5 ms·
The article is light (and confusing) on details, so it's hard to take it seriously or draw conclusions from it. For example: "State-chartered banks like his ha
by rahimnathwani 7y ago
The article is light (and confusing) on details, so it's hard to take it seriously or draw conclusions from it. For example:
"State-chartered banks like his have the regulatory and compliance framework in place and the lending licenses necessary to originate loans. Most fintechs do not and thus rely on banks for funding."
If the fintechs have a lack of cash money then they might need to rely on banks for funding. But there's no reason a lack of licences or processes would require them to rely on banks for funding.
Also, I'm not sure why the need to mention 'FDIC-insured' a couple of times. FDIC insurance has nothing to do with consumer lending (the subject of this article). FDIC insurance protects retail deposits, but these fintechs aren't generally offering current/savings accounts.
I wish the article would explain why it's difficult to become a lender in the US. It mentions LendingClub many times, but a quick online search showed me that LC has dozens of state consumer credit licences: https://www.lendingclub.com/legal/licenses https://www.lendingclub.com/legal/licenses
So why don't the other fintechs apply for these licences? Is it hard to be approved? Are the regulations very difficult to implement?
- rolltiide 7y agoThe FDIC is a confidence game. Mentioning it just gives a reminder of its existence and confidence in the system. I just like to imagine the enterprisers in 1930 that convinced Congress to insure their private company deposits with public money in order to more easily convince people to make deposits. Worried about the viability of a new market because there is no recourse if you lose your money? Make enough money to lobby Congress to insure it with non-participant's money! Now there is more confidence in your market
- rahimnathwani 7y agoFDIC insurance, and similar deposit guarantee schemes in other countries, aren't primarily a way to socialise private risks. A bank run is caused by the perception that a bank may have insufficient liquidity. But once a bank run starts, this is a self-fulfilling prophecy. The bank may have held enough of its assets as cash/near-cash for normal times, but of course many of its assets are illiquid things like mortgage loans. The main purpose of deposit guarantee/insurance schemes is to prevent this vicious cycle from starting in the first place. If the scheme succeeds in instilling confidence, then there will never be a run, and the scheme will never result in a costly bail-out.
- rossdavidh 7y agoJust to reinforce one point: the bank in question could even have MORE of a cushion than other banks, but if the rumor mill hits them instead of other banks, they are the one who goes under. So, it's not even a case of rough justice from the market, it's death by rumor mill. Of all the stupid laws and regulations regarding finance, this is not one of them.
- cromwellian 7y agoThe FDIC isn’t public money and there is no congressional appropriation for it. FDIC is funded by bank premiums. Sure if the FDIC goes bust in a massive financial implosion the feds will backstop it, but in such a disaster almost no private orgs have the resources to backstop it. This sounds like an uninformed libertarian rant.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- xivzgrev 7y agoI used to work for a fintech like LendingClub. First you absolutely need a license. You can’t just go making consumer loans without the proper license to do so. If that wasn’t the case there would be rampant abuse / predatory schemes as there was before. The problem is not getting a license so to speak, the problem is that it’s not worth it. Not only do you need to get 50 of them and follow a cluster-fuck of 50 different state laws, you need to follow the ongoing compliance procedures of all 50 state to maintain said licenses. Why would any sane company do that if there is a bank that has already done that, and willing to lend in your name, if they get a little piece of the action? Your whole value prop is in marketing and underwriting, not legal compliance. So outsource that shit and focus your resources on what is going to differentiate you. So what you see is that lendingclub tried to get their own licenses, realized it was fucking stupid for above reasons, and then outsourced it. They still have the licenses to either keep servicing some existing loans or perhaps for some other business reason (eg perhaps a particular kind of product is actually easier to license themselves than thru third party for a particular state), but that’s definitely less common than outsourcing.
- rahimnathwani 7y agoThat's interesting. I co-founded a consumer loan business in the UK back when Consumer Credit Licences were administered by the Office of Fair Trading. The regulations seemed reasonable and not overly-onerous. But I can understand that, even if the corresponding regulations in the US are no more complex than those in the UK, having to register with and deal with 50 different regulators might be 10x or 20x the effort of dealing with just one regulator.