4 ms·
You're not correct. EU citizens should be allowed to work anywhere in EU member states. That's fine, it's one of the founding principles of EU membership. The
by ChuckNorris89 7y ago
You're not correct. EU citizens should be allowed to work anywhere in EU member states. That's fine, it's one of the founding principles of EU membership.
The problem is when EU companies have virtually no restrictions on hiring people outside the EU putting even more downward pressure on local salaries in high COL areas.
- hos234 7y agoCompanies will outsource, move development centers elsewhere etc etc. Visa restrictions alone aren't going to save anyones job. The world is too competitive.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoThe whole fear of outsourcing is a myth companies use to deregulate immigration and it needs to stop being used as fear mongering to justify lax regulations. If outsourcing was so good why hasn't all of SV packed and moved abroad already to cheap countries or even to cheaper states in the US instead of offering insane salaries at home? Companies stay in the west because of the ecosystem comprised of stable government, generous financing and skilled workforce.
- hos234 7y agoIf Airbus wants to hire 300 software engineers, good luck finding them in reasonable time periods in Germany or France. Local small niche firms can survive. The larger you get the longer it takes to hit hiring goal. You will understand that only after you spend time actually hiring people. Telling the boss well I can't do this locally in 3 months, I need 6 plus a budget to relocate people from other EU locations will just get you laughed out of the room for the simple reason someone else in the org has already done it through outsourcing and importing people. > Companies stay in the west because of the ecosystem comprised of stable government, financing and skilled workforce This is probably 10-15 year old rhetoric that isnt true anymore. There are now dozens of hubs worldwide that make it simple to hire large number of people fast. Just make a trip and look at the scale at which they function. The EU is doing the right thing by trying to pull more people in.
- pnako 7y ago> If Airbus wants to hire 300 software engineers, good luck finding them in reasonable time periods in Germany or France. Are you serious? Countries with traditions of engineering going back centuries, with some of the best schools in the field, will have trouble to find... 300 software engineers?
- echaozh 7y ago300 unemployed engineers, or you're just moving the hiring problem to the smaller companies with their engineers suddenly gone.
- ChuckNorris89 7y ago>If Airbus wants to hire 300 software engineers, good luck finding them in reasonable time periods in Germany or France. Airbus can't find 300 engineers in Germany and France? Come on! More like Airbus can't find 300 engineers in Germany and France willing to work for peanuts. It's always the last part that gets lost in the translation. Has Airbus thought about training said engineers instead of expecting them to magic themselves out of thin air whenever they're needed? Looking at their margins it's not like they can't afford it. >The EU is doing the right thing by trying to pull more people in. The EU is doing the right thing for Airbus shareholders, not for the local workforce.
- hos234 7y ago:) You will find Airbus managers who agree with you BUT they compete for reaources with Airbus managers who don't. This is an old debate and it's more or less a settled one in large orgs with large requirements whether in US or EU - the managers who don't care how they meet their goals win. You don't have to believe me, you just need to spend time talking to people who have run large teams in the EU and ask them how they survive. The world is not getting any less competitive and mgmt in large orgs spend most of their day reacting rather than proactively doing anything. Smaller orgs it's easier but again they too are under pressure in different ways. During this phase where many things are in flux and unstable it's a safer bet to move to where the jobs are then expecting the govt or corp s to do anything radical. They are too trapped even if they have competent ppl...anyway that's just my experience and opinion and I hope I am wrong.
- thrower123 7y agoBecause outsourcing fails and is abandoned after two or three years, when the real costs have become apparent. The bastards that thought it up have moved up and out on the strengths of the initial cost savings by the time those chickens come home to roost. You don't have to see this kind of cycle too many times before you get a little cynical.
- d44m 7y agoI've been in the IT industry for close to 20 years now. Outsourcing as a factor is not significant in project failures. Also, most outsourcing companies have been around for a while and are doing fairly well.
- jfim 7y agoOutsourcing of IT duties (helpdesk, etc.) or outsourcing of software development? Those two are very different.
- zerr 7y agoEU is just a yet another set of deals. Switzerland is not even a EU member - it has a yet another set of deals. There are reasons for such deals as with Blue card deals or similar. Preferring one deal over another just because of nationality or race is wrong.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoHiring restrictions to the EU exclusively have nothing to do with race but they do with nationality and there's nothing wrong with that. As an EU national and EU taxpayer for decades, I expect to be a first class citizen of my region and the governing bodies to prioritize my well being first as much as I expect the US or Chinese or Indian governments to prioritize the well being of thier citizens first as opposed to mine. Is it wrong if I can't get a work visa for SV? Or China? Or India?
- zerr 7y ago> Is it a problem of race/nationality It is, when you're saying that it is fine for Romanians or Polish to dump the market, but not Indians.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoYou see, now you're making it a problem of nationality. EU membership allows free movement of capital, goods and workforce between EU states with equal rights. Singling out Romania and Poland means you have a personal problem with these nationalities. Don't like it? Vote your country leaving the EU. Oh, and FYI, Romanian tech salaries are some of the highest in EU where new grads can earn €2k NET due to a hot market and low taxes so your point about wage dumping doesn't hold.
- negamax 7y agoThat's still not good enough as compared to Zurich or Amsterdam. Or many other cities. Why stop at tech. Many Romanians and other poor EU immigrants move across Europe for all kind of jobs. I don't think you have thought this through and not realizing or outright ignoring xenophobia in your arguments.
- aclsid 7y agoI think more of an issue with who they hire it should be more about the minimum amount they are allowed to pay. That will tilt the scale in favor of home players since they already know the language, local customs, work culture, etc.