6 ms·
I think if we ever see an alien, he will either fly to us in a completely enormous nuclear rocket which we will spot years before his arrival and deceleration.
by baybal2 7y ago
I think if we ever see an alien, he will either fly to us in a completely enormous nuclear rocket which we will spot years before his arrival and deceleration. This is in the case if there is really no other way to traverse stars besides conventional rocketry.
But in case if there is a way to trick any of the fundamental physics we know after all, then very likely the guy will come right at our porch, and they've probably done so many times without us even noticing, and will only contact us, if ever, on their own terms.
Given the premise is right, and somebody can really do something on the level of fundamental physical force manipulation for space travel, then there would be no reason for them to not dispense with conventional space travel altogether, or at least to a reasonable extent where this technology is more practical than giant nuclear rockets.
And the same goes for things like stealth technology, or inertia control. If somebody can arbitrary manipulate gravity, entropy, or fundamental forces to travel stars, or make traversable wormholes, then inertia cancelation, invisibility by directly manipulating light, undetectable radio comms, and power sources unlimited or almost so by heatsink capacity should be child's play for them too.
- wonderwonder 7y agoThis assumes they are not coming from some giant station on the other side of our sun, parked there for the last several hundred years. They could also be anywhere in our solar system, that our technology is not advanced enough to detect. We cant really keep track of all the space rocks floating near us and they aren't trying not to be seen.
- ianai 7y agoHow about they’re from a birth of life somewhere nearby but hard for us to detect - like oceans below the surface of Enceladus?
- wonderwonder 7y agoI think that makes sense too, we are still finding out basic things about the moons of Jupiter and Saturn. Space wise we are really just getting started.
- lolc 7y agoThat would be really weird for them to be hiding from us behind the sun. What's in it for them? They arrive in Sol to set up a base but the carbon-based predators on the wet planet must not be disturbed. Why should they care about us in that specific way? That tale sounds a lot like typical human hubris to me.
- mrfusion 7y agoWe hide to observe animals all the time.
- lolc 7y agoMost of the time we don't.
- dylan604 7y agoWe also install remote/un-manned viewing platforms all the time. They sometimes require us to revisit them periodically to collect the data and load fresh media/power/etc. Then we upgraded them to use solar to replenish power, and installed wireless communications to make it so we don't have to visit. Maybe we just need to start listening for rogue broadcasts from our planet for these ET-phone-home devices?
- wonderwonder 7y agoWhy do we have rules about disturbing the tribes in the amazon or the Sentinelese. Maybe there are established rules about contacting primitive cultures? Maybe they are just watching for the Fermi Paradox to take care of us.
- ojosilva 7y agoWe tend to try to predict alien behavior basing it more or less on our own, 10000 year-long history. If intelligent life that travels the billion-old stars actually exists, I doubt we would be able to put their intentions and modus operandi into words with our constrained ideas and limited, lonely planet vocabulary.
- baddox 7y agoI suspect that space probes like STEREO would have been able to see a giant space station on the other side of the Sun, but they might not have been looking.
- PhasmaFelis 7y agoIf they're using any technology that we know to be feasible (and they haven't already been here for a century or more), their approach would involve a star-hot plume of nuclear flame that burns in the sky for weeks or months at least. Now, as Baybal said, if they've uncovered fundamental physics that we don't know about, all bets are off. Or they could have showed up centuries ago and been hanging around ever since, for all we know, recorded by history as a supernova or something. But if they arrived recently and use known physics, we most likely would have seen them.
- gregable 7y agoIs that even necessary? If they sit far enough out, are sufficiently small, and are not broadcasting radio, I doubt we'd notice them.
- okonomiyaki3000 7y agoBut why would they have come here hundreds of years ago? They'd have had to leave their planet hundreds (if not thousands) of years before that. Meanwhile, Seinfeld hasn't even reached them yet. What did they find so interesting about our system so many years ago that they would expend the time and energy for such a project? Who is paying for this?
- wonderwonder 7y agoMaybe they are simply observing the experiment they started 4 billion years ago.
- nkrisc 7y agoIf they're hiding from us on the other side of the sun, then that means they're probably on the same orbit as the Earth, but a full half orbit ahead. But then you'd think spacecraft like the Parker Solar Probe which has a perihelion of only 0.04 AU and a very eccentric orbit would be able to spot it. Hiding on the other side of the sun only hides them from direct observation from exactly Earth. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parker_Solar_Probe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parker_Solar_Probe
- krapp 7y agoWouldn't the same gravitational lensing that proved relativity also possibly reveal something hidden behind the sun, if it were massive enough?
- cellular 7y agoHmm, it seems like we could see behind our sun with our space probes
- preommr 7y agoTrying to apply logic to a conspiracy theory is usually a pointless endeavor.
- OrgNet 7y ago> I think if we ever see an alien, he will either fly to us in a completely enormous nuclear rocket which we will spot years before his arrival and deceleration. I think that they will teleport here and be minuscule and invisible (at first).
- baybal2 7y agoThat's the point. If you will ever see a martian on your porch, and you haven't seem a giant nuclear rocket on which he came here, it will be the most direct proof that we missed something really big in our physics theories, something on the level of 5th force, existence of negative mass, or quantum gravity being a thing.
- krapp 7y agoOr magic. At that point, if our physics models are that wrong, you might as well say a wizard could have done it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- narag 7y agoAnd the same goes for things like stealth technology, or inertia control. We have stealth techonology, don't we? Inertia control is not needed if you can create a field. The problem with acceleration is that it needs to be transmited from the engine to the human body. That happens through the seat in planes or rockets. But if you were able to create a field that uniformly affected all the molecules of everything into the ship, including human bodies, you could perform sudden turns without crushing the crew.
- Recurecur 7y agoSo, positing the video is authentic, which seems likely, here's what we know: - This object, estimated to be 40 feet in largest dimension, exhibited flight performance beyond an F-18 - These objects exhibit long flight endurance, indicating a high density power source - The object was solid, as it was detected by the Aegis radar - According to the pilot involved, the object did not obey the laws of physics as we know them - The object flew without visible airfoils - no wings or rotor - and at low speeds including a hover - The object allegedly hovered as low as fifty feet above the water, although I don't think this was caught on video - The object departed the scene in a way the F-18 couldn't match - The object changed orientation without apparent regard for direction of flight - The video clearly shows some kind of nimbus, exhaust, or field around the object If this is a classified project of some government, they've likely discovered new physics. Personally I doubt that's the case, and these are the product of extraterrestrials. (BTW, to the grandparent - there's a lot that's not understood by current physics. Dark energy, and dark matter, for starters. A new baryon may have been discovered recently. Quantum gravity. Much more I'm sure...)
- hirundo 7y agoBefore we diagnose unicorns, why couldn't it have been a drone with cowling around its propellers/impellers, forced to be 40 foot long in order to carry an advanced miniaturized submarine fission reactor. That could give it range and enough acceleration to make it seem to defy physics.
- 7y ago
- TearsInTheRain 7y ago>I think if we ever see an alien, he will either fly to us in a completely enormous nuclear rocket which we will spot years before his arrival and deceleration . We have a tough time detecting asteroids until they've already flown by, I have a hard time believing we would spot a ship years in advance
- xenophonf 7y agoThe drive plume will be bright and hot and aimed right at us. Somebody running an all-sky radio survey will spot it, eventually. It will take a long time to decelerate, years if not decades even if it's only cruising at a small fraction of c. (Project Daedalus would have cruised at 0.12 c.)
- IG_Semmelweiss 7y agoIndeed, but take umbrage that no matter their level of technological sophistication, any race visiting us ij this manner would not only be very advanved, but also could not be hostile without violating or contradicting laws of the expanding universe, economics, and physics.