3 ms·
Disagree. Asimov has enormous resonance today despite never writing a convincing human character. Tau Zero puts barely any paragraphs into people's society or r
by lmm 7y ago
Disagree. Asimov has enormous resonance today despite never writing a convincing human character. Tau Zero puts barely any paragraphs into people's society or relationships, but is still breathtaking. Having a world that behaves consistently and plausibly is what gives a fictional work heft; we can care about characters and actions because we can trust that their consequences will be followed through honestly.
If an author can't even get their physics straight, why should anyone care about what they came up with on the social side, where it's a lot easier to get away with blind guesses or wishful thinking?
- yedava 7y agoWhat if an author gets inanimate physics right, but horribly botches the realm of the mind? After all, science deals with organic matter, and how that matter manifests thought and emotions. If an author can't even get that part of science right, why should anyone care what they have to say on another part of science?
- krapp 7y ago>If an author can't even get that part of science right, why should anyone care what they have to say on another part of science? That does happen - an author will be educated in a particular field or have some specific domain expertise, and their work will obviously be correct in that one regard, but the science everywhere else will be kind of ridiculous. An author may put meticulous detail into the command structure and tactics of a military sci-fi setting but still portray concepts in physics, biology, etc. which are outdated or inaccurate, or filtered through the author's own prejudice. I don't think it's reasonable to expect even a "hard SF" author to be an expert in everything, or to expect all the science in such stories to be rigorous and correct. Remember that the reason positronic brains exist in Asimov's books is that he thought "positronic" sounded cool and futuristic. It's complete and utter technobabble, yet his robot stories are still considered "hard SF" by many. People just have to accept that even so-called "hard SF" is mostly BS, and enjoy stories for what they are.
- watwut 7y ago> If an author can't even get their physics straight, why should anyone care about what they came up with on the social side, where it's a lot easier to get away with blind guesses or wishful thinking? Because they require different set of knowledge and different focus. Perfect physics does not imply good characters or understanding of society regardless of how difficult they comparatively are. Moreover, Asimov resonates, because he wrote feel good stories. Many of them are effectively detective stories with some futuristic simple idea of world. Asimov however does not appeal to people who care about characters nuance and exploration of society under this or that condition. Asimov appeals to people who want to have fun with a creative idea without uncomfortable feelings.
- kwhitefoot 7y ago> despite never writing a convincing human character. Not even Elijah Baley?
- lmm 7y agoBaley didn't feel anywhere near a complete human to me. If he has hobbies, hopes, or dreams, they weren't significant to the narrative. Even someone who spends all their time at work must surely have friends, ambitions, petty rivalries - or else he could be a single-minded obsessive who thinks of nothing but solving the case. But neither of those things came through into my awareness, if they were even mentioned on the pages at all. I genuinely couldn't remember whether he was single/married/divorced/widower without looking it up. None of which is a fault with the stories! You could say the same for, say, Sherlock Holmes: these are not convincingly rendered human characters because that's not the point of this kind of storytelling. My point is that Asimov's work succeeds on its own terms, and resonates today, without needing any of the things that the literary/soft sci-fi fans will tell you are essential.