3 ms·
Precisely. This shouldn't be taken as an indictment against genetic testing and acting on those results. Only that preventative actions and their consequences s
by ineedasername 7y ago
Precisely. This shouldn't be taken as an indictment against genetic testing and acting on those results. Only that preventative actions and their consequences should be balanced against the uncertainty present in this fairly new field.
- trentnix 7y agoHow aware of the uncertainty were those “experts” who recommended they have surgery? Was that uncertainty effectively communicated to this family? Surgery carries risk and costs as well. And it’s becoming more likely that the risk assumed by these women might have been needless. Is there no accountability to be assigned at all because all is well that ends well? Throughout my life, and ESPECIALLY in medicine, there has been constant change in understanding but never a shortage of confidence by “experts” assuring me we got it right this time.
- hobofan 7y agoWas it really the experts that suggested surgery, or was it the patients that based on the genetic testing seeked out surgery? (I'm actually asking, as I'm blocked by the WSJ paywall.)
- bookofjoe 7y agohttp://archive.is/7S89q http://archive.is/7S89q
- stevehawk 7y agoI'd bet the surgery was not recommended for some of them. BRCA isn't a death sentence just because you've tested positive (assuming you haven't presented with any symptoms). If you're in your 20s or 30s the "experts" usually tell you to stay proactive on monitoring/medical appointments (self breast exams, ultrasounds of ovaries/uterus, etc) until you're done having children. Once you're done with having children you should consider a double mastectomy and possible hysterectomy. But we live in the age of Google. Our ability to search the Internet tends to result in patients making horrific decisions. My wife is a breast cancer surgeon and has a late 20s BRCA patient that presented with a significant breast mass six months ago. She refused any of the advised treatments because she was breast feeding at the time and stated to my wife, with a straight face, she would simply cut out sugar because she read that helps. Obviously my wife told her otherwise. Same lady came back in recently to finally seek treatment and she has a 30cm mass now. She's not even a candidate for surgery anymore because you wouldn't be able to close the wound post-op. But hey, imagine what it would have been like if she had kept eating sugar, right? Silly "experts".
- Alex3917 7y agoHysterectomy makes much more sense than double mastectomy. Breast cancer is detectable and in most cases treatable, whereas ovarian cancer can't really be detected until it's already fatal.
- stevehawk 7y agoMastectomy is the preferred treatment for a lot of breast cancers, particularly BRCA. Otherwise the woman or man is likely to just be back in a few years for treatment when they develop the cancer in a different spot.
- ineedasername 7y agoAgain, none of that is an indictment against preventative medicine base on genetic testing. It's an argument that medical professionals involved in it should be knowledgeable and up front about balancing risks.
- tomc1985 7y agoI'd beg to differ. There are armies of marketing drones out there trying to convince people of the necessity of genetic testing when it still carries so much uncertainty. Personally I find it very concerning that submitting samples to each of the firms returns dramatically different results
- bookofjoe 7y agoThis retired physician (neurosurgical anesthesiologist) agrees wholeheartedly with you re: the radically different results the same patient often receives from different companies. Better not to test at all?
- ineedasername 7y agoThe different results pertain to their (very speculative) ancestry models. I have not seen any incident where testing services disagreed on specific genetic markers, and that is what the medical indicators are based off of. You have to separate the ancestry guessing from the medical research, which is not done by the testing companies.
- ineedasername 7y agoBut what you're saying is not that preventative medicine based on genetic testing is bad; You're saying genetic testing is over hyped by the testing companies. That criticism doesn't argue against testing, it argues for medical practitioners to be well informed and to inform patients about balancing risks of treatment. As for differing results, I've never heard of firms disagreeing about particular genetic markers. What I've seen are ill-defined correlation models that try to tie them back to geographical regions when that's just not a great idea at all. You have to separate the two: The ancestry stuff is much closer to pseudo science than the medical.