3 ms·
It’s funny how people treats unions as panaceas to all problems. It’s strange to present them as some sort of solution in this case, where there was widespread
by dmix 7y ago
It’s funny how people treats unions as panaceas to all problems.
It’s strange to present them as some sort of solution in this case, where there was widespread engineering and management cultural
issues, and would therefore somehow have prevented major air disasters.
Workers rights and forcing higher wages might be great for the working poor and it might actually make economic sense in certain niche industries where protectionism can prevent the companies entire business being eaten by Chinese/global ones without the myriad of rules and restrictions that unions being - rules that go well, well beyond wages. But it is not some grand solution to high level engineering problems caused by stupid cost saving priorities made by C-class executives and other weakness in quality down the line.
Further, non-union companies are more often the default these days, and tons of these companies are producing high quality American engineering and manufacturing products.
Even in the romanticized history of US labor only a minority of working Americans were ever in unions even during the hayday when it actually made sense to have unions (when America had tons of factories and manufacturing but little global competition and plenty of protectionism to artificially keep them alive).
- jacquesm 7y agoUnions still make sense today. Without them labor conditions would likely go down quickly. There is plenty wrong with unions but to dispel the need for them without giving careful thought to their good sides is throwing out the baby with the bathwater.
- dmix 7y agoThere are a lot of good unions can do but I think they went way too far in their demands over the decades of their existence (like making it super hard to fire delinquent workers and hyper specialization where one guy does one job, and refuses to wear multiple hats like any modern business requires, because his union requires him only to do that one job). It’s not like unions are bad or evil, this sort of scope creep and beaurucratic self destruction is common in countless organizations. If unions were reformed, or we could get some form of union-lite where it really was just about wages and sane working hours/conditions then I’d be much more in support of them. It’s just the disconnect between what it sounds like on paper (great for the working poor!) and what they actually do in practice with the myriad of negative side effects which heavily contributed to massive inefficiencies and making America (and other countries) less competitive... it’s just difficult to square the two.
- frenchyatwork 7y agoI've never worked with a union, but it seems a little bizarre to me how people seem to treat unions with the same sort of helplessness as the democratically elected lizards of the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. If a union really gets that bad, vote them out, or replace them with another union. That these unions stick around suggests to me that people like them more than they're willing to admit.
- jacquesm 7y agoThat's not the reason why they continue to exist. They continue to exist because if they didn't the whole thing would slide backwards in a hurry and then we'd have to start all over again. I've seen a lot of union based excesses and there are tons of horror stories. With all those taken into account the situation is still far to be preferred over what you'd get without unions. Witness the kind of pushback IT companies give against unionization and you have to wonder what they're so afraid of, a level playing field definitely benefits the employees and collective bargaining rights is one of the greater goods to come out of the 20th century. You will lose that at your peril. In a way the whole gig-economy is trying to do an end-run around any kind of social safety net, and looked at from that angle it will likely end bad to very bad for the participants, even if from their present day perspective it looks like a great deal.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ThrowawayR2 7y agoSo if unions want to be more attractive, why are they not actively trying to fix their problems?
- lhopki01 7y agoJust curious how you'd explain Germany and the high levels of unions in the export industries there? You can hardly say that there is little global competition or high levels of protectionism for them.
- dmix 7y agoIf there was ever a work culture that wouldn’t give in to the various temptations of inefficiencies and stupidities which unions offer you without consequence it’s the Germans. They’ll work their ass off regardless if some piece of paper says they don’t really have to and if they don’t their peers will look down on them. I highly recommend this video to highlight the cultural differences between the UK vs Germany (particularly the bit about using Facebook at work), which I think do matter a lot in these conversations: https://youtu.be/mSQKtxJ-Uvk https://youtu.be/mSQKtxJ-Uvk I also think Americans are worse for challenging authority than the UK culture highlighted in that show clip.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> It’s funny how people treats unions as panaceas to all problems. > But it is not some grand solution to high level engineering problems caused by stupid cost saving priorities made by C-class executives and other weakness in quality down the line. They're not a panacea to all problems, but they could be the solution or part of a solution to many of them. In this case the "stupid cost saving priorities made by C-class executives" were the major issue, and how do you deal with that? You increase the power of other, non-management stakeholders. Unions are the way you do that for labor. Of course, in this case they're not the complete solution. Increased and more effective oversight by the FAA is probably more important, and there are other things as well. However, unions could be helpful by protecting employees who want to make a fuss over management decisions from management reprisal, for instance.
- dmix 7y ago> In this case the "stupid cost saving priorities made by C-class executives" were the major issue, and how do you deal with that? You increase the power of other, non-management stakeholders. Unions are the way you do that for labor. This to me sounds like that old regex joke, now you have two problems.