3 ms·
Advice from health organisations is generally not "anti salt". Rather, it's "pro health", that is, those organisations are not telling you to eat less salt beca
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
Advice from health organisations is generally not "anti salt". Rather, it's "pro health", that is, those organisations are not telling you to eat less salt because they don't want you to enjoy life, or because they are idiots who don't know how to read the data. In fact, public health organisations have people who are specifically paid to read and interpret the literature, so it's very unlikely they'll be the last ones to catch up on the new information.
If public health advice hasn't changed with "recent data" the reason for that -other than the experts being stupid and not knowing their shit- is that recent studies are recent. You can't overturn a few decades of evidence with a few studies- not even a few meta-analyses etc.
And one should always remember that a study is a study, and not the word of the God of Science. And studies are flawed.
Take for example the study quoted in your linked article:
In May European researchers publishing in the Journal of the American Medical Association reported that the less sodium that study subjects excreted in their urine—an excellent measure of prior consumption—the greater their risk was of dying from heart disease.
Such surprising results have also been found for wine, for example, and the methodological error that produces them is as insidious as it is now well understood. In particular, studies on the effect of this or that on cardiovascular health often don't control for people with _pre-existing_ heart disease. People who already have heart disease are very likely to have reduced their salt or alcohol etc consumption _before_ the study, as a result of medical advice - but of course, they will still suffer from heart disease. If they later die of their pre-existing condition, the study will show an association between low sodium or alcohol etc consumption and death from heart disease.
That's very likely what happened in the study quoted by the article you link to- but of course we can't know for sure because bloody "Scientific" American never cites the studies it quotes.
Anyway, from my perspective (I have a relative with kidney disease and I've been eating a low-sodium diet with them for years now) the first I heard about salt being OK for you after all was a few years ago when a heart doctor published a book that caused a hell of a controversy - between expets, no less. Here's an article about it:
https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/aug/08/a-danger-to-public-health-uproar-as-scientist-urges-us-to-eat-more-salt https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/aug/08/a-danger-to-...
My hunch is - if there's a controversy about it between experts, better stick with the advice that is _not_ controversial among experts, until things clear up.
And don't be prepared to celebrate overturned scientific orthodoxies so easily. If you have 100 studies that say A and 10 studies that say B, you trust the 100 studies that say A. See the green jellie beans XKCD etc.
- Retric 7y agoIt’s far more than the last decade, here is an example from 1983. “Rigorous sodium deprivation can lower the blood pressure of some patients with essential hypertension (at best, 30% to 50% of patients). In the rest, sodium depletion is ineffective and, in some instances, can raise the blood pressure and cause adverse clinical effects. In normal persons, it is difficult to affect blood pressure even with drastic changes in salt intake; for the blood pressure to rise even slightly, it may be necessary to consume more than 800 meq/d. There is no evidence to indicate that a widely applied, moderate reduction of salt intake could prevent the development of hypertension. The evidence suggesting that such moderate salt intake would significantly lower blood pressure in the patients with sodium-sensitive essential hypertension is weak. Human hypertension comprises a heterogeneous spectrum of abnormal vasoconstriction-volume interactions. Sodium deprivation, like other forms of therapy, should be applied only to those patients in whom its effectiveness has been established.” https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/6847013 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/6847013
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoFrom the same time period, I find this review that has found different evidence: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3510595 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/3510595 Sodium and hypertension. A review. Arch Intern Med. 1986 Jan;146(1):179-85. Abstract Abnormal sodium metabolism may be critical in the causation of certain forms of hypertension, particularly salt-sensitive hypertension. Long-term restriction of sodium intake in patients at high risk for the development of hypertension may reduce the chances of established hypertension occurring later. These high-risk patients in whom subsequent hypertension may be prevented include normotensive patients with family histories of hypertension, elderly patients, black patients, and those with low-renin hypertension. Treatment of hypertension with moderate sodium restriction to 70 mEq/day will significantly reduce blood pressure in a large percentage of patients, particularly known salt-sensitive hypertensive patients. This degree of restriction is also an effective adjunctive therapy for patients receiving antihypertensive medications. There is convincing experimental, epidemiologic, and clinical evidence that moderate sodium restriction helps prevent and assists in the treatment of hypertension in those patients who are genetically predisposed to develop primary hypertension or who already have hypertension. There is no evidence that this degree of sodium restriction is harmful. My hunch is that for every study we could find in the bibliography reporting that there is no correlation between high salt consumption and high blood pressure, we would find another 10 that say the opposite. Personally, I don't have the time, or the background, to figure out how to evaluate the quality of an epidemiological study. So I base my assumptions on the current expert opinion that continues to be that too much salt is bad for you especially if you have high blood pressure (or are at risk for it, like the review above says). Edit: also, remember the basic rule that "absence of evidence is not evidence of absence". But _presence_ of evidence _is_ evidence of presence. If 10 studies find "no evidence" that lowering salt intake reduces hypertension risk and one study finds that it does, then we have "evidence that lowering salt intake reduces hypertension" and we do not have "no evidence that lowering salt intake reduces hypertension". How we interpet the evidence we do have is another matter, of course.