4 ms·
Probably the denizens of the next star over noticed that the star in question had inhabited planets, and turned it off against the possibility they might, other
by ncmncm 7y ago
Probably the denizens of the next star over noticed that the star in question had inhabited planets, and turned it off against the possibility they might, otherwise, someday become a threat.
This is a candidate for the Great Filter: interstellar civilizations that come into contact destroy one another.
- Faaak 7y agoFor those that wonder: this is (one) of the plots of the "Three body problem" trilogy. It's a really great book, I really recommend it !
- celticmusic 7y agoThe entire series is amazing. In addition, he has a collection of short stories 'The Wandering Earth'. If you want to see a movie loosely based upon the ideas of one of those shorts stories, look up the movie 'The Wandering Earth' on Netflix. Just to give some background, I watched that movie not realizing what it was based off of, just knowing it was a chinese sci-fi. And I remember being amazed at how big the ideas were and thinking China must have a culture of exceptional sci-fi writers. Afterwards I did some research and realized who it was. Cixin Liu is the author and he's so good at big ideas. I can't recommend his stuff enough. edit: link https://www.amazon.com/s?k=the+wandering+earth+cixin+liu https://www.amazon.com/s?k=the+wandering+earth+cixin+liu
- ismail 7y agoI have been waiting for the 3 body problem film. Last I checked it was delayed, with just the trailer released. Will check out the wandering earth. Thanks.
- colordrops 7y agoThe Wandering Earth was one of the worst movies I have ever seen. Poor writing, no plot, bad science, melodramatic acting, and propagandistic messages throughout.
- dpau 7y agoit is indeed a horrible film, let's hope the three body series is not similarly butchered
- colordrops 7y agoLet's hope, but I'm not holding my breath. Officials hold far too much sway over Chinese filmmakers, making it near impossible to create a quality film.
- mercutio2 7y agoI don’t understand. Every one of those negative traits applies to The Three Body Problem as a novel, except for acting, in my opinion. I realize there exist people who like sci-fi and think The Three Body Problem is good, but... I can’t understand what they see in it. The last 50 pages or so was at least an ok short story...
- ncmncm 7y agoLast 50 pages of the first volume? The last 50 pages of the third volume were not worth the paper.
- celticmusic 7y agoThe ideas in it were amazing. I can understand people who can't look past the execution to see the underlying ideas. One of the things it did really well was the idea that it takes everyone pulling in the same direction to be effective.
- nightfuryx 7y agoThis read very similar to the "Three-body problem" trilogy, specifically the second book "The Dark Forest"
- ismail 7y agoThis is a plot element in The Dark Forrest [0] book. Otherwise called the Dark Forrest theory [1] [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dark_Forest https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Dark_Forest [1] https://bigthink.com/scotty-hendricks/the-dark-forest-theory-a-terrifying-explanation-of-why-we-havent-heard-from-aliens-yet https://bigthink.com/scotty-hendricks/the-dark-forest-theory...
- maratd 7y agoAlso Winter World (and the other two books in the trilogy). Fun read. Very similar in style to the The Expanse.
- ismail 7y agoPersonally I found the style very different between the expanse and the three body problem trilogy. The expanse seems “lighter” or less hard. The last book, deaths end i found to be particularly “hard sci-fi”.
- maratd 7y agoWrong trilogy =) I was talking about https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B07N32K12H/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_d_asin_title_o08?ie=UTF8&psc=1 https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B07N32K12H/ref=ppx_yo_dt...
- xvector 7y agoJust a tip - forest has one ‘r’ :)
- ncmncm 7y agoThe Dark Forest is a related idea, in which mature civilizations are not all destroyed by contact with their equals, but lurk about, in ambush. The mutual demolition alternative seems simpler and more reliable, and possibly more consistent with the evidence. Dropping a black hole, even a smallish one, into a star would seem to eliminate the central pressure needed to sustain fusion, and turn it off pretty suddenly, by astronomical timescales.
- monkeycantype 7y agoI was thinking of the first moment when the bubble appears in quarantine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quarantine_(Egan_novel) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quarantine_(Egan_novel)
- wostusername 7y agoSince everything in physics tells us that FTL travel is impossible (as far as I am aware), then when a civilization detects signs from another civilization in another solar system it knows that 1) that civilization was advanced enough to produce signals into space light years ago, and 2) by the time it reaches it at sublight speeds (hundreds, possibly thousands of years) it will be more advanced still. That means your extermination mission might be facing a technologically superior enemy with home field advantage.
- maratd 7y agoUnless you assume each solar system is a threat, so you proactively send automated machines to each solar system that can adapt to the threat as needed. They might also not care if there is or isn't life there and just want to build Dyson spheres everywhere.
- ncmncm 7y agoThe argument for Dyson spheres is extremely weak. If you are powerful enough to build one, you are also powerful enough to dismantle a nearby gas giant and fuse that.
- DaiPlusPlus 7y agoThe energy required to dismantle and fuse a gas giant would be tremendous - there's definitely an opportunity-cost involved. Compared to a Dyson sphere - which only requires a tiny, tiny, tiny fraction of the energy absorbed to build and launch the orbiting platforms that make-up the sphere. You can "ignite" a gas-giant by maneuvering a black-hole into position inside the gas-giant, but (as far as we know) there are far more gas-giants than there are black-holes, and the distances involved are tremendous (nearest black hole: 3,000ly, nearest gas-giant: 6 to 9e-5 light-years). It just doesn't strike me as feasible or even worthwhile even if it was feasible. Maybe as the heat-death of the universe approaches, the last band of remaining humans (don't ask) try to ignite the gas-giants to keep the lights on?
- 7y ago
- bsdetector 7y agoWhat if these stars are disappearing as part of an orderly shut down procedure of some grand simulation, taking millennia from our perspective. Civilizations would get to a level of science where they find out and even if they could reach us before the reset, there'd be no point. Like when you're playing a video game and you get "server shutdown in 30 minutes", you log off right away or mess around until it happens. The Great Filter is only limited by our imagination and doesn't even have to involve us at all.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoSeem to vaguely remember a Twilight Zone or similar along those lines. There's a planet that's trying to achieve peace. They're in the middle of a cold war, looking rather like earth, half hour ends with the failure of talks and a nuclear war. Camera pulls back to two alien teens playing an intergalactic arcade game, now showing "game over". Perhaps the one playing the sim got bored and started star killing their own solar systems.
- perl4ever 7y agoIn SimEarth, there was always the temptation to destroy everything with asteroid strikes...
- ncmncm 7y agoArthur Clarke, in his throwaway short story The Nine Billion Names of God, had an obscure cult that believed humanity's, and the universe's, purpose was to write down all of God's names. They are well along before they rent a computer with a line printer, and finish the job in a few weeks. Then the stars start to go out.