4 ms·
I love that idea for 401k matching. All the downsides of a pension [1], combined with all the downsides of a 401k[2], with none of the upsides of either! [1] I
by vkou 7y ago
I love that idea for 401k matching. All the downsides of a pension [1], combined with all the downsides of a 401k[2], with none of the upsides of either!
[1] If your employer goes belly up after you retire, you are screwed.
[2] Because it's fixed contribution, as opposed to fixed payout, if you lived longer than you planned, you are screwed.
- softwaredoug 7y agoExactly! We could transition our stock out, but that setup employees with the lovely complication of having to learn about insider training and how to NOT do it...
- smileysteve 7y ago> but that setup employees with the lovely complication of having to learn about insider training and how to NOT do it Generally speaking, the majority of (non DOD) Boeing employees should not be restricted by insider trading; It's often rumored to have broader reach than it does. In order to be an insider, you would need to have direct impact or insight into an unannounced project, corporate, or financial disclosure. It may even take some authority to be able to materially impact delivery deadlines or financials before you're considered an insider.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoIn fairness, issue two is probably better addressed at the national level -- something like what Social Security's original intention seemed to be: a safety blanket for those who lived much longer than expected. In 1935 when SS was enacted, life expectancy was 61.7 years. benefits didn't kick in until the average person was dead by 3.3 years. If this chart is accurate: http://vis.stanford.edu/jheer/d3/pyramid/shift.html http://vis.stanford.edu/jheer/d3/pyramid/shift.html -- it looks like in 1930 less than ~5% of the population was older than 65. If this chart is accurate: https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.65UP.TO.ZS?locations=US https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SP.POP.65UP.TO.ZS?locat... -- it looks like ~15% of the population is currently older than 65.
- refurb 7y agolife expectancy in 1935 was severely dragged down by infant mortality. What was the life expectancy at age 18? At retirement age? If you made it past childhood, you were pretty likely to die far later than 61 years.
- onlyrealcuzzo 7y agoThat's why I also looked at the percentage of people that were older than 65. It's 3x higher now.
- smileysteve 7y agoWell, if being prudent you wouldn't be using your non company match part in Boeing at all. (puts in line with those of us with no match). Sidenote: It's laughable when companies say they think options are a better choice for the employee than a 401k match.
- leetrout 7y agoIt could be better... in the University of North Carolina System you are FORCED to participate in 401(k) or the state pension and once you pick one you have to keep it throughout your employment.
- sjg007 7y agoState pension seems like the better way to go...
- afjl 7y agoWhat about the risk that the government slashes your benefits?
- sjg007 7y agoEven if they do you can also vote in someone next time to restore your benefits. I'd rather have an option on an indefinite benefit vs a fixed one.
- CydeWeys 7y agoPension isn't infinite though, as you will die at some time, and the parameters on how long people can live are quite well known. For example, you should always take $2M up front at 70 instead of $50k per year indefinitely because you simply can't live long enough for the latter option to ever come out ahead. * with the current state of medical science.
- afjl 7y agoI suppose I agree on a personal level, but my concern is moreso with the structure of funding pensions vs funding 401k's.
- vkou 7y agoEven if you expect to take a haircut on your pension, it's still a good idea to diversify your retirement investments, for the same reason that you should invest into both bonds, and stocks. If you retire during a recession, your planned 20 years of 401K runway may not last you more than 12. Or you might end up living longer than 20 years. Or both. With a guaranteed payments pension, you will continue receiving benefits as long as you live. This aspect of it wont matter to you if you fall over dead at 68, but will matter greatly if you end up living longer than planned. Right now, less than 5% of my retirement savings are going towards a pension (Social security). I would be much happier if that number (And the expected returns from it) were closer to 25% - and that's with the expectation that SS payments will unexpectedly drop in the future. Having an investment instrument that will pay me until I die is great for diversifying my portfolio.
- jeffdavis 7y ago401(k) is an amazing system, because it's accountable. The only use for a traditional pension is to hide the liabilities for someone else to discover later; or perhaps avoid the liabilities completely by declaring bankruptcy. 401k solves the problem by putting the assets with a third party immediately. Maybe there's some way to have an insurance product to handle cases where people live longer than normal. That could be an improvement. But that should be handled by a fourth party. That sounds like an annoying number of parties. But trust me -- mixing up of money for today with money for 30 years from now is just not a good system (in the private sector or government).
- refurb 7y agoPensions are insured by the US gov’t up to a limit, I believe around $60K per year.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoThe PBGC is just a cover your ass entity. It can’t handle the debts coming due it’s way, so much so, that Congress is working on a bailout for multi employer pension plans currently.