5 ms·
I tried to read this article but it is tone deaf, infantile, and moronic. And I'm a very ardent environmentalist. Fundamentally it blames the victim. Carpooli
by AtlasBarfed 7y ago
I tried to read this article but it is tone deaf, infantile, and moronic. And I'm a very ardent environmentalist.
Fundamentally it blames the victim.
Carpooling won't work because even if people go to work at the same time (by some miracle no one is sidetracked in the process), getting home is even more unreliable given different workloads, so someone might get stranded. What to do then if you're in the burbs? Eat a 100$ taxi that might be a significant chunk of the take home pay they earned that day? Take an even longer time on things like busses that they haven't navigated before?
Biking is great until there is rain, snow, cold, and it exposes the rider to a far greater risk of catastrophic injury, and the downside of getting a flat is a lot worse than in a car since changing the innertube is often about a 50% chance of actually solving the problem if there are splinters or a bad outertube.
As for the victim blaming, companies should be obligated to providing comprehensive transit networks, or contribute to the existing transit networks. If the company is the usual adult daycare cubefarm office junk, then a company should be obligated to providing telecommuting options for parttime at least, and several office centers (especially in downtowns near transit nexuses).
Yes Americans suck. But they also are overworked, underserved by infrastructure, and given little options by businesses and governments.
- legulere 7y agoThe points you mention against biking to work in my opinion as someone that bikes to work don’t hold. The only problems are too big distances and cultural acceptance which would also lead to more infrastructure like showers at work.
- aidenn0 7y agoThe people driving to work can't get showers installed, so I think gp's point holds.
- heretoo 7y agoLiving in Melbourne, Australia, the real risk of catastrophic injury keeps me from cycling. The chance of being "doored" is very real, and the likelyhood of getting hit by a moving car is also very real. Most of my colleagues that cycle have been involved in these accidents. The city has bike lanes, which suddenly disappear, or require crossing moving traffic, just to go straight ahead, because the bike lane has now moved one car lane to the right. Along with a lack of training of drivers with regards to sharing the road with bikes, I wouldn't ever recommend that someone cycles in this city, even though many do. It would need the concerted effort from the entire population, similar to the Dutch population in the 70's or whenever they changed their bike road rules. See: https://www.vicroads.vic.gov.au/safety-and-road-rules/cyclist-safety/car-doors-and-bike-riders https://www.vicroads.vic.gov.au/safety-and-road-rules/cyclis... It mentions 771 "doorings" over a 5 year period. The number is probably much higher, since many wouldn't get reported.
- vjktyu 7y agoThe only problem with biking is that the land surface area is 2 dimensional and thus grows too slowly to accommodate everyone :/ but if someone buys me a reasonable place within biking distance then sure, I would sign a contract that obligates me to bike at least 75% of my work days (we can negotiate a different number) as long as I live at that place.
- specialist 7y agoFWIW, I weighed the risk of injury more as I got older. I live in a bike happy area. As in rows of bike stalls and people complain there still aren't enough. Three of my coworkers ended up in the ER, two of which were knocked unconscious. Many others have had spills and chills. It changed my behavior. Way more risk adverse. Only choose routes with lots of other cyclists (only thing which increases safety, from my reading). Totally avoid intersections with trucks. And so forth.
- creato 7y agoI'd agree with the article being infantile ("nudges"), but I don't think it fundamentally blames the victim. The main thing I took from it was that companies should stop subsidizing vehicle commuting (free parking, which they claim is thousands of dollars per year).
- seventhtiger 7y agoIndividual environmentalism like recycling and vegetarianism is an industry built to release frustration. Over and over their impacts have been shown to be negligible. They are selling you a feeling and not helping the planet. There is only one vehicle for effective change here and it is regulation. No matter how many people practice and advocate for less consumerism, if it's just so easy and cheap to massively destroy the environment then it will continue to be done in the service of other goals, whether profit, development, or even just for kicks. No amount of vegetarians and vegetarian-activism will have as much effect as the politician that bakes environmental costs into the price of meat. Lab meat is a similar pipe dream because it still doesn't address the problem.
- nsomaru 7y agoSo I’ve heard that most stuff marked for recycling never actually gets recycled. But vegetarians? What’s wrong with that?
- seventhtiger 7y agoNothing is wrong with it. It's perfectly ok to be vegetarian. But if you think you're helping the environment by being vegetarian, then you might not be as frustrated about the environment. Being a vegetarian is not "doing your part" when it's just an ineffectual gesture that assuaged your guilt. So it's only wrong as much as it is misdirected energy.
- cycomanic 7y agoIt seems like you did not read the article. The article is about a European airport so I'm unsure why you are talking about Americans at all. Most of your other arguments don't aplly either, for most people working at an airport telecommuting is not really an option, an airport also likely already has good public transport connections. The whole point about the article is that it's a study on how to change commuting behaviour, and the take home message is, it's difficult you need to have real incentives not just light nudges. No victim blaming to be found.