6 ms·
>>>> The nudges that we tried would likely have been more successful if employees had to bear the full costs of their commuting decisions. Employees already vo
by analog31 7y ago
>>>> The nudges that we tried would likely have been more successful if employees had to bear the full costs of their commuting decisions.
Employees already voluntarily increase those costs if they can, by buying more expensive and less efficient vehicles.
The only thing I've read that makes sense is for people to live closer to things, and that's hard to make happen overnight. For instance, as a bicycle commuter, I'm aware that many if not most of my colleagues live many miles from work. Thus the debate about transportation mode is practically moot.
- btrettel 7y ago> For instance, as a bicycle commuter, I'm aware that many if not most of my colleagues live many miles from work. Thus the debate about transportation mode is practically moot. Yes, as a cyclist myself I've had people tell me "Cycling is impossible in my case because of the distance." But what they've actually done is optimize for driving, which makes cycling inconvenient. If they optimized for cycling then driving might be inconvenient! If someone wants to make an intervention here they need to catch people at a particular time (i.e., moving) rather than random times.
- damnyou 7y agoNo, people are optimizing for things like family over work (which is good and should be strongly encouraged as part of work-life balance). It just so happens that driving is the most flexible way to get to work, so it looks like they're optimizing for driving.
- maxsilver 7y ago> But what they've actually done is optimize for driving, which makes cycling inconvenient Did they optimize for driving, or optimize for affordability? At every place I've ever worked, "optimize for cycling" has actually meant "optimize for being a millionaire". The housing near work is literally 250% more expensive than regular housing, and most people can't afford that. And even if you do optimize for cycling, at some point you'll have to get a new job that wrecks this plan. Do you force your family to move every 2-3 years, everytime you get a new job, so you can continue to live cycling-distance to it? If you have a spouse, which of the two of you gets to live cycling-distance to work?
- graywh 7y ago> at some point you'll have to get a new job that wrecks this plan. Do you force your family to move every 2-3 years, everytime you get a new job, so you can continue to live cycling-distance to it? you could give preference to jobs that don't require moving
- analog31 7y agoThat can be hard. Very few people have all that many realistic options, especially when they have to wrestle with things like health benefits, age discrimination, and so forth. There are relatively few places in the country where a person can find multiple jobs within cycling distance of affordable housing.
- erik_seaberg 7y agoYou'd think this would work in the bay area yet it hasn't. I've changed jobs four times since 2006 and none has ever been within thirty miles of the next.
- analog31 7y agoI was actually thinking the bay area was the least likely because of the separation of housing and employment centers.
- btrettel 7y agoIn my experience going car-free and moving closer can easily be cheaper. At my previous apartment (Austin, TX) I paid maybe $200 more per month in rent to live within a few miles of my work. The savings from not having a car definitely exceeded that in my case. As for the remainder, you're making a number of assumptions that don't apply in many cases. I'm not arguing that cycling is good for everyone, just that often optimizing for driving means making cycling more difficult. First off, not everyone has a family. I don't, so this criticism doesn't apply to me at all. I know one cyclist who has moved his family for every job he gets. When he gets a new job, so far they've been so far away that moving was necessary even if he drove, though. (Not actually sure he cycled before he moved to Austin, now that I think about it, but still.) I also know at least two cyclists who have lived in the same place for long periods of time. In one case I don't believe their spouse works, and in the other case I believe their spouse might drive.