2 ms·
The British Government hasn't had a good experience with writing criminal laws to stop people saying things it didn't agree with in the past. It turns out that
by tialaramex 7y ago
The British Government hasn't had a good experience with writing criminal laws to stop people saying things it didn't agree with in the past. It turns out that people are OK with your broad generalities, but the thing about criminal law is that it rests on specifics. Justice in one particular case before the courts, not an army of hypothetical "What if?" questions.
Lady Chatterley's Lover in 1960 was an example. The Government had just written a law (in 1959) clearly saying you mustn't publish obscene stuff. As a generality this seemed very supportable. In the specifics it struggled, was this novel obscene merely because it was about fucking? Because it used words that would be familiar to readers, such as "fuck" and "cunt" precisely because they were words about fucking? The government made its case but jurors concluded the publisher was not guilty. If obscenity meant anything, it apparently did not include literature about fucking. The government gave up and no similar trials were conducted.
The thing about End-to-end encryption is that you can't see inside. So your test case ends up being we weren't able to see inside this message, we want to know what's inside it. And in the course of the trial the jury are likely to discover that either the contents of the message were in fact mundane and uninteresting or that nobody in fact can prove beyond a reasonable doubt what they were anyway, whereupon all the exciting stories about terrorists or shadowy figures preying on children evaporates and the question is just: Is it right that the government wants to pry into everything you do? And a jury is going to say "No".
The idea of an independent judiciary sounded good in the UK, and so they actually built one‡, but they didn't get the memo from America that the independence is supposed to be a thin pretence - so the judiciary actually is independent and they can't trivially unwind that (though leaving the EU will mean at least nobody can tell them not to try any more).
‡ For many years the courts of England & Wales were independent from the British Government but they didn't look it because the ultimate court of appeal actually worked out of the Palace of Westminster where the Parliament is, and its judges were technically "Lords" in the Parliament, so it _looked_ superficially as though there was no separation. All the actual independence was a matter of convention rather than being visible. This appearance was fixed by giving them a new name (the "Supreme Court") and a Supreme Court building, a short distance away from the Palace so now they look as independent as they actually were anyway.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI think your distinction between generalities and specifics is an insightful one. I have not realised previously that this is a good reason why some laws never enter reality.