5 ms·
Salt is definitely bad for your if you have high blood pressure (can dig up refs if required) and high blood pressure is a risk factor for cardiovascular diseas
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
Salt is definitely bad for your if you have high blood pressure (can dig up refs if required) and high blood pressure is a risk factor for cardiovascular disease.
Btween 35% and 40% of people have high blood pressure. For them, the consumption of "liberally salted" products is something to be avoided.
Statistics from WHO:
https://www.who.int/gho/ncd/risk_factors/blood_pressure_prevalence_text/en/ https://www.who.int/gho/ncd/risk_factors/blood_pressure_prev...
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoSalt is one of those weird things. The salt studies were years ago, mostly, and haven't fully been redone with modern standards. It isn't that they were fully wrong, but it doesn't always have the ills one is warned about and the amounts of "healthy" salt might vary. Some of those folks with high blood pressure will be helped by a lower salt diet: Some will not and I'm not sure if there are consistent links saying it causes high blood pressure in healthy folks with normal blood pressure. The rest of the folks with high blood pressure aren't always helped - probably because there is more than one path to high blood pressure. Genetics, medicines, smoking, diet, lack of exercise, weight, and so on. Even in this subset, these meats aren't universally bad. If your salted meat is a smallish portion of your diet and you use comparatively little salt in the rest of your food, you might be just fine. It isn't that one thing is salty, but that the overall diet isn't too high in salt.
- sjwright 7y agoAnd reducing salt has a devious unintended consequence: encouraging a diet higher in carbohydrates and fructose specifically—almost certainly worse than the salt for most people. Salt is one of the most effective ways to make healthy low carbohydrate foods (particularly fats and protein) palatable and compete with the sugar, corn and wheat that are so prevalent in unhealthy foods.
- trianglem 7y agoI find spicyness and sourness to be pretty good substitutes for salt and they make a lot of the blander (but healthy) vegetarian food taste fantastic.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> Salt is one of those weird things. The salt studies were years ago, mostly, and haven't fully been redone with modern standards. That sounds very vague- what is "years ago" and what are "modern standards"? If "modern standards" are better for salt studies- are they also better for, e.g. drugs research, or physics or chemistry, etc? I think probably not. What I understand the big difference is between now and the past (let's say the 1950's), in terms of scientific standards has more to do with ethical requirements, rather than methodology. More modern studies are also more likely to use more recent statistical tools, or to rely more on automated tools and software packages, but that doesn't meant the newer studies are more accurate. I also don't know why you say that salt affects different people with high blood pressure differently. My understanding is that there is variability between _studies_, so some studies have found that hypertensives that reduce their salt intake see a reduction in their blood pressure, some have not, but that doesn't mean that hypertensives react to salt differently- it means that different studies had different results and that's all. And variability among studies' results is clearly expected, given the different methodologies etc. Generally, I'd say it's hasty to discard data and results collected over many years because some -but not most- modern studies have different results. In such cases the prudent thing is to wait and see before making up your mind. Currently, the bulk of the data supports the mainstream view that salt consumption over some amount is associated with raised blood pressure. The wise thing to do is to take that into account and manage your consumption accordingly. Another thing: how many people (say, under 30) know what their blood pressure is and how it's affected by salt? I know, because I have a relative with kidney disease and I often measure my blood pressure with them, and take notes. Most people though - they have no idea. So again- don't be hasty. It's difficult to know how salt consumption affects the general population, but if anyone wants to know how it affects them, personally, they don't need to rely on studies, new or old. All they have to do is use a blood pressure monitor once or twice a day for a few weeks. And I personally suggest everyone does, because what happened to my relative was downright scary. They had splitting headaches for a long time (years) and they only found out the reason when we visited a doctor for something unrelated. A nurse asked a question about general health and I replied that my relative has these splitting headaches (my relative would never bring up something so trivial themself!). It turned out those headaches were the result of 200/100 hypertensive episodes that were happening with regularity. Hypertension was likely either the root cause, or a contributing factor to the damage to my relative's kidneys (and also caused by that damage, in a real nasty feedback loop)- but we had no idea it was even there. And btw, my relative has definitely been able to control their blood pressure by cutting down drastically on their salt intake (they take drugs, of course, but salt still affects them very clearly). Blood pressure is such a basic vital sign that's so easy to measure. It's so easy to know, studies or no studies, how salt affects you. And yet, most people never measure it and instead we end up having these arguments on the internets about what this study or that study says about salt, in the general population, in the abstract. I don't quite get it.
- Retric 7y agoBased on recent studies salt does not seem to be that bad for you. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/its-time-to-end-the-war-on-salt/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/its-time-to-end-t... Anti salt advice from heath organizations has persisted despite a lot of evidence. Even the basic osmotic argument around blood pressure ignores lymph outside of blood vessels containing salt resulting in zero net forces. At most there is a minuscule change in viscosity.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoAdvice from health organisations is generally not "anti salt". Rather, it's "pro health", that is, those organisations are not telling you to eat less salt because they don't want you to enjoy life, or because they are idiots who don't know how to read the data. In fact, public health organisations have people who are specifically paid to read and interpret the literature, so it's very unlikely they'll be the last ones to catch up on the new information. If public health advice hasn't changed with "recent data" the reason for that -other than the experts being stupid and not knowing their shit- is that recent studies are recent. You can't overturn a few decades of evidence with a few studies- not even a few meta-analyses etc. And one should always remember that a study is a study, and not the word of the God of Science. And studies are flawed. Take for example the study quoted in your linked article: In May European researchers publishing in the Journal of the American Medical Association reported that the less sodium that study subjects excreted in their urine—an excellent measure of prior consumption—the greater their risk was of dying from heart disease. Such surprising results have also been found for wine, for example, and the methodological error that produces them is as insidious as it is now well understood. In particular, studies on the effect of this or that on cardiovascular health often don't control for people with _pre-existing_ heart disease. People who already have heart disease are very likely to have reduced their salt or alcohol etc consumption _before_ the study, as a result of medical advice - but of course, they will still suffer from heart disease. If they later die of their pre-existing condition, the study will show an association between low sodium or alcohol etc consumption and death from heart disease. That's very likely what happened in the study quoted by the article you link to- but of course we can't know for sure because bloody "Scientific" American never cites the studies it quotes. Anyway, from my perspective (I have a relative with kidney disease and I've been eating a low-sodium diet with them for years now) the first I heard about salt being OK for you after all was a few years ago when a heart doctor published a book that caused a hell of a controversy - between expets, no less. Here's an article about it: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/aug/08/a-danger-to-public-health-uproar-as-scientist-urges-us-to-eat-more-salt https://www.theguardian.com/science/2017/aug/08/a-danger-to-... My hunch is - if there's a controversy about it between experts, better stick with the advice that is _not_ controversial among experts, until things clear up. And don't be prepared to celebrate overturned scientific orthodoxies so easily. If you have 100 studies that say A and 10 studies that say B, you trust the 100 studies that say A. See the green jellie beans XKCD etc.