3 ms·
Every analysis shows that actually dealing with the problem front and center invigorates the economy. Politicians resisting action are not motivated by concern
by ncmncm 7y ago
Every analysis shows that actually dealing with the problem front and center invigorates the economy. Politicians resisting action are not motivated by concern for the economy or public well-being. The only alternative consistent with the facts is they are beholden to fossil industry.
- makomk 7y agoNo, every analysis shows that dealing with the problem front and center will require huge amounts of resources and labour. That's not the same thing as benefiting the economy. There's a well-known problem in economics known as the broken window fallacy. Suppose someone wakes up and notices their window has been smashed. They have to get a glazier in to replace it. Even though this helps to employ someone and causes economic activity, it makes no sense to argue that breaking windows helps the economy - that person has had to spend money to get back to where they would be if their window hadn't been broken that could otherwise be put to use actually improving their life. Much like the broken window fallacy, aggressive climate change action involves throwing vast amounts of resources at hopefully getting to the the same point we're already at and providing things we already have, but hopefully with less CO2 emissions. Those resources then cannot be used for other things. Economically speaking, this makes everyone worse off in order to reduce CO2. There's not really any way around that. The press like to spin all the green jobs action against climate change will create as proof it will benefit the economy, but that's just not how things work.
- TheCapeGreek 7y agoThe window is already broken. Do we leave it and die from exposure to the elements because it costs money and effort to fix, or do we bite the bullet and fix it with something stronger and sustainable?
- makomk 7y agoYou seem to be arguing that fighting climate change is so vital that it's worth the economic cost. That's certainly a valid argument, but it's not the one that was being made - that argument was that rather than having an economic cost, it actually has an economic benefit.
- ncmncm 7y agoWe must not be reading the same analyses. The ones I see very plausibly show reliable profits, an invigorated domestic job market, and massive savings on costs as diverse as energy, medical treatment, and criminal incarceration. The fossil fuel economy is a huge drain on any country dependent on it. Getting off it is hard but a big win. That is without counting the huge cost savings in not needing to try to counter effects of global climate disruption, which absolutely dwarf the cost of switching.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- lazyjones 7y ago> Every analysis shows that actually dealing with the problem front and center invigorates the economy That's nonsense. First of all it involves spending trillions. Who is going to pay for that? Sure, if you spend trillions on anything, the economy will be invigorated - but whose economy? Buying solar panels made in China isn't going to help your own economy as much as spending the same money on locally made products. > The only alternative consistent with the facts is they are beholden to fossil industry. It would really help the cause if people who supported it stopped using such obviously wrong arguments.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoMobilising for war involved spending billions, and pulled the US out of the Great Depression as New Deal spending hadn't been enough. Quantative easing to correct the excesses of the banks in '08 involved spending trillions yet was more indirect and less effective than more traditional forms of stimulation. That spending invigorates economies is pretty much unarguable. Choosing more carefully, and directing where that spending goes is better than leaving it to the random walk of the market. Pretty much everything is made in China, yet installing those solar panels will require local companies and engineers. Were they made locally the boost might be higher, but so few products are made locally in our globalised world that it's probably harder to unwind globalisation than fix the climate with foreign made panels.