2 ms·
There aren't really many "performance critical" multithreaded environments in the world. For the most part you either have something that doesn't scale and need
by zamadatix 7y ago
There aren't really many "performance critical" multithreaded environments in the world. For the most part you either have something that doesn't scale and needs a really fast thread or you have a cost equation about how many servers you need to buy/maintain. The main exception that comes to mind are extremely large databases that heavily resist horizontal scaling due to poor design (of either software or database).
I'd argue most large compute by total $ is actually shared at the host level i.e. public/private cloud or user devices. Basically the only things that aren't are dedicated clusters for specific applications and a few hundred supercomputers while AWS alone has over 100x as many cores as the largest supercomputer.
Also I don't think there is a high horse to be on about an article not targeting the audience of the largest exacompute scale clusters, not everyone/everything at HN need be at the forefront of the field to avoid being flagged.
- chaps 7y agoEr, there aren't many performance critical multithreaded environments? Latency sensitive systems disagree, and those are all over the place.
- zamadatix 7y agoCan you give examples of something that scales via threading but requires in a single thread the function takes 500 microseconds instead of 600 microseconds to compute that actually contradicts that "most" systems aren't this way?
- jcelerier 7y agoMost professionnal audio software is like that - you can have e.g. a thread per track to make it simple but you also have to ensure that each execution cycle does not take more than 1 millisecond else you get audio glitches. And there is no limit to how hard you have to improve - this is a central factor for people buying your software (see dawbench) and artists really really don't like limits - they will always try to add more effects, etc etc on each track.
- zamadatix 7y agoAgreed but I'd hardly call pure software professional real time audio setups a disruptor of the vast majority of systems. Put all of these niche compute heavy multithreaded real time use cases and you have <1% the CPU market. I.e. my claim was "There aren't really many 'performance critical' multithreaded environments in the world." not that there aren't any.
- jcelerier 7y ago> Agreed but I'd hardly call pure software professional real time audio setups a disruptor of the vast majority of systems. I mean, there's still a few hundred thousand people registered on DAW-related forums so certainly a fair bit more are using those. That is more than a dozen european countries. Sure, it's not angry birds but I do not think that it is relevant to cater to the lowest common denominator of software.
- tomc1985 7y agoThere are lots of performance-critical environments out there in the embedded world... why else would VxWorks be so popular?
- zamadatix 7y agoUnless you're implying there are a lot of embedded machines running VxWorks on overclocked i9 9900K's because they needed the single core throughput I think we are talking about completely different concepts.