4 ms·
The intermingling of economic-focused and academic-focused educational systems is the core cause of this issue. Universities used to be for scholars, whereas ap
by keiferski 7y ago
The intermingling of economic-focused and academic-focused educational systems is the core cause of this issue. Universities used to be for scholars, whereas apprenticeships were for tradespeople. Over the past century, universities have essentially replaced the role of trade school/master and thus you get the intellectual abstraction process applied to professions which have very little use for it.
There are very worthwhile areas of knowledge which have no economic value in the current system. Ergo the apprenticeship model makes no sense for a field like literature or philosophy. They belong in the academy, not the workshop.
- headsoup 7y agoNot sure even that entirely holds. A philosophy mentor that can follow your interests and provide/recommend short courses may be as beneficial as a college degree... Except the providers of work focus quite a lot on those fancy certificates.
- analog31 7y agoOddly enough, one college major is well known to have limited economic value: Music. Yet music education follows the apprenticeship model. Individual lessons, practice, ensembles, and performances, are central to the education of music performance majors.
- zozbot234 7y agoComposition and improvisation (where relevant - mostly surviving today in performance on the organ, and almost totally dead in other instruments) are also taught the same way. Somewhat surprising perhaps, since there's actually quite a bit of intellectual engagement with these topics, too - but a heavily practical attitude has long been recognized as yielding the best results.
- analog31 7y agoI'm a jazz musician, but learned improvisation on the bandstand. It was certainly "learning the hard way," and I'm not sure I recommend it. I think one reason for needing practice is that in either of those areas, you're going to suck for a long time before you get good at it. Maybe this is true of writing too. The academic environment is a place where you can get that kind of practice.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> I think one reason for needing practice is that in either of those areas, you're going to suck for a long time before you get good at it. Maybe this is true of writing too. It is true of writing too.