3 ms·
I don't think the article successfully argues against Thiel's criticism. Clearly there is an opportunity cost to putting highly trained individuals to work on s
by Barrin92 7y ago
I don't think the article successfully argues against Thiel's criticism. Clearly there is an opportunity cost to putting highly trained individuals to work on some issue vs another. If you look for example at the number of PhD physicists in finance it seems obvious to me that if these people were working on biotech or materials or infrastructure or process optimisation there would at least be some more progress than there currently is.
Digital tech giants barely interact with other sectors of the economy in meaningful ways, the lack of economic or productivity growth after the computer era is well documented, and there would be tangible benefits from aiming resources and talent at sectors that interact with the material world and the economy at large.
The article also brings up Europe as an example that the lack of digital giants doesn't result in more progress, but that's actually not true. Infrastructure costs in Europe are significantly lower than in the US. One only needs to look at the transport sector in Germany or France and compare it to California's attempt to build high-speed rail. The US trails not only Europe but even countries like China in some key sectors.
Now building high-speed transport infrastructure for the masses might not make it into the next Pivot podcast or on the frontpage of techcrunch, but for the long term health of the economy and the general surplus for society is probably larger than more smartphone apps.
- vorpalhex 7y ago> One only needs to look at the transport sector in Germany or France and compare it to California's attempt to build high-speed rail California is about the same size as Germany and less than half the population. Germany has several existing, historical train systems. California, less so. There's a lot going on in that case beyond just California having a lot of digital tech folks.
- dragonwriter 7y ago> California is about the same size as Germany and less than half the population. California is about 20% larger than Germany, in terms of land area, much longer when you look at the longest dimension. Germany is both substantially smaller and more compact for it's land area.
- Barrin92 7y ago>Germany has several existing, historical train systems. California, less so. There's a lot going on in that case beyond just California having a lot of digital tech folks. Yes, but that is the point. Process knowledge is lost when it isn't practised, and the attitude in the US over the last few generations of prioritising so-called 'shareholder value' and tightly concentrated knowledge sectors in the economy over a more general, infrastructure and manufacturing-oriented course is the reason for this. Digital tech is both a symptom and a cause of this, I don't blame it alone obviously. By the way, this was not always the case for the US. The US used to be a world leader in for example rail transportation in the 19th and early 20th century. The changes in the US that have made it fall behind in infrastructure were choices, not fate. If the US wanted it could revitalise that culture. And maybe as a cautionary tale for the US, we have one example on the European periphery, the United Kingdom. A country that went from being a world leader in many sectors to harvesting global IP in one part of the service economy to the detriment of competitiveness in others. The average British worker is now 30% less productive than their German or French counterparts, and internationally British products outside of finance are largely irrelevant.