3 ms·
Wasn't the whole point of the 737max to all planes with new engines (which were more efficient but changed significantly the flight characteristics) to be flown
by LatteLazy 7y ago
Wasn't the whole point of the 737max to all planes with new engines (which were more efficient but changed significantly the flight characteristics) to be flown by pilots without having to re certify?
As I understand it, airlines or the faa only permit pilots to be licensed for 2 airframes at a time. So a 747 pilot can also fly 737s but not other commercial airliners. That's a problem because if the new boeing isn't a 737, existing pilots can't fly it without giving up one of the other two. Airlines dont want that as it makes introducing the new plane a massive pain in the arse and it means either dumping old planes or running a complex mixed infrastructure.
So Boeing effectively had pilots fly a 737 simulator that would make the actual Max fly when/where/how they wanted.
Except the simulator had a bug where if a single sensor failed it crashed the plane.
So the trigger of the issue is a single point of failure in a sensor but the fundamental causes are needing to not change pilot certification and/or only being allowed 2 certifications at a time.
- yardie 7y agoBoeing backed themselves into a corner they weren’t going to get out of without major restructuring. The 737 is an old airframe design. They’ve extended the design for decades with longer cabin and more powerful engines. But underneath it all is the 60s era design considerations. They needed a new regional airframe design a decade ago. Something to iterate on for the next 50 years. And that could be introduced while the 737 was phased out. A smaller version of the 787 would have a been a good foundation.
- LatteLazy 7y agoBroadly I agree, but the corner isn't just boeing: the faa and airlines banned pilots from knowing more than 2 (I think) air frames a while ago. That's anticompetitive and any progress. It's the reason Boeing is still selling 50 year old designs: no one will buy anything newer. What exactly to do about that, I'm not sure...
- redis_mlc 7y ago> the faa and airlines banned pilots from knowing more than 2 (I think) air frames a while ago. The FAA does not limit how many type certificates that a pilot has. However, large airlines have policies that likely do limit their pilots to flying two airliner types. Source: commercially-rated airplane pilot.