3 ms·
That's because Vancouver is a relatively small, and dense city, and has a lot of people with countries where people think of good public transport as something
by baybal2 7y ago
That's because Vancouver is a relatively small, and dense city, and has a lot of people with countries where people think of good public transport as something taken.
It's important to make public transport good enough for people to use it. When public transport is an inferior option to owning a car, people would not use it.
I think what urban planners in the West miss is that public transport scales non-linearly.
The bigger the city, the more you gain from owning a car. For a public transport to be viable in a megacity, the network needs to be like much, much, better than in a smaller city.
When planners miss that, you get both terrible car traffic, and terrible public transport
- ido 7y agoI disagree after having lived in 4 cities with metropolitan populations of 500k to 4.5m: In the smallest town driving was ok cause there wasn't as much traffic. In the largest driving anywhere central would usually mean getting stuck in traffic and parking was expensive and hard to find.
- baybal2 7y agoEven if you get stuck in traffic, you still can get to more places quicker than on foot. Yes?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ido 7y agoOf course the alternative is not on foot- it's mostly mass transit, sometimes mixed with cycling.
- bobthepanda 7y agoDepends on how long it takes to find parking, especially if you're not willing to stump the higher cost for a garage space. And wouldn't the alternative be transit? No one is walking all the way across Vancouver.
- beatgammit 7y agoI live near Salt Lake City and the train infrastructure that exists is well used and pretty well thought out, and we have a pretty big car culture here. Salt Lake City isn't a very big city in terms of population, and it spans a pretty big, flat area, yet the transit system is popular. My extended family lives near Seattle, which has more dense population and higher motivation to use public transport (lots of environmentally conscious people), yet I think most would agree that the train system is inferior to Utah's. I think this is because: - commuter rail doesn't link up very well with the light rail line (airport) - commuter rail only runs morning and afternoon The Trax (light rail) and Frontrunner (commuter) lines, however, are very well connected and both run all day. My main frustration is that the Frontrunner line doesn't run on Sundays, but it has a far more flexible schedule than the Seattle line. If you live anywhere along the Frontrunner/Trax system, you can rely on it to get you to the airport, work, or shopping, provided you don't need to travel late at night. That being said, I think Seattle's total transit system is better than SLC's, but I think that's because there's less of a stigma against riding the bus in Seattle as well as a higher budget (Utahns are very fiscally conservative). I think SLC has done a fantastic job of building a transit system that works for tourists and locals alike. Seattle built two separate systems that works okay for each, but doesn't work together very well. Drivers like flexibility, but the Seattle train system isn't flexible. So, in order to convince people to commute differently, that system needs to be useful for far more than just commuting. I don't want to rely on a commuter rail line of I'll occasionally need to stay late, which would cause me to miss the last train. I also don't want to rely on a system that's inconvenient to work into other plans, like going to the airport at lunch time or doing some shopping on the way home.
- boring_twenties 7y ago> that system needs to be useful for far more than just commuting Isn't this the biggest problem with Trax? I'd love to take it downtown at night, but it stops running well before 1am.
- bobthepanda 7y agoThe main issue with the Seattle commuter rail, Sounder, is that the host railroad is not keen on giving more slots to run trains, so the schedule isn't very useful. The issue with the station is that the Union Station office complex and historical building are in the way of proper wayfinding, so that the path between the commuter rail and the light rail looks more like an out-of-the-way alley than an actual path you're supposed to take.
- scarejunba 7y agoHmm, folks in my family commute from Burquitlam to the city all the time. I don't think you're right that it's small. The Millennium line runs to Lafarge Lake.