8 ms·
It seems fashionable these days to redefine terms to suit an agenda. I think that this should be pushed back against. The term 'monopoly' is clear and well-def
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
It seems fashionable these days to redefine terms to suit an agenda. I think that this should be pushed back against.
The term 'monopoly' is clear and well-defined.
If Amazon is not a monopoly "in the traditional sense of the word" then the correct term should be used to qualify what Amazon is instead of trying to redefine the word in order to be able to label Amazon with it.
- nicoburns 7y agoIndeed. And what is weirder is that there seems to be an attitude that if it's not a monopoly then it must be fine and should be allowed.
- nabla9 7y agoMonopoly is used as a generic term to discuss everything under antitrust and competition law with layman, because people don't know what monopoly power, market power, barriers to entry or exit, restraint of trade, price discrimination, market failures etc. mean. Everyone knows what pure monopoly is. This creates problems if people take it too literally.
- dahfizz 7y agoYeah, that's the whole problem. "Monopoly" has become a generic and unspecific term, but it's still very politically significant. So laypeople cry for X company to be regulated "because they're a monopoly" without having to have any sort of actual objective backing. The point OP is making, and you seem to agree with him, is that we shouldn't overload the terms. "Monopoly" is a very specific enconomic term, a political term, and a subjective layterm used to portray large companies negatively. Bundling all those meanings together creates miscommunications.
- nabla9 7y agoMy point is that just because word "monopoly" is used as a shorthand for more accurate term "monopoly power" it don't make calls for regulation any less important.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]