3 ms·
> As of October, U.S. scrap exports of plastic to mainland China were down 89% since early 2017, when China began to make clear it would ban many categories, wh
by aazaa 7y ago
> As of October, U.S. scrap exports of plastic to mainland China were down 89% since early 2017, when China began to make clear it would ban many categories, while mixed paper exports were down 96%, according to the Institute of Scrap Recycling Industries. Total U.S. plastic scrap exports to all countries were down 64% in that time period, while mixed paper exports were down 42% according to ISRI.
The article doesn't clearly explain why the shift has happened. It does point out:
> ... China ... wants to stimulate domestic garbage collection and end the flow of foreign trash it sees as an environmental and health hazard.
And later:
> China accepted dirty and mixed recyclables because it had low-wage workers to sort out unwanted material, often by hand. That gave American contractors little incentive to weed out food scraps, plastic bags and nonrecyclable junk stateside.
Have wages in China really risen so quickly that human garbage sorters are now too expensive? That seems unlikely, and the article gives no evidence for it.
An alternative explanation might be that the plastic was never recycled in the first place. It's more than just sorting. Each container has a residue of liquid/solid stuff that can't possibly be compatible with low-cost material recycling.
What if the material received by China was actually burned instead to generate energy rather than new containers? That might explain the newfound reluctance of China to take the stuff.
- mulmen 7y agoAre you suggesting China was just burning all the recyclables? If so why did they stop?
- bobthepanda 7y agoChina has a massive pollution problem. If China were to burn all recyclables in a manner consistent with the rest of their industrialization, the process probably wasn’t very clean. China could invest in cleaner recycling processes, but a quick way to reduce a problem is to reduce its scope, and banning imports of recyclable material is certainly a quick way to do that, everyone else be damned. (I don’t really think China burnt all of it, but if they did and stopped this would be why.)
- abhiyerra 7y agoI read in an article a majority of the Pacific Garbage Patch likely comes from this discarded plastic. Can’t cite at the moment...
- Mikeb85 7y ago> Have wages in China really risen so quickly that human garbage sorters are now too expensive? Probably. Some Chinese companies are now outsourcing labour to cheaper countries like Vietnam.
- Zarath 7y agoAnother anecdote, but I was in Shanghai last month and they recently started an initiative to sort trash/recyclables much more strictly. The people I was staying with were telling me that they could be fined if they don't properly sort their trash. Not sure if it's related.