4 ms·
Excerpt: "Need some ideas for a crappy schematic? Here are some easy ones I can think up off the cuff: o Current limiting resistors missing (BJTs, diodes, etc
by peter_d_sherman 7y ago
Excerpt:
"Need some ideas for a crappy schematic? Here are some easy ones I can think up off the cuff:
o Current limiting resistors missing (BJTs, diodes, etc.)
o Shorting a potentiometer node to a rail
o Voltage regulators missing capacitors at input/output
o Missing pull-up/pull-down resistors on digital buses
o Missing decoupling capacitors
o Powering ADC reference voltages from a switching supply
o Transistors placed in wrong/backwards configuration
o No signal conditioning/buffer for analog signals into ADC
o AC coupling high-pass filter sets corner frequency too high into ADC
o Reset sequence of digital component is wrong
o Antenna is missing a matching network/filter
o Clock/data lines swapped backwards in digital bus
o No pull-up/pull-down resistors on IC configuration pins
o No frequency compensation on unstable opamp circuits
o Improper gain settings on opamp circuits"
Fascinating!
Would love to see a book about these errors and others -- with the title:
"Learn EE (better!) -- by studying things that don't work"
The book could be divided into chapters... Each chapter delves into another way that a circuit can fail, along with an explanation of why, and the correct way to engineer that type of circuit/circuit component... The chapters would be ordered from the most common errors to the less common ones... it would be a great teaching tool for people who wanted to become better at EE...
- cushychicken 7y agoI've never heard of a whole book, but I can see how it'd be a great book if someone really took the time to make it. I guess you could argue that The Art of Electronics kind of fills this niche. Horowitz and Hill call out a bunch of non-functional or error prone circuits with large, friendly "DON'T DO THIS" labels. The second edition had a great section at the end of each chapter entitled "Bad Circuits" that served just this purpose. (The only flaw with the 3rd edition is that they took out "Bad Circuits", in my opinion.)
- yummypaint 7y agoThat's too bad they removed the bad circuits. I found those extremely useful when first starting out. Sometimes my first guess at how to do something was explicitly noted as a bad circuit, which i suspect was the intention. After reading about a new component, students often wonder "can i just do x instead?" and the bad circuits section did a great job of anticipating these kinds of questions.