5 ms·
Well, the cookie popups have helped me become more selective in my browsing. If they don't make it reasonably easy to opt out, I just don't open the site. But
by nottorp 7y ago
Well, the cookie popups have helped me become more selective in my browsing. If they don't make it reasonably easy to opt out, I just don't open the site.
But the real benefit is this:
Some random online store that i bought something from once decided to send me a spam sms around black friday.
One email and 24 hours later, all the data they had about me was deleted.
Of course, this only works if you're in europe buying from an european store so they're subject to fines from some trigger happy privacy authority.
Assholes like Google still do not ask for consent. Guessing someone at the EU is working on gathering a mountain of documentation so they can fine them that famous 4%.
- dijit 7y agoThe cookie pop ups were a thing before, I guess being able to opt-out is a neat feature but there are certainly companies who do not comply when you choose to opt-out. (Looking at you Verizon, yes I know it’s you behind “oath”.)
- nottorp 7y agoIf i see the "oath" message when following a link, i close the browser tab :)
- oneplane 7y agoSame here, it's like they don't even bother getting their systems up to date.
- PeterisP 7y agoAny opt-out popups anyway aren't caused by GDPR anyway, as consent is 'GDPR-kosher' only if it's explicitly opt-in. If I take no action, accept the default conditions and don't opt out of anything, then that must be interpreted as me not granting permission to anything - there are a bunch of data use-cases that you're allowed to do without my consent, so you don't need the popups for that, but otherwise no informed explicit affirmative action means no consent.
- nottorp 7y agoThat's how it should work, but in practice most popups are opt out. I've seen only one type of cookie popup that comes with default opt in, and even that one has a very proeminent 'opt in to all and save' button and a slightly harder to find 'just save' button that will actually allow the opt out to stay.
- lucb1e 7y agoI find it interesting how Google still does this on sites like blogger. I ignore the banner covering 80% of my mobile screen and read the article but agree to nothing. They'll probably still process my data despite me not agreeing to it, and when the day comes, someone will sue them, an investigation will be held, and a large fine will be collected. What I find strange is that google's army of lawyers doesn't seem worried about this.
- lucb1e 7y agoA few notes: > One email and 24 hours later, all the data they had about me was deleted. You make it sound as if this is new, but this was also possible under the DPD from the late 90s. GDPR didn't improve that. (What helped is that GDPR isn't from the late 90s but was introduced in a year where privacy was already a hot topic, so it was picked up by the media and now companies actually know about it so you don't have to point out the law before they understand what you're talking about when you do an access/deletion request. But it technically hasn't changed.) > this only works if you're in europe buying from an european store Sort of. While the EU claims it applies to anyone, the Chinese government isn't going to give a rat's ass if you sue and win a court case against a Chinese company. However, if that Chinese company has assets in the EU, they can be seized, not to mention that they can probably be banned from the EU market altogether. Anyone who wishes to continue selling to Europeans and not have any European assets seized would do well to comply with European law, also if their headquarters / choice of court / assets is/are outside the EU.
- m11a 7y ago> You make it sound as if this is new, but this was also possible under the DPD from the late 90s. GDPR didn't improve that. GDPR did improve it. Under the implementation by member states of the DPD many required that you can show "duress and/or distress" from continued processing to request erasure. GDPR made it so you don't have to show anything, you can just request it (or, more technically, you can withdraw consent). And the DPD only said: > as appropriate the rectification, erasure or blocking of data the processing of which does not comply with the provisions of this Directive, in particular because of the incomplete or inaccurate nature of the data; Organisations often took a very conservative interpretation of this which wasn't enforced differently by many DPAs in EU states. GDPR Art. 17 is definitely stronger.
- m11a 7y ago> Assholes like Google still do not ask for consent. Google do ask for consent where required, but consent isn't required. There's various legal bases for the processing of data according to the GDPR (including for the performance of a contract and for legitimate business interests). Google just invested more in lawyers to use the GDPR strategically so they would have to change as little of their processes as possible. Companies that don't understand the GDPR or privacy spent a fortune on consultants that milked them for money. Such companies seem to think the GDPR is a doomsday weapon and a revolution. It really isn't.