6 ms·
> I actually stopped using apps which went from paid to subscription, like Ulysses and Gemini. In some cases, doing so actually helped me find better, free alte
by masklinn 7y ago
> I actually stopped using apps which went from paid to subscription, like Ulysses and Gemini. In some cases, doing so actually helped me find better, free alternatives that I can theoretically count on practically forever.
Seems to me "I don't pay for it at all" would be the exact opposite of "count on practically forever".
> If vastly more complex products of Pixelmator/Affinity's quality can remain on a pay-once model
Unless they can keep expanding their userbase forever, they can't and don't over the long term (though a relatively high initial price helps there).
Historically this sort of software has relied on "major version" sales to keep revenue flowing e.g. you'd buy version 2, then would buy version 3 for a reduced price, there would be churn (and buying version 2 would entitle you to using it forever) but there's a point at which continuous work requires continuous pay.
Many software houses have switched to subscriptions not because that's fun, but because upgrade pricing was not an option (AFAIK it's available from neither Apple nor Google) and "pay once" is not a sustainable model.
> An optional yearly upgrade model (a major version jump) is also fine.
That's a good model, but AFAIK no appstore caters to it. You can do either subscriptions or "only get money once", the latter only works for software which is essentially not maintained like video games (and even that's not really the case anymore).
- servercobra 7y agoApple does support upgrade pricing, though mostly as a hack using App Bundles and the Complete My Bundle pricing. For example, upgrading GoodNotes: https://support.goodnotes.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000124915-I-have-already-paid-for-GoodNotes-4-How-can-I-download-GoodNotes-5-for-free- https://support.goodnotes.com/hc/en-us/articles/360000124915...
- masklinn 7y agoBundles are an interesting hack around store limitations. When did apple implement bundles?
- Razengan 7y agoYou keep saying "hack" when all these are advertised, publicized, and officially supported features of the App Store. They literally touted them at various WWDCs.
- masklinn 7y ago> You keep saying "hack" when all these are advertised, publicized, and officially supported features of the App Store. As the proper and official way to implement upgrade pricing?
- servercobra 7y agoI saw them touted as ways to bundle apps together under one price, but never heard anything about using it for version upgrades. But I may have missed that, I've never been to WWDC just watched keynotes and some of the dev talks.
- Razengan 7y ago> there's a point at which continuous work requires continuous pay. The majority of software has been pay-once (not counting major version upgrades) throughout the history of software, and still is. I just mentioned some major examples: Pixelmator and Affinity, along with Astropad, CrossOver, DaisyDisk, Duet, Final Cut, Motion, Path Finder, Pixen, SiteSucker, Textual, Unarchiver, to name a few from my Applications folder, and also the vast majority of games. > That's a good model, but AFAIK no appstore caters to it. Acorn 4: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-4-the-image-editor-for-humans/id634108295?mt=12 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-4-the-image-editor-for-h... Acorn 5: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-5-the-image-editor-for-humans/id1019272813?mt=12 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-5-the-image-editor-for-h... Acorn 6: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-6-image-editor/id1233861775?mt=12 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-6-image-editor/id1233861... You may not be able to view the product pages for Acorn 4 & 5, but they show up in my purchase history and I can still redownload them. There are other examples like that. If a company chooses to keep its older versions on display they could.
- masklinn 7y ago> The majority of software has been pay-once No. > (not counting major version upgrades) That's very much a different model. You can't "not count" major version upgrades because that's how you make "pay once" actually work. > Acorn 4: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-4-the-image-editor-for-h.. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-4-the-image-editor-for-h.... > Acorn 5: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-5-the-image-editor-for-h.. https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-5-the-image-editor-for-h.... > Acorn 6: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-6-image-editor/id1233861… https://apps.apple.com/us/app/acorn-6-image-editor/id1233861... That's a hack, which I mentioned in an other comment: the appstore has no support for this model, so you have to release each major version as completely separate software with loss of history, reviews, links, … and you can't do upgrade pricing.
- Razengan 7y ago> No. Yes. > You can't "not count" major version upgrades because that's how you make "pay once" actually work. Pixelmator. Affinity. Again. Also Panic. Final Cut. Motion. Logic. SiteSucker. Unarchiver. I paid literally once for them years ago and they're still getting substantial updates and I'm still getting the latest version on every machine, without having to do anything except sign into my App Store account. Panic even let you receive updates for Coda after they took it off the App Store! The majority of apps I use are pay-once. The majority of games I play are pay-once. The next most common model is yearly-upgrade (Parallels, CrossOver, Path Finder) or sequel/expansion, but even they do not prevent me from using their older versions if I choose to (system compatibility notwithstanding.) > That's a hack, which I mentioned in an other comment: the appstore has no support for this model Yet they are all there on the App Store. I have been using Acorn for years and I was able to choose when to upgrade and I always did. I can still access the older versions; the App Store itself shows them to me in my history. They can still publish the older versions if they wanted to. > loss of history, reviews, links New reviews for a new version is how it has always worked for all apps on the App Store, and how it should be, considering how updates sometimes piss users off. Keeping the same history/ratings/reviews across all versions is vulnerable to baits-and-switches. As for links, again taking Acorn as an example, whenever a new version was available, the older versions mentioned it in an alert and on their product pages.
- chooseaname 7y ago> Unless they can keep expanding their userbase forever, they can't and don't over the long term (though a relatively high initial price helps there). And that's okay. People who bought the software can keep using it and we don't have companies that are forever old hanging onto the market "just because that's what people buy".