3 ms·
"To sketch a worst case scenario, suppose that five years from now (from 1985) the strategic computing initiative collapses miserably as autonomous vehicles f
by Animats 7y ago
"To sketch a worst case scenario, suppose that five years
from now (from 1985) the strategic computing initiative collapses miserably as autonomous vehicles fail to roll. The fifth generation turns out not to go anywhere, and the Japanese
government immediately gets out of computing. Every
startup company fails. Texas Instruments and Schlumberger and all other companies lose interest."
All of which happened. That was the "AI Winter".
The "Fifth Generation" was an initiative by the Ministry of International Trade and Industry in Japan to develop a new generation of computers intended to run Prolog. Yes, really.[1]
The "Strategic Computing Initiative" was a DARPA-funded push on AI in the 1980s. DARPA pulled the plug in 1987.
I got an MSCS from Stanford in 1985. Many of the AI faculty from that period were in deep denial about this. I could see that expert systems were way overrated. I'd done previous work with automatic theorem proving, and was painfully aware of how brittle inference systems are.
Each round of AI has been like that. Good idea, claims that strong AI is just around the corner, good idea hits its limit, field stuck. I've seen four cycles of this in my lifetime.
At least this time around, machine learning has substantial commercial applications and generates more than enough revenue to fund itself. It's a broadly useful technology. Expert systems were a niche. There's enough money and enough hardware now that if someone has the next good idea, it will be implementable. But strong AI from improvements to machine learning? Probably not.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fifth_generation_computer
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Computing_Initiative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Computing_Initiative
- mcswell 7y agoI worked on an AI program in the 80s that is perhaps the only program from that era that's still being used. I got hired in 1984 into the AI group at Boeing Computer Services (neither the AI group nor BCS exists any more, and yes, it was part of that Boeing); I was in the Natural Language Processing group (the expert systems group was a different set of people). I left in 1987 to do s.t. else. By that time, we had built a syntactic parser of English that covered most everything in "standard" English (but without most of the probabilistic apparatus that modern parsers have). It was a solution in search of a problem. After I left, the rest of the NLP team came up with the problem. When Boeing builds an aircraft, they have hundreds, if not thousands, of manuals. (No comment on the 737 MAX...) The planes are sold to airlines around the world, many of whose employees don't understand English anywhere near as well as a native speaker would. Boeing wanted its writers of manuals to write in simplified English. There was (and is) a standard for that, but it was very hard to ensure that writers conformed to it. The solution was to rip out all the "interesting" constructions from my grammar, and retain only the constructions and lexicon that conformed to the simplified (technical) English standard. Then the manuals got pushed through the parser; anything that didn't parse had to be re-written to conform to the grammar. And (I think, remember this was after I left) if anything parsed too ambiguously, it was sent for a rewrite as well. And that's how a 1980s AI program is still in use today.
- The_rationalist 7y agoIs it open source? Why keep it for themselves? Where you doing semantic parsing? What parsing techniques where you using? Where you inspired by a linguistic formal grammar in particular?
- wileyarmenian 7y agothe fifth generation computers didn't "run prolog", they were completely new forms of concurrent constraint logic/dataflow hybrid architectures using Prolog-like Horn clause notation for user end programming, which the US Navy implemented successfully around the same time but you don't hear about as much
- The_rationalist 7y agoSource? How can I query this?