14 ms·
A Navy Seal's Semester at Yale, at Age 52
- asdfman123 7y agoMore people need to learn that if you leave your bubbles and talk to people, you'll find that they are actually indeed people too, and not caricatures you read about on outrage-bait new articles.
- tareqak 7y agoI’ve mentioned an idea to a friend of mine: a sort of welfare/basic income program where people are paid to talk to others. There is no restriction as to the topic as long as the other person consents to having the conversation: it can be as mundane talking about the weather. My reasoning behind it was just to get people who otherwise would not talk to each other to do so to actively reinforce my observation that everyone is the same in different ways and different in the all same ways.
- usrusr 7y agoReminds me of the movie Breakfast Club and I haven't even seen it.
- asdfman123 7y agoNah, I don't think many people would get much out of socializing if you made it mandatory to keep receiving their income. I would like to see just less dependence on cars, but I have no way of foisting that on people either. You could be like me and grow up a weird liberal in a red state, but that will give you a complex and I don't recommend it.
- philwelch 7y agoThis is the social value that we used to get from churches, fraternal organizations, bowling leagues, block parties....
- AaronFriel 7y agoSome of those things are more inclusive and diverse than the others. Fortunately there exists a modern equivalent that exposes people to a lot of different folks all at the same time: universities. For many rural teenagers, a university will be the first time they meet people from another country, who don't speak English as their first language, or a sizable number of people with a different skin color. Speaking from experience, growing up in Iowa.
- philwelch 7y agoAnd that brings us full circle back to OP. Most university students are in their late teens and early 20's and once they graduate they never go back. Churches and other social institutions are more lifelong.
- true_religion 7y agoAll of which exist, and will happily take you in if you want. So this is a social value in addition to that, not a replacement for its loss.
- philwelch 7y agoThe degree to which they exist and successfully serve that function has been diminishing, at least in the United States, for decades.
- JshWright 7y agoThose all tend to be pretty ideologically homogeneous...
- wetmore 7y agoBowling clubs and block parties are ideologically homogeneous?
- mcguire 7y agoTalk to, or talk at? "What she meant by “safe space” was that she was happy to be in an environment where difficult subjects can be discussed openly, without the risk of disrespect or harsh judgement. This works both ways."
- starpilot 7y agoOnly do this if you're part of the in-group. If you're part of the out-group and reveal yourself, you could lose your job, friends, and more. If you were to reach out or fraternize with someone like James Damore, you will likely be cast out.
- Izkata 7y agoThis is actually the impression I got from the medium post: he didn't reveal any viewpoints that would risk exposing him as not being part of the in-group, whether or not he actually held any.
- tstrimple 7y agoCan you say the same for Derek Black? https://www.npr.org/2018/09/24/651052970/how-a-rising-star-of-white-nationalism-broke-free-from-the-movement https://www.npr.org/2018/09/24/651052970/how-a-rising-star-o...
- hellomyguys 7y ago> More people need to learn that if you leave your bubbles and talk to people, you'll find that they are actually indeed people too, and not caricatures you read about on outrage-bait new articles. I often find the people that make this case are in their own bubbles, they aren't aware about. Like the notion LA and NYC are bubbles, and the midwest is "real America." Even though LA and NYC contain huge amounts of economic, racial, and LGTBQ+ diversity, and what many politicians consider "real America" to be a homogenous group.
- hirundo 7y agoFrom the author's photo his purple heart was not from a minor wound. He appears to be an amputee. I imagine that the dog in class was related to this. It is heartening that these students were able to respect this man for his service, or despite it. I would hope that the same would happen if his sacrifice was less evident. I'd think it well could have. People are so much better when they meet face to face without any built in confrontation.
- defen 7y agohttps://www.stripes.com/news/navy-seal-dog-handler-how-a-failed-mission-to-rescue-bowe-bergdahl-caused-irreparable-loss-1.385511 https://www.stripes.com/news/navy-seal-dog-handler-how-a-fai...
- ohashi 7y agoThat story is heartbreaking
- dave84 7y agoThe larger incident is the subject of the season 2 of the Serial Podcast.
- gbronner 7y agoThe Yale Directed Studies program is no joke -- it tends to attract the most motivated humanities students and to have incredible amounts of work and reading. Impressive that he's taking it, but he's also seeing a somewhat more serious class of students who, by extension, are less likely to be snowflakes.
- mistrial9 7y ago> snowflakes what does that mean ?
- runjake 7y agoRead the article where he describes the meaning? It's a reference from the book/movie, Fight Club. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowflake_(slang)#Unique_or_special_snowflake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowflake_(slang)#Unique_or_sp...
- ThrowawayR2 7y agoSee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowflake_(slang) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Snowflake_(slang) The "Other Uses" section is interesting; I didn't know about its (now historical) use by abolitionists in a different meaning.
- asdfman123 7y agoAre you sure that relationship holds true? I've talked to more ordinary college students and they're pretty reasonable, normal people too. Perhaps what's more likely is a tiny fraction of toxic people who use the social justice toolbox illegitimately are amplified disproportionately. The world has always had toxic annoying people. There's always been that lady at church that pretends to be into Jesus but secretly just likes to dominate and bully others. Most people you meet though are pretty reasonable and nice. Try to see the humanity in people who aren't like you.
- didgeoridoo 7y agoThe point is that the tiny toxic fraction is unlikely to pursue a curriculum that starts with the assumption that the western canon is worth reading and understanding deeply.
- lazyjones 7y agoThis very humble author possibly impressed and changed his fellow students more than he would admit. Many modern narratives and trends simply fall apart when confronted with reality.
- hackworks 7y agoThank you very much for the wonderful and very insightful article. Developing the humility and truly believing that we are all snowflakes and willingness to learn from the diversity around us is a big step forward. I loved the analogy between leaders and bridge builders. I always considered leaders as those who build a pedestal or platform or ladder for the rest to use and grow. Very similar. It gives me confidence and courage to take up a few courses myself and enjoy learning and not just go after grades.
- tantalor 7y ago"infamous YouTube video" No link.
- aidenn0 7y agoMaybe this one? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiMVx2C5_Wg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiMVx2C5_Wg
- lordleft 7y agoStudying with veterans is an incredible experience. I'm lucky that my school (Columbia) has a very large undergraduate vet population. It adds a dimension of experiential diversity that many colleges fail to capture, and makes real what are normally distant and easy to abstract away geopolitical decisions, like deploying troops in Afghanistan. I hope more universities follow Yale and Columbia in creating spaces for returning serviceman to integrate into collegiate life - it's good for all of us.
- rb808 7y agoAlso hiring. I worked with an ex Army Ranger who was by far the best leader I've seen.
- op00to 7y agoI have an ex ranger on my team who is the most sexist, pompous, self important asshole I’ve ever met. By far the best bloviator and derailer of projects I’ve seen.
- fredsanford 7y agoEx ranger... While I didn't serve, I did grow up with and had close family and friends that were part of navy, army and air force special forces. The clown you describe does not last long in special forces unless he's a modern day Audie Murphy, Roy Benavidez or Chesty Puller.
- patleeman 7y agoI totally agree. I'm a graduate of Columbia's School of General Studies, alongside many veterans and other non-traditional students. I'm not a veteran, but I had many friends that had served. We had classes with younger students from Columbia College and Barnard and I felt like we brought a different perspective to the classes. I learned a lot from my fellow classmates and I feel so fortunate that I had the opportunity.
- chrisseaton 7y agoGoing into the military before you go to college seems to be a very common thing in the US. In the UK you'd either do college (university) first, or you wouldn't be planning on doing it at all. Some people do in-service degrees but I don't think it's common for large number of people to do a normal undergraduate degree after a military career.
- haecceity 7y agoHe shouldn't be too impressed by his younger class mates. Having discipline to do the work and problem sets would put him ahead of most of them.
- sanj 7y agoBased on the article, I'd expect that he disagrees with you. Strongly.
- ProAm 7y agoHis book 'Touching the Dragon' [1] was an interesting read. I recommend it if you liked this article, gives you a perspective of where he is coming from now. [1] https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/548196/touching-the-dragon-by-james-hatch-and-christian-dandrea/ https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/548196/touching-the...
- forgotmylogin2 7y agoThe author either has a fundamental misunderstanding of the criticisms against "safe spaces" or he's deliberately mischaracterizing them to earn the favor of his classmates. > What she meant by “safe space” was that she was happy to be in an environment where difficult subjects can be discussed openly, without the risk of disrespect or harsh judgement. If that's actually how safe spaces were implemented in practice, there'd be little backlash against them. The primary criticism against safe spaces is that they are an excuse to censor dissenting opinions. A common example is that people opposed to sex-reassignment surgery are not allowed into discussions about trangenderism because their opinions are considered "disrespectful" or even "violent" to transgender people.
- toiletfuneral 7y agoIf you every get to know someone who is, you'll find trans people actually do suffer significant violence and disrespect. I know you put those in scare quotes to imply it's not real and I think that's really dishonest.
- jedbrown 7y ago"If wearing a tan suit wasn't deeply unbecoming of a President, there would have been little backlash from conservatives."
- shkkmo 7y agoI am sure safe spaces are implemented in a variety of ways and with varying levels of competence. I would point out that "being opposed to sex-reassignment surgery" is not so much an opinion as it is an ideology. I suspect many safe spaces would be far more open to including people who subscribe to that ideology if those people entered those discussions with a willingness to learn, a desire to honestly explore the pros and cons of that surgery, and a desire to share their own experiences of gender while also learning about other experiences of gender. That is not any easy thing to do and it is especially difficult to do for cisgender people who have little knowledge of the emotional land mines they can trigger by simply relying on the "common sense" they have learned over a lifetime. If there is an honest desire to be included in these discussions, I would highly recommend taking the time to listen and learn before you start sharing your viewpoint so you can understand the effects that your words will have.
- sillysaurusx 7y agoIf you want to see what a Navy SEAL's life is like, I highly recommend this documentary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGvvNKBGgUw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGvvNKBGgUw "Documentary" makes it sound sterile or clinical, but in fact it's pretty badass. Kind of dispels the illusion that we're not pampered. It's so good I'll probably watch it again today. The diving section is the best, IMO. Imagine someone spinning you around underwater and ripping off parts of your dive gear then having to reassemble it basically blind. Imagine a junior code review that starts like this (https://youtu.be/AGvvNKBGgUw?t=230 https://youtu.be/AGvvNKBGgUw?t=230): "This entire codebase has been a joke. There hasn't been a single module that you've written during the course of this project that has even remotely resembled perfection. Everything has been sad, weak, and unreadable. And it's all because you're inside your tiny little brain, self-defeating yourself." Admittedly that only happens during the training phase, though.
- anon9001 7y agoThis kind of training seems like it would cause a lot of injuries. Is that just an accepted part of it?
- JshWright 7y agoSeems to be, yeah. Just about every SEAL I know suffered done sufficient (sometimes career ending) injury in training.
- staplor 7y agoYes, it is more likely for a serviceman to die in training than in combat.
- sillysaurusx 7y agoYes and no. It’s not acceptable to overlook safety. During the documentary, there are situations where you can see the instructors prioritize the well-being of the candidates (as opposed to saying “no, keep going”). One candidate complained he was feeling dizzy, and the instructor sent the candidate to get checked even though he personally felt there was nothing wrong with him. Wish I could remember the timestamp. There is also the concept of being rolled back due to injury. If you sprain your ankle, for example, you can’t keep going. It’s a persistent fear of all candidates, since it’s a big setback. But the flipside is that apparently you only get rolled back to when the next class catches up to where you’re at right now in training. It’s one of the cooler parts in my opinion, since you can see they truly value the candidates rather than thinking of them as disposable tools (which you occasionally feel like as a programmer...) But, ultimately, you’re correct: it’s inherently dangerous. Everyone signs up knowing the risks. EDIT: Found the timestamp: https://youtu.be/AGvvNKBGgUw?t=2266 https://youtu.be/AGvvNKBGgUw?t=2266
- jl2718 7y agoThe thing that hit me after coming back from the war, was how absolutely meaningless the vast majority of life’s required set of petty exercises are. I understand the elitism and the challenge of conquering Yale. There seems, however, to be a monumental difference between him and the rest; that is, 26 years of hardship, quiet observation, and directed action in shaping the world before reaching toward a philosophical understanding of it, versus young people desperately seeking that relevance for themselves, but only within the bounds of perfect physical and emotional comfort, perhaps not realizing that their pontifications are more limbic than neocortical. Downrange was my “safe space”; it gives a name to that limbic fear and drops a lot of emotional pretense otherwise. Stanford, not so much. What I found impressive there was the Sisyphean devotion to transforming ones mind into a perfect vessel of discovery, creation, and healing. I didn’t really respect it until I started to see that path as a superior way of being to my own, and made my best effort to commit to it despite the overwhelming disadvantage of time. Perhaps someday I too will see the same moral superiority in the screeds of elite youth in the humanities and social sciences. He was, after all, a far greater man in his first career than I ever will be.
- ganzuul 7y agoThe trouble with the term 'elitism' is that sometimes the best is only adequate, and for many people the best that society has to give is legitimately not enough. One lifetime of learning is not enough. Another one is in order. "We work in the dark - we do what we can - we give what we have. Our doubt is our passion, and our passion is our task. The rest is the madness of art." - Henry James
- sizzle 7y agoThanks for sharing that powerful quote.
- dang 7y agoIt sounds like you have a similar story—if I understand correctly, you went to Stanford as a veteran? If you'd be willing to share more, I think readers here would be interested.
- 7y ago
- sequoia 7y agoThis man's experience & his positive report of campus culture at an Ivy League school are heartening among all the distressing stories of ideological conformity on elite college campuses. It certainly is not all students at elite schools who are trying to shut down discussion, and claims that all students are doing that are surely exaggerated. Two things should be noted, however. First, that this is one person's account, not an examination of broader trends. For a broader, data-supported survey of anti-free-speech trends on campus and why it harms students, "The Coddling of the American Mind" is a fantastic and enlightening book. (Incidentally it cites causes from right & left wing extremists, on and off campus, it's not a story of "snowflakes bad".) Second, it's not necessary for authoritarian/illiberal activists to be in the majority in order to have a profound impact on the culture. "A small group of dedicated individuals" can affect great change even if they're in the extreme minority. If 1% of people on campus are willing to publicly condemn you and do everything they can to destroy your reputation or get you fired, and 4% are willing to go along with it, that can be enough to convince the the other 95% to keep their mouths shut. None of this is to take away from the fact that this is a refreshing narrative of unity, openness & cultural exchange in the Ivies.
- andreilys 7y agoNot sure why you're getting downvoted, everything you say is pretty much on the money. Nassim Taleb explores this exact concept in his essay titled "The Most Intolerant Wins: The Dictatorship of the Small Minority" https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dictatorship-of-the-small-minority-3f1f83ce4e15 https://medium.com/incerto/the-most-intolerant-wins-the-dict...
- exabrial 7y agoI loved every part of this. This is true leadership.
- ganzuul 7y agoHN is not a safe space by this definition.
- dang 7y agoHN is certainly not a safe space. No large anonymous internet community can be.
- ganzuul 7y agoIt annoys me. Smart people should be able to deal with subjects outside their comfort zone but what I see here is the intellectual version of footguns employed more as a rule than an exception. - People downvote things they don't understand. - It's crazy. They can't even stand up for their opinions but do it anonymously, like cowards.
- dang 7y agoI think there's a confusion here: Smart people should be able to deal with subjects outside their comfort zone "Smart" is a cognitive trait; dealing with what is outside one's comfort zone is a different developmental axis altogether. Smart people are no better able to do this than anyone else, and may even have a harder time.
- ganzuul 7y agoI see. I mean a different smart. General intelligence. It implies you learn the traits required to solve a hard problem. It's a habit of self-optimization.
- SolaceQuantum 7y agoI don't actually know if general intelligence is a thing the way you're describing it. There's no reason why an insanely smart algo PhD-from-MIT person could take their algo smarts and intuitively apply it to being a compassionate human being dealing with others whose existence and experiences may be drastically different from themselves for practically no feasible reason (fate/gods/random chance).
- Merrill 7y agoI hope we hear from him again as a Senior at Yale.
- m0zg 7y agoPrediction: out within a year, after saying something not 150% politically correct to those "open minded" students in their "safe space". Nowadays you can get fired for insisting that biological differences exist between men and women or suggesting that, perhaps, uncontrolled, illegal immigration is an undesirable phenomenon. A 52 year old veteran is not going to survive walking over that minefield for very long.
- oropolo 7y agoYou might be surprised how "civilized" military members can be. Among their own and blowing off steam they will say things that will make the hair curl on most people... and then if you look around at the others it's obvious it's not said out of malice but is a mark of The Brotherhood. They have not only pledged their lives to serve and protect their bothers in arms, they have, in many cases, made good on that promise. Saying massively politically incorrect things -- even things that would sound hateful to an outsider -- is a strange way of showing affection. "I might think you're a blankety-blank blah-blah politically incorrect and mentally inferior example of humanity but I will give my life on the battlefield so that you can make it home, even if I don't make it back myself." For those who have not gone through such an experience, no amount of explanation is possible; for those who have, no explanation is necessary. But around "normal people" you would never suspect what they've been through (with the exception of PTSD and obvious injuries).
- calderarrow 7y agoTangentially related anecdote: As an undergrad, I got to spend a semester in the ROTC capstone for second semester seniors called “Leadership and Ethics.” I remember walking in on my first day in cargo shorts and flip flops as the only civilian and non-senior student. Everyone else was in full uniform. The class was taught by a Marine Officer. As a business student, I realized how similar the military and business can be. Most of the theory of leadership and management aims to address a fundamental goal: how do you get people to do something they may not necessarily want to do. Whether that’s making widgets or killing someone, the underlying theories are quite similar. The main difference I noticed between the two fields was the military’s emphasis on trust. You were to respect a chain of command because you could trust your commanding officer. You were expected to perform your best because you could trust your teammates to do the same. The reason soldiers could rely on this trust was because their superiors had gone through the bullshit and could manage from a seat of positional and experiential authority. In the business world, they taught management as if having positional authority would automatically create trust and inspire subordinates. MBA students graduate and come into supervisory roles without any prior experience in the underlying work and get mixed results. Part of me wonders whether this is due to ineptitude or simply inexperience. I remember finishing that course and thinking I really should study engineering because I knew that wanted to play a role in managing and leading technical teams working on innovative problems. Fast forward a few years and I left my role in public accounting to go into industry, but instead of going into finance or internal accounting I chose to learn development and spend a few years experiencing what it’s like to be a developer, so that one day when I’m managing a technical team I can actually know when they’re giving me a legitimate justification for something, and when they’re just bullshitting me. Having been a developer for a couple years now, I don’t know how I could have managed a technical team without this experience. I think back to my “career plan” before I took that class and remember thinking that I’d not only be able to find a managerial position upon graduation, but that I’d be able to lead effectively as a 22 year old. What a foolish 20 year old I was! Anyway, this is really just a roundabout way of saying I loved my class and have tremendous respect for military leadership. I would have loved to have more classes with officers and veterans, and hope my kids get that opportunity someday.
- kev009 7y agoIf you have kids that want to do things in a pretty non-conformant way (with beautiful irony) I'd recommend taking a look at VMI and The Citadel, neither requires military service afterward (although it is an option and a good one to pay for the experience) yet you will be along side some of the best current and future military leaders as teachers, classmates, and friends for life. The Federal service academies are also well regarded but there's something a little bit more rough and tumble at these two that is precious and I say that with respect even as they two are rivals. To have you ass kicked every day, in every way imaginable (mentally, physically, athletically, motivational, trivially, lack of sleep and food, academically) while still doing a full course load is really a great start on adult life which can be just as hard and you are always prepared. I doubt the academics are anything like an ivy, just sharing another option that reminded me of the bridging of two worlds of physicality and academic pursuit.
- gjkhkldajghl 7y agoDid you go to either of those schools?
- kev009 7y agoYes, G Co 2011 at El Cid
- duelingjello 7y agoDon Shipley should check for this guy’s name in his database just to verify. Meeting a SEAL is like getting struck by lightning because there are so many phonies out there stealing valor. I hope it’s not the case.
- wetmore 7y agoIt's not hard to find more info about the guy, just Google his name.