5 ms·
There is so much technology available to combat it, yet those people elected seem hell bent on wrecking it to support a shrinking fossil fuel industry. They’re
by bamboozled 7y ago
There is so much technology available to combat it, yet those people elected seem hell bent on wrecking it to support a shrinking fossil fuel industry. They’re obviously failing to realise they will be victims too.
How pathetic and what an unusual time to be alive.
Take a look at the Australian PM. What a stick in the mud, the whole state of NSW is practically on fire, and all he can say is that isn’t not really caused by climate change, there are “other factors involved.
What these climate scientists have done to predict this would’ve been witchcraft a hundred years ago, the work they’ve done is amazing. The people who matter still don’t listen.
- jacquesm 7y ago> What these climate scientists have done to predict this would’ve been witchcraft a hundred years ago You may be on to something there: if cause and effect are too far related that an ordinary person without any training in the matter will be able to say 'Aha!' then trying to argue that scientists have proven it is a losing battle. The reason for that is that decades of being oversold by advertising and guys in white lab coats have conditioned people to disbelieve scientists over the words of other lay people that they feel they have a closer connection with. See also: vaccination, various 'truthers' and so on. Add in another healthy factor based on the fact that people will have to give up some luxuries and you have the stage set for a perfect disaster.
- lazyjones 7y ago> yet those people elected seem hell bent on wrecking it to support a shrinking fossil fuel industry. This is a silly recurring narrative that has no basis in reality. Politicians aren't clinging to some particular industry, they're interested in not destroying the whole economy that is necessary for our wealth and prosperity, certainly not for the FUD that is currently being spread in an area where nobody even takes a closer look at outrageous claims anymore for fear of being shouted down and where quoting IPCC reports is considered "being in denial".
- strombofulous 7y agoThey're not actually trying to support the fossil fuel industry. They don't really care about it at all. It just happens to be the case that a lot of people who vote for them are involved in the fossil fuel industry and will be directly affected by its downfall.
- bamboozled 7y agoNo, I think they’re trying to support the industry. What other plausible motive would there be for the inaction? I mean, if what you said was true and they only cared about people’s futures, they would’ve carved out a transition plan for those jobs to renewables thirty years ago. Nothing has been done really since.
- Udik 7y ago> No, I think they’re trying to support the industry. What other plausible motive would there be for the inaction? This is the "if you don't agree with me, you must be paid by someone" conspiratorial thinking. In particular, I find it simply incredible that you can ask a question such as "what other plausible motives would there be for inaction". Here is one: every part of the economy is deeply dependent on fossil fuels consumption. Economy, like climate, rests on a very delicate balance where changes can have enormous costs in terms of jobs, lack of growth, and ultimately poverty and death.
- ncmncm 7y agoEvery analysis shows that actually dealing with the problem front and center invigorates the economy. Politicians resisting action are not motivated by concern for the economy or public well-being. The only alternative consistent with the facts is they are beholden to fossil industry.
- makomk 7y agoNo, every analysis shows that dealing with the problem front and center will require huge amounts of resources and labour. That's not the same thing as benefiting the economy. There's a well-known problem in economics known as the broken window fallacy. Suppose someone wakes up and notices their window has been smashed. They have to get a glazier in to replace it. Even though this helps to employ someone and causes economic activity, it makes no sense to argue that breaking windows helps the economy - that person has had to spend money to get back to where they would be if their window hadn't been broken that could otherwise be put to use actually improving their life. Much like the broken window fallacy, aggressive climate change action involves throwing vast amounts of resources at hopefully getting to the the same point we're already at and providing things we already have, but hopefully with less CO2 emissions. Those resources then cannot be used for other things. Economically speaking, this makes everyone worse off in order to reduce CO2. There's not really any way around that. The press like to spin all the green jobs action against climate change will create as proof it will benefit the economy, but that's just not how things work.
- papermachete 7y agoHas anyone proven it was global warming and global warming only?
- cryptica 7y agoI used to think that global warming was an absolute true fact of life but with age, I've become more skeptical. I've worked with and listened to enough scientists that I've become skeptical of certain branches of science; particularly those that try to make general predictions based on incredibly complex data which encompasses an almost infinite number of variables. Several things which make me doubt: - Having worked on extremely complex software projects, I don't believe that any human being is capable of understanding or simulating something as complex as the earth, they will almost certainly exclude the vast majority of variables; many of which may not seem relevant to our primitive human minds but which may in fact be critical once you factor them in combinations with all other variables. - The earth was hotter at several points in the not-so-distant history. The Earth's climate has been constantly fluctuating. - Humans only produce 3% of the total CO2 released in the atmosphere each year. I wouldn't be surprised if the annual average fluctuation in CO2 produced by geothermal activity alone is higher than 3%. - Scientists acknowledge that more CO2 means a greener earth because plants strive on CO2 but they fail to acknowledge the possibility that more plants would take out more CO2 from the atmosphere so even with these primitive models it's looking more like some kind of equilibrium will be reached rather than a 'point of no return' as climate scientists keep advertising. - Life on earth has always been evolving and can continue to evolve to handle changes in temperatures. The species which don't adapt will die out and this is fine, it has always been like this. - If the Earth can go from being a burning ball of magma (as it was millions of years ago) to what it is today, then surely it can recover from a few degrees higher than normal. Without hindsight, nobody could have predicted that this burning ball of magma would become the lush planet that we have today and yet scientists are claiming that they can make predictions from an initial state which is much more complex and less predictable than that relatively simple ball of magma. - Climate scientists need jobs and they wouldn't have any if they didn't continuously create fear to keep public funding coming their way. At some point in the past, for reasons unknown to us, some powerful people decided to give climate scientists a platform and a voice on the world stage and now they make heavy use of it.
- ncmncm 7y agoClimate models of decades ago have turned out to be dead on. Denialism is fundamentally dishonest. Uncertainty does not favor inaction. The more the uncertainty, the more action is justified.
- omar_a1 7y agoDon't forget the ridiculous propaganda being pushed by the fossil fuel industry, if the slew of climate denialist rebuttals to your comment are any indication...
- bamboozled 7y agoI’m quite surprised honestly.
- docdeek 7y ago>Take a look at the Australian PM. What a stick in the mud, the whole state of NSW is practically on fire, and all he can say is that isn’t not really caused by climate change, there are “other factors involved. Aren’t there almost certainly other factors involved? Acknowledging that climate change is one factor among several doesn’t seem to me outrageous.
- igorkraw 7y agoSure, but what's next. Are you gonna do something about the other factors? Are you saying that because of the other factors we shouldn't do anything? This is the same trick that non-feminist MRAs try to pull when they talk about men being raped as well whenever women being raped comes up. Most don't care about the men being raped and won't really care about asking the question "and how do we stop that from happening", they just want to stop the conversation. Fuck no, if you want to comment on serious issues, comment constructively (on the bushfires example "it's also caused by XXX so we should do less of that/fix that" would be reasonable to ask for, then we can talk about prioritising this over fighting climate change)
- leereeves 7y agoYour claim is so incorrect as to border on slander. MRAs are mostly men who have been victims of institutional sexism: victims of domestic violence or sexual assault ignored by every institution meant to help such victims, or presumed guilty after false allegations, or discriminated against in custody disputes, or forced to pay child support for children that aren't theirs or after being raped, or other events like those. Watch The Red Pill if you're interested in learning something real. And if it helps you overcome your biases, you should know that it was made by a feminist woman who also regarded MRAs as the enemy, until she heard their stories.
- igorkraw 7y agoThis is why I specified non-feminist MRAs, e.g https://old.reddit.com/r/TheRedPill/ https://old.reddit.com/r/TheRedPill/. If you want to have an example for how to do it right, check out https://old.reddit.com/r/MensLib/ https://old.reddit.com/r/MensLib/ (currently on holiday private to give the excellent moderators a break but check it out after christmas) Once it's available again you will notice that in the latter, the focus is on actually helping men. Thing like the male domestic abuse shelter, Terry Cruz joining the #metoo movement, discussion of toxic masculinity and how it fucks up men+how to overcome the damage it did. All of that is good stuff, necessary and compatible/part of the feminist lens onto the world, figuring out how the traditional view on masculinity (stoic, unfeeling rocks that only want sex and power) fucks men in similar way as it does women. Now, when you check out https://old.reddit.com/r/TheRedPill/ https://old.reddit.com/r/TheRedPill/, you will notice that they also do that to some degree, but they seem to be mainly obsessed with pointing out women's hypocrisy, shutting down feminism, playing bullshit evopsych games etc. Basically, anti-feminism as a way to continue doing things that hurt the bulk of men, with the promise that if they try hard enough they will be the winners. Also, before this gets flagged as well, come on guys, just engage. My statement is clear: feminist MRA which recognizes men getting fucked doesn't mean women are doing the fucking and wants to change our social structure to the benefit of both gender roles (or dissolve them)=> good. Reactionary MRA which doesn't actually care that much about helping men and more about shutting down women's rights movements=> bad. If you are a conservative that disagrees with e.g. abolition of gender but agree that men should not have to real men and that women are not fact out to manipulate all men into doing the work for them (something r/theredpill has in their sidebar: https://dontmarry.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/the_manipulated_man.pdf https://dontmarry.files.wordpress.com/2008/08/the_manipulate...) then you are part of the feminist MRA crowd, not the anti-feminist one. And if you feel I am being uncharitable, come at me, I have sources and am always up for a good debate with strangers on the internet :-)
- nsonha 7y agoBushfires are frequent occurrences in Australia. We should combat climate change regardless of bushfire. To claim that bush fire is proven to be caused by climate change is disingenuous and unnecessary.
- bamboozled 7y agoAustralian scientists have linked the severity and intensity of this event to climate change. https://www.sbs.com.au/news/scientists-say-the-nsw-mega-fires-are-linked-to-climate-change-here-s-how https://www.sbs.com.au/news/scientists-say-the-nsw-mega-fire...
- ThomPete 7y agoLots of things gets linked, doesnt mean its true. They are speculating not demonstrating.
- bjowen 7y agoThat not been claimed. Plenty of evidence that the extent and severity has been severely exacerbated by the warming climate has been pointed out, exhaustively, to irrelevant objections like this.
- stinos 7y agoThey’re obviously failing to realise they will be victims too Will they? Many of them won't live to see the worst effects. And I can't help but think one driving force for them is simply selfishness: if the problem doesn't affect you personally it's oh so easy to just ignore it.
- bamboozled 7y agoI’m pretty sure if you look into the fires in Australia at the moment, you will see the effects are pretty bad for people of all ages. There have already been deaths from this event and many people are suffering from the heatwave and smoke inhalation. Even major sporting events have been cancelled. I would say this has exploded into somewhat of a political crisis for the current Australian government. I would say they’re were hoping to see out their careers before shit got this real. Again probably thinking the worst is a long way away; However; Here we are it is worse than predicted. The older generation are not missing out at all, they’re involved now. If you’re under 80-90, you’re like going to have a pretty miserable ten-twenty years ahead.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoSelfish enough to condemn their children... Don't most parents still care about their children when they happen to be MP's or fossil fuel execs? It's not quite the same problem as don't bathe near the factory's pollution outlet. Have to confess this is the point I find most difficult to understand, as it seems obvious it will affect everyone, regardless of income, but most especially the young and future generations. Parents generally want theirs kids and grandkids to have a better life than they did, not worse...