7 ms·
I found it amusing that the writer (and journalist) listed opposition to the Equal Rights Amendment among achievements worth defending. It still hasn't passed,
by ncmncm 7y ago
I found it amusing that the writer (and journalist) listed opposition to the Equal Rights Amendment among achievements worth defending.
It still hasn't passed, to all our disgrace. It only needs a few more states to ratify it.
- macintux 7y agoI didn't interpret that as a defense. I interpreted that as noteworthy and an indication of the complexity of his tenure that wasn't adequately captured.
- ElderKorihor 7y agoI think you're almost certainly correct. The "giveaway" to someone from a Mormon background was the inclusion of "Monson led the committees that codified the doctrines taught in every Mormon meetinghouse across the Earth." in the article. This sentence probably sounds completely banal and uninteresting to outsiders, but the "correlation" process, as it is called, it largely hated by both the most fundamental believers AND the most rabid apostates. The believers hate it because it's watered down all the crazy (and frankly much more interesting) parts of Mormon doctrine, Ex-mormons hate it because it whitewashes away many uncomfortable historical truths. The institution is invested in it, however, as a way to try to stamp out the legacy of polygamy. Like you say, the point of this article is that there's a lot of "there" there, but it takes more digging to find that NYT was willing to invest.
- lcall 7y agoFor what it may be worth: As a lifelong member who knows many others and reads a lot, I am completely unaware of anyone hating correlation. It has never come up in any conversation or thing I have read, until now that I see your comment. On the other hand, I am aware of tremendous amounts of original historical source materials and information on many topics that have been published and made freely available on the 'net, to anyone, including about experiences and statistics around polygamy and many other things). When I compare the journals I have read (handed down) and oral family history stories, personalities I have known, etc etc., with what I have seen of Church publicationis and online materials, I see nothing being whitewashed or hidden.
- wonderwonder 7y agoIt was a strange read. There were times I wondered if it was a parody. Praising all of the things the guy did to keep women and gays as second class citizens. Best that could be said is that at least he did not appear to be a racist, so that's nice.
- gliese1337 7y agoHave you read the Equal Rights Amendment? The idea behind it is nice, but as written it is an absolutely terrible bit of law, rife with unintended consequences. We already saw what happened with prohibition; opposition to the ERA is the right choice.
- lalaland1125 7y agoWhat exact issues do you have with the Equal Rights Amendment? The amendment is quite simple. It's just three sentences that state that men and women should have equal rights. > Section 1. Equality of rights under the law shall not be denied or abridged by the United States or by any State on account of sex. > Section 2. The Congress shall have the power to enforce, by appropriate legislation, the provisions of this article. > Section 3. This amendment shall take effect two years after the date of ratification.
- comex 7y ago...And even if the GP does name issues, what possible connection could there be to Prohibition, other than the fact that both involve constitutional amendments?
- gliese1337 7y agoThe connection to prohibition is that it seemed like a good idea at the time, but the unforeseen side-effects were way worse than the problem it was intended to solve--hence an additional ammendment was required to repeal it.
- gliese1337 7y agoAll government programs that benefit women suddenly become illegal. No more mandatory FMLA maternity leave. No more WIC, especially not for single mothers. Women would have to register for the draft. No more government support for women's shelters. No more presumption in favor of women in family courts. No laws requiring female representation. And a huge transfer of legislative power from the state to the federal level, for no clear benefit. Now, you could argue that some of those might be good things, but I guarantee that will not be a universal opinion. And you could argue that, rather than cutting services for women, we should increase services for men--but the ammendment does not require that, and are you really ready to gamble that that's how it would go? And what about discrimination based on gender--which, after all, is not the same thing as sex?