2 ms·
They clearly overreacted, probably because of bad medical advice. Science is self correcting is not an excuse to give overconfident bad advice. The first info
by gus_massa 7y ago
They clearly overreacted, probably because of bad medical advice. Science is self correcting is not an excuse to give overconfident bad advice.
The first info was that she had up to an 84% risk of getting breast cancer by age 70. How big where the error bars? Perhaps it was 84% ± 83% but it was presented as it was 84% ± 1%.
Why did they rush to get operated?
Why did the sister not wait 2 or 3 years to have another children? It's not a minor thing. She could freeze eggs just in case.
Why did she not wait 2 or 3 years so the toddler was older? Raising small children is very difficult if you can't pick them up.
Why not something less invasive like regular mamographies?
In these cases it is very important to get a second and third opinion before a major irreversible surgery.