3 ms·
>> It keeps the genre separate from “science fantasy” e.g. Star {Wars, Trek}–which are enjoyable in their own right, but quite different. Being a staunch Trekk
by YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago
>> It keeps the genre separate from “science fantasy” e.g. Star {Wars, Trek}–which are enjoyable in their own right, but quite different.
Being a staunch Trekkie, I protest. You can't put Star Wars in the same sub-genre as Star Trek! For instance, a common categorisation would have to explain the distinct absence of Ewoks or cute robots from Star Trek [1] or the much reduced focus on technology in Star Wars [2]. While (according to the wikipedia page on Science Fantasy) Star Trek is sometimes labelled as Science Fantasy, it's clear the aim of the show is completely different than the aim of Star Wars. I mean, one is an adventure with space swords and space knights, the other is ... an adventure, but with space captains and space lieutenants.
So very different.
____________
[1] I doubt anyone would consider Lt. Cmndr. Data a "cute robot" and anyway, he's an android.
[2] See: "the tech is overteching" (copied here so you can avoid opening that atrocious syfy.com page):
"It became the solution to so many plot lines and so many stories," Moore said. "It was so mechanical that we had science consultants who would just come up with the words for us and we'd just write 'tech' in the script. You know, Picard would say 'Commander La Forge, tech the tech to the warp drive.' I'm serious. If you look at those scripts, you'll see that."
Moore then went on to describe how a typical script might read before the science consultants did their thing:
La Forge: "Captain, the tech is overteching."
Picard: "Well, route the auxiliary tech to the tech, Mr. La Forge."
La Forge: "No, Captain. Captain, I've tried to tech the tech, and it won't
work."
Picard: "Well, then we're doomed."
"And then Data pops up and says, 'Captain, there is a theory that if you tech the other tech ... '" Moore said. "It's a rhythm and it's a structure, and the words are meaningless. It's not about anything except just sort of going through this dance of how they tech their way out of it."
https://www.syfy.com/syfywire/ron_moore_calls_star_trek https://www.syfy.com/syfywire/ron_moore_calls_star_trek
P.S. I know my comment comes along as a bit ironic, but I really see a difference between Star Wars and Star Trek and the kind of SciFi they represent. My best attempt at an explanation: in Star Wars, starships are cool. In Star Trek, how starships work is cool.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoOn the other hand, Star Wars is mostly free of time travel plots while they're quite common in Star Trek. Time travel, while theoretically possible, is mostly used to introduce elements of fantasy into science fiction.
- D-Coder 7y ago> On the other hand, Star Wars is mostly free of time travel plots while they're quite common in Star Trek. Perhaps because writers have so far only needed nine plots for Star Wars but needed 79 for Star Trek (TOS alone!) episodes.
- DonHopkins 7y agoI'm bistellar: I love both Star Wars and Star Trek!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- crdrost 7y agoSo this in part comes down to what novelists call a “type of conflict” that Trek makes great use of, but Wars does not. The term is usually “Man vs. Technology conflict” but if I were writing it, I would call it “people versus tools” to clarify that usually fighting off a robot counts as one of the other conflicts. Like if you have to land a plane, that is PvTool conflict. In Star Wars, this conflict is largely but not entirely absent. In a climactic scene of A New Hope, the rebels get to blow up the Death Star, except—“It didn’t go in. Just impacted on the surface.” Very short bursts in the middle of other conflict. Similarly there is a short moment of Han Solo explaining that he needs to give his computer time to make hyperspace calculations lest they all die—it is another really tiny moment to enhance a larger existing conflict. Whereas with Trek it is usually more pronounced, “no one has ever done those things with these tools, how do we even begin to do it?” ... A lot of the rest of the apparent difference comes down to format. The Trek that we remember had to be rushed and crushed. The episodes were short and the TV stations reserved the right to show them out of order, so just like virtually all TV off that time, there was typically a short circular arc by which everyone at the end of the episode must more or less be however they started. One really interesting thing someone pointed out to me about reality TV was that it was extremely cognitively complex for its time, and indeed this was its selling point. People watched Survivor because something changed as a result of every episode and there was a lot of mental stimulation of the form “ooh I wonder who would be the best strategic target for him to take out?!” . There was a little of this in other places; I like to think about how we used to debate whether a French chef should really challenge Iron Chef French Hiroyuki Sakai, or whether he should have the audacity to fight the nearly undefeatable Iron Chef Japanese Rokusaburo Michiba. But even those shows returned mostly to the same place week after week.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoMuch more insightful than my lazy comment- thanks.
- jerf 7y agoAfter some thought over the years, I've come to the conclusion that "Star Trek" isn't hard or soft or anything else. Individual episodes of Star Trek are hard or soft or whathaveyou. From that perspective, there are plenty of episodes where it's reasonably hard and plenty where it's as soft as a cooked noodle (see the many episodes set in places where thoughts become reality, just about the softest concept you could ask for). It should really be looked at more as a compilation than a single work. I also can't think of a single episode where it was rock-hard. There has always been a lot of fuzz in how fast the Enterprise can actually travel, for instance, that a truly hard series would need to commit to, even in the context of an episode. Even when they try to set for a particular story that the Enterprise could get to this destination in X hours, it's still soft because if they just try harder there's always more that can be pulled out of the engines if necessary.
- grawprog 7y ago>There has always been a lot of fuzz in how fast the Enterprise can actually travel, for instance Been watching some of the original series and next generation lately. Next generation definitely focusses more on consistancy and explaining how the 'tech' works. I've noticed a lot of TOS is completely inconsistent with the technology and abilities of different things and even people between one episode to the next. TNG, at least for the most part, seems to try and keep the explanations more 'realistic' and consistent between episodes, at least from what i've noticed.
- jerf 7y agoMy kids want to get into Star Trek, and I had them at least sample The Original Series just so they had some idea of what the "Next" generation is. One of the handful we watched was the Naked Now, the original story in which the crew gets a disease that makes everyone like super drunk, which was followed on in the second episode of TNG. Even ignoring the planet exploding for no reason, and its mass wildly fluctuating (huh-what now?), the episode ends in the Enterprise restarting its engines in a tearing hurry by "imploding" them, which causes them to go so fast they go back in time three days. I had forgotten about that! Moreover, the only reason they go back in time three days is that's when they chose to stop; there is no reason to believe they couldn't have continued on much longer. Forget slingshotting around the sun in a dangerous manner, there's a TOS episode that establishes that Kirk can damn near simply radio down to Scotty and tell him to rig the engines to travel back in time again. They even rhapsodize at the end of the episode about how amazingly useful such a thing might be in the future! (I run on the theory that if the Enterprise can accidentally do it, even if it is risky, surely you can build a thing to do it deliberately if you try.) (TBH I don't love where Star Trek is right now, but they've got a long way to go before they run out.)