8 ms·
A Stanford Professor Says Juul Stole Her Anti-Vaping PowerPoint Slides
- Chris_Chambers 7y agoShouldn’t she just be happy they didn’t kill her? Honest question.
- pesfandiar 7y ago"Company in tobacco industry that tries to get children addicted plagiarizes slides" Relatively nice journalism by Buzzfeed, but I think there are better topics to report on Juul if you're appealing to ethics.
- catalogia 7y agoIt all goes towards painting a more complete picture of the company. Stories like this wouldn't mean much in isolation but it strengthens the greater narrative of Juul being a unethical corporation.
- chottocharaii 7y agoIt seems you didn't read the article closely. They didn't just plagiarize the slides, they neutered them, and then attempted to pass them off as Stanford endorsed research; all without permission from the author.
- allovernow 7y ago> they neutered them So they're derivative works of PPT slides? Does that count as theft? How much do you need to change a slide before it's a new work? >attempted to pass them off as Stanford endorsed research As in falsifying a conclusion or reinterpreting the data?
- pesfandiar 7y agoI did read the article. All that is just a more unethical strain of plagiarism to me. I however agree with the other comment below that this report could go toward painting a full picture of what kind of company we're dealing with.
- suyash 7y agoStealing other peoples work (including orignal slides) is not okay, specially without credits and/or permission.
- dehrmann 7y agoThe title (from BuzzFeedNews) leaves out that the slides were plagiarized by Juul, then Juul paid schools to teach them, all while name-dropping The Farm. I'm trying to tease apart how much of the plagiarism is to be expected when you're an academic, whether Juul was being more manipulative or lazy, and is paying schools to teach this a token gesture, an insult, or inception marketing.
- caseyf7 7y agoInception marketing....I hope that doesn’t catch on, but it sounds like 2021’s growth hacking.
- musicale 7y agoMarketing and market research.
- jdsully 7y ago> how much of the plagiarism is to be expected when you're an academic Last I checked academics have the same rights under copyright as the rest of us.
- dehrmann 7y agoIANAL, but it's complicated because this was(?) produced as part of her employment by Stanford, so arguably Juul took Stanford's work. Stanford is private, it can do what it wants, but what about public universities? Should the public own the IP they fund? IP created by public employees in the US are often released into the public domain. What if a professor from a private school got a government grant? I'm not sure how settled any of this is legally.
- geofft 7y agoNot just "released" - works created by federal officers and employees cannot be copyrighted in the first place. But public universities are run by states/territories/etc., not by the federal government, and there's no such restriction on state governments. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_status_of_works_by_subnational_governments_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_status_of_works_by_s... Another interesting case: works done by government contractors are eligible for copyright protection, and the copyright can be transferred to the government, which is, I think, how parts of OpenStack can be copyrighted by NASA. By that argument, professors (or anyone else) with government grants should definitely be able to copyright their work and keep copyright. There's certainly an increasingly-popular argument that publicly-funded research work should be publicly accessible / open access, but there's no law or even norm about it yet.
- WilliamEdward 7y agoIn 50 years we will look back on Juuls the same way we look back on cigarettes today.
- zamfi 7y ago50? I hope, for everyone’s sake, that it’s closer to 5.
- barrkel 7y agoI'd be surprised, since it appears that vitamin E in grey market THC pods has been the cause of the health issues, and aside from that vaping is substantially less harmful than cigarettes (but not risk free).
- taurath 7y agoJuuls in particular give you about 3x more nicotine per puff than a cigarette, and they marketed directly to kids via free handouts at concerts. Juul is the thing that isn’t about getting you off cigarettes, it’s getting you on even more nicotine so it’s even harder to stop.
- taurath 7y agoI should also note that they go to fairly great lengths to muddy the exact amount in comparison to a cigarette. Most of the copy on the internet about the amount is a direct quote from Juul (1 pod - 1 pack).
- ericpauley 7y agoAny specific reasoning here? My understanding is that virtually all recent vaping injuries were caused by grey-market oil-soluble (e.g. THC) products, not from water-soluble nicotine products. Do you have data/studies suggesting the claimed extreme danger of vaping commercially available nicotine products (especially considering their obvious use as smoking cessation aids)?
- EdwardDiego 7y agoAs a reformed smoker who moved to vaping, I'm terribly concerned at the current marketing of vaping to teens, and the uptake within that age bracket in my country (NZ). I switched because my nicotine addiction isn't an easy one to break, and vaping is significantly cheaper (our government increases excise taxes on tobacco annually, so currrently $30 NZD buys me a pack of 20 cigarette that I smoke in a day, or it buys me a bottle of vape juice that lasts 2 weeks). And I'm a big fan of vaping for the economic and (so far as we know currently) health benefits for smokers. But what really concerns me, is the number of young people who would never smoke due to the (successful! and good on the Ministry of Health for doing so) demonisation of cigarette smoking, who are instead happily vaping away. It seems apparent from the marketing that Big Tobacco has realised where their next big market lies - young people who don't want to smoke, but will vape if you tell them it's healthy and cool. At the end of the day, you're still getting people addicted to nicotine for money. Yes, bonus that there's less cancer involved, but it' still a monetised addiction. My preference would be for vape liquids containing nicotine to be prescription only for recovering smokers. If kids want to blow watermelon vapour out of their lungs, go nuts, just don't do it with a known addictive substance in the mix.
- lovehashbrowns 7y ago> My preference would be for vape liquids containing nicotine to be prescription only for recovering smokers. Isn't this going to make the argument for making teens smoke cigarettes so they can get access to vaping with nicotine? And before you say "they're not going to go that far," we can also have a conversation about what underage people will do to get access to alcohol. Also, I'm especially humored by people wanting to put legal restrictions on things like vaping but wont have that same discussion about alcohol, which imo is much more harmful. Alcohol literally is: Yes, bonus that there's less cancer involved, but it' still a monetized addiction.
- adjkant 7y agoI think the flaw in that flow is that no one cares about nicotine, they just want vaping. As long as vaping without nicotine exists, there's no reason to go after the other version. Unless you're already addicted, and in that case, I'd say let's get them the prescription as well.
- aaomidi 7y agoFor the people here who are thinking teens are doing this for taste, etc. Ask yourself how much more existential crises kids these days are facing. Global warming is happening and the adults aren't doing anything. They're seeing their family get crushed by medical debt and the adults aren't doing anything. Not only that they're actively voting for people who support the current system. The world is fucked for these people and the adults are blaming stuff like how it tastes instead of the structural issues these kids are going through.
- maverick2007 7y agoAlthough I'm sure there are some teens that think that, don't you think "my friends are doing it", "it's cool" and "it's fun to blow sick clouds when the teacher isn't looking" a lot more likely than some existential crisis? I mean at least I was a lot more likely to think the former than the latter a couple of years ago when I was a teen
- ultrarunner 7y agoMaybe the belonging and ‘adult’ involvement in something semi-dangerous distracts them from the existential dread. I don’t know if I’d make that argument, but I do think the reasons involved are nuanced and varied.
- catalogia 7y agoOne need look no further than the marketing material corporations like Juul are putting out. Are the ads playing up fears of climate change, or are the ads about making the product look cool? It's the later, obviously. Anybody who says otherwise is either deluded or trying to delude you.
- barry-cotter 7y agoYou’ve heard of the bomb, right? From 1950 to the end of the Cold War every thinking person knew there was an excellent chance that’s they and everyone they knew could die along with the rest of civilization. Before WW2 even the richest society in world history, the US, was by modern standards fairly poor. People died of diseases we just don’t worry about now because we have antibiotics. This generation is not special. Everyone has to deal with shit.
- lazylizard 7y agoHey. I agree with smoking zones and so on. But why the trend towards bans? I want to die young.