3 ms·
I peer reviewed lots of articles when I was a researcher, including for IEEE and ACM publications. Peer reviews, editorial work, authoring articles, etc. are al
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
I peer reviewed lots of articles when I was a researcher, including for IEEE and ACM publications. Peer reviews, editorial work, authoring articles, etc. are all part of academic life, much of which is publicly funded and benefits society.
I've never heard of anyone getting payed or compensated for peer reviews. This is not a thing. Journal editors probably get payed in some cases but mostly this is a thing that is part of their professional responsibilities as e.g. a university professor and also something that looks good on their CVs and gives them influence and power. Actual labor related to proof reading, typesetting, etc. is uncommon except for some high profile publications. Mostly this work is done by authors themselves. I've dealt with professional proof readers only on two occasions.
Cost related to distribution of scientific work is almost exclusively related to the printing process, which for the past 25 years has technically been completely redundant. As soon as the WWW emerged in the early nineties, scientist started distributing articles in digital form. I know, because this is when I started doing research. I think that over the course of my research career, I've only visited the library twice. Once to get a copy of some journal article by a publisher that just was just super anal about online articles and once to drop off a box of thesis copies (a requirement of the university at the time). Even before Google became a thing, finding articles online was easy.
Considering the ACM is an organization that claims to act in the interest of it's members (i.e. researchers), open access should be a foregone conclusion and completely and utterly uncontroversial. The fact that this is not the case, tells me it is prioritizing other interests and not acting in good faith on behalf of its own members who would be do well to make continued membership conditional on this getting resolved ASAP. Money talks and members walking away would fix this in no time. Online publication is cheap (not free obviously) and should be easily funded from membership fees.
- chrisseaton 7y ago> I've never heard of anyone getting payed or compensated for peer reviews. This is not a thing. You are paid for it because if you're a paid researcher then it's part of your paid day-to-day job, in your job description.
- peterkelly 7y agoRight, but those costs are paid by the university and/or the taxpayer (in the case of publicly funded research) - they are not paid by the publishers. The latter effectively treat academics as free labour from which they can profit.
- mschuetz 7y agoAnd journals are happy to take all that research and review work that is paid for by tax payers, and then put it behind paywalls.
- joesingos 7y agoYou are not paid by the publisher though, which I think is important. Peer review is essential for publishing, and yet the cost of it is shifted to the universities (and other publicly funded institutions). From the point of view of the publisher it's free labour