoDon't know that line, but the approach to London Bridge is overall far less congested after the improvement work over the last few years, despite far more frequent Thameslink trains. It has follow on effects far down some lines as well, as problems at London Bridge would often cause delays far south of Croydon and up again towards Victoria (because Croydon becomes a chokepoint) for example.