3 ms·
While I see your point, I'll add that there is no language called "Lisp", or rather, that language stopped in the 1960s while other Lisp dialects developed. "L
by eesmith 7y ago
While I see your point, I'll add that there is no language called "Lisp", or rather, that language stopped in the 1960s while other Lisp dialects developed. "Lisp evangelist" is instead applied to the wider set of Lisp-like languages.
As a point of pedantry, should Perl 6 (the programming language of 4 months ago) be considered a Raku dialect?
Or vice versa?
- lizmat 7y agoI would argue that Rakudo used to implement a Perl 6 dialect, and that it now implements a Raku dialect. Perl 6 and Raku share just about everything, except the name :-)
- eesmith 7y agoC, Objective C, C++, Java, and C# are part of a family of related languages. These may be referred to as "C-like" languages. The C-like languages, plus Pascal, Ada, and others, are part of the Algol superfamily of languages. "Family" and "superfamily" aren't well defined, in the way that it is for biological taxonomy, but I think it's intuitively clear enough for this discussion. The Python family includes the various CPython language implementations, plus JPython/Jython, Iron Python, and PyPy, as well as wider-away dialects like Cython. At some point it's part of the Python superfamily. What's the name for the family of languages which includes Perl 6 and Raku? I think "Perl-like" includes Perl 4, 5, and 6, Raku, as well as (further away), Ruby. I think Perl 6 and Raku are parts of the Perl 6 family, following the usual tradition of naming language families after the first instance in that family. (It isn't always that, see https://wiki.c2.com/?WirthLanguages https://wiki.c2.com/?WirthLanguages ). What would you suggest as the family name for Raku and Perl 6 which excludes the more distant members of the family, like Perl 5? Delphi is an Object Pascal, for example.
- lizmat 7y agoWall-inspired Languages?
- lispm 7y ago> that language stopped in the 1960s while other Lisp dialects Lisp has seen direct lineage from the 60s until today with lots of backwards compatibility.
- eesmith 7y agoSure, but name one widely-used one since the 1960s where the implementation is referred to, simply, "Lisp". "Lisp" refers to a family of languages, not a specific implementation. Similarly, the term "Lisp evangelist" probably does not mean someone who only promotes Scheme, or only Clojure, or some other specific Lisp dialect.
- kazinator 7y agoSomeone who promotes Scheme or Clojure is not a Lisp evangelist, since these aren't Lisps. Among other things, they don't have syntax made of mutable cons cells, terminated by the symbol nil, which is also self-evaluating and serves as (the only) Boolean false.
- eesmith 7y agoI defer to your deeper knowledge and experience.
- lispm 7y agoMost users of Emacs Lisp, and similar languages talk of just "Lisp". Implementations tend of have Lisp in their name. Books, too. If the language/implementation does not have Lisp in their name, it usually signals that this language is not (or no longer) backwards compatible and a new derived dialect: Logo, ML, Scheme, Dylan, ... There are basically almost no languages with single implementations. C has many. Python has many. Ruby has several, Scheme has dozens, Logo has probably a hundred, Clojure has several, ... We have a clear view of what C means: the language even has standards. C then has a lot of derived languages: Objective C, C++, and a bunch of others. Still I would think that there are many implementations/languages which are very near to C, but don't implement the full ISO C standard or can differ from it in various ways (-> Dialects). Similar for Lisp. There are basically two standards for Lisp: ANSI Common Lisp (with >30 implementations - full or subsets) and ISO Lisp (called ISLisp). There are also a few (often) historical variants of Lisp: Emacs Lisp, AutoLisp / Visual Lisp, Standard Lisp, Interlisp, LeLisp, ZetaLisp, ... These languages have a core, which is more or less compatible to / derived from Lisp I. See for example the Lisp dialects mentioned in 'History of Lisp': http://www.softwarepreservation.org/projects/LISP/ http://www.softwarepreservation.org/projects/LISP/ These are the historic core of Lisp. There is a tendency to speak of a wider 'Family of Lisp' - but if you look closely, then languages like JavaScript/ECMAScript tend to be a part of that 'Family' - which makes it more or less meaningless. I tend to avoid that, because it does not set the expectations for practical usage right: JavaScript is practically not compatible, though it shares some features with Lisp: functions, anonymous functions, symbols, garbage collection, data syntax, evaluation, interactive use, ... Similar: Scheme is now its own language family with its own standards: RNRS Scheme, IEEE Scheme, ... and many more or less conforming implementations.