4 ms·
It seriously depends on the technology being used. There isn't any evidence from human psychology that dark-skinned people have harder-to-recognize faces, so we
by shadowgovt 7y ago
It seriously depends on the technology being used. There isn't any evidence from human psychology that dark-skinned people have harder-to-recognize faces, so we're probably just using the wrong approach in the technology currently available.
- formercoder 7y agoGreat point, I don’t know how much our brain uses, for example, depth information in facial recognition.
- jlawson 7y agoEyes are just better at distinguishing similar dark colors against each other compared to cameras. Only the most expensive, massive and heavy cameras (costing hundreds of thousands of dollars, generally) can compete with eyes in this respect. Plus human facial recognition is massively overpowered for normal cases. I think if you tested it in challenge cases (through blurry video, or snow, or in the dark, or at a distance), you might see darker skin tones being recognized less easily. It'd be an interesting experiment.
- shadowgovt 7y agoThat might very well be true, but if it is, then it re-enforces the point: the technology may not be where it needs to be yet, and if it isn't, the tool probably shouldn't be deployed in public use cases where the end-result could be inherently discriminatory by race.
- aaron695 7y ago>There isn't any evidence from human psychology that dark-skinned people have harder-to-recognize faces Citation? Dark cars have more accidents- https://www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring/news/7845366/Black-cars-more-likely-to-be-involved-in-crashes.html https://www.telegraph.co.uk/motoring/news/7845366/Black-cars... There clearly will be a difference. Whole careers are around making things more or less recognizable depending on color. What study makes you think it's insignificant for human faces?
- shadowgovt 7y agoWhat study makes you think it is significant for human faces? I'm noting absence of evidence; if you're making the point that it doesn't imply evidence of absence, I agree, but I've also never heard anyone seriously claim "black people's faces are just harder to recognize." The anecdotal claim isn't even present. The linked study on cars is analogous at best, but doesn't prove anything for human facial recognition. Cars on highways and human beings in various settings are extremely different circumstances.
- SiVal 7y agoPart of the technology is the capturing of photons, fewer of which bounce off dark skin than light skin, so it is in part the same generic problem as always: fewer photons, less data, worse images. Whether it's day vs. night, fast lens vs. slow, close vs. distant, fast moving vs slow (requiring fast shutter than lets in less light), or whatever causes it, fewer photons mean more problems. And even if you get enough photons to, for example, recognize both black and white equally well in daylight, you might not at night or in a deep shadow indoors, or up close equally well but there will be some distance at which the advantage of more photons begins to matter, or some speed, or some combination of factors. Any technological improvements will help, but there won't be any technological solution that will always work equally well with fewer photons as with more.
- ummonk 7y agoCameras don't have the same dynamic range as human eyes.
- ailideex 7y agoMaybe there is some transitive effect from racially biased cameras.
- notauser 7y agoThe very best HDR cameras have roughly the same dynamic ranges as the human eye. You can't display all of this range to people because of the limitations of display technology, but you can feed the full range to a facial recognition engine. Security budgets might not stretch to top-end HDR equipment but the price keeps on coming down. The performance of a modern flagship phone is remarkable compared to a few years ago - and fixed surveillance cameras can have much bigger glass and sensors, making it cheaper to get super-human performance. One new but related issue is that body-worn cameras can capture more low-light detail than the human eye. Police unions have argued against deploying these sensors, because, they want the evidential record to show what the officer could see - not what a cat could see.
- randomcarbloke 7y agoMost digital cameras have a dynamic range well in excess of the human eye.
- etaioinshrdlu 7y agoLess reflected light, all else being equal, means the same amount of detected noise (whether using cameras or eyes), and therefore a worse signal to noise ratio on the dark image. Worse signal to noise ratio means less information. Less information indicates worse detection accuracy. While there isn't evidence that dark-skinned people have harder-to-recognize faces, there is also no evidence to the contrary. It seems like the null hypothesis in this case, given no additional evidence, is to assume that darker images are indeed harder to recognize.