3 ms·
Interesting examples. Monopolies are usually considered to exist with respect to a particular market. It doesn’t have to be a global monopoly to count, particul
by simonh 7y ago
Interesting examples. Monopolies are usually considered to exist with respect to a particular market. It doesn’t have to be a global monopoly to count, particularly with respect to a particular regulating authority. For example Amazon’s share of the Chinese book market is of no concern to the US regulators. But similarly Amazon might have a monopoly in certain types of books and not others.
In your example of the mine, a regulator would have to consider the degree to which the mine and it’s supplier are or aren’t integrated into the overall market. It’s not a one size fits all question. The free marketeer answer is to this their hands up in the face of such complexity and say let the market decide. But then it’s back to cartels and sub standard goods. The balanced approach is messy though and there are difficult edge cases, but someone has to bite the bullet, IMHO.
- kortilla 7y agoBut what is a regulator to do in that situation? Dictate prices for the seller to keep the mine open? Who does that really help if it’s preventing the nash dealer from selling it someone who is willing to pay more for it? This suddenly puts the regulator in position of keeping the mine open under the auspices of a central planning committee, which is not an easy position to defend. Both the mine and the nash seller are operating in global markets. But this is an industry (like most heavy industry) where location and transportation connectivity can make or break a deal due to the volumes being talked about.
- simonh 7y agoOh absolutely, the specifics will matter, that’s why I say it’s not one size fits all. By itself charging what the market will bear can’t be enough, and the rules have to be clear so rulings aren’t arbitrary and participants can reasonably avoid infringement.