3 ms·
Distinctions between Germany under Hitler, Russia under Stalin, or China under Mao are more or less sophistry. All produced similar results by similar means des
by ncmncm 7y ago
Distinctions between Germany under Hitler, Russia under Stalin, or China under Mao are more or less sophistry. All produced similar results by similar means despite differences in details; principally, murder and enforced starvation of millions, and mass enslavement. China, anyway, did not adventure much beyond their borders (Tibet notwithstanding, and didn't), unless you consider that most of Chines territory was already under occupation.
- Yetanfou 7y agoThey're not sophistry and it is important to make these distinctions, if only because not doing so allows those who continue to profess allegiance to these ideologies to get away with it. As a case in point it should not come as a surprise that there are few places in the world where those who present themselves as 'National Socialist' or 'Fascist' are given a warm welcome. What should be surprising but is not is that this does not go for those who present themselves as 'Communist' or, more recently, 'Islamist'. This is made possible in part by the use of the term 'fascist' as a stand-in for all those unsavoury ideologies as it serves to wash them clean of the crimes committed in their name by allowing their proponents to claim that those who committed the crimes were not 'true' Communists or Islamists or any other -ists.
- ncmncm 7y agoIf those presenting as "communist" or "islamist" were shunned like nazis because they are all, effectively, fascists, that would not be an improvement? How not?