3 ms·
I occasionally see a therapist, drive a safe car outside rush hour, avoid drugs, get a flu shot, do not live in areas with high violence statistics, exercise an
by jvanderbot 7y ago
I occasionally see a therapist, drive a safe car outside rush hour, avoid drugs, get a flu shot, do not live in areas with high violence statistics, exercise and wear sun screen, but simply have no recourse against most gun violence. The magnitude of risk is commensurate with problems we take head on, but somehow it's wrong to consider gun violence preventable or a worthy issue.
- allovernow 7y agoWhat recourse do you have against a random stabbing? Or a hammer blow to the back of the head? >but somehow it's wrong to consider gun violence preventable or a worthy issue It's not about believing it's worthy, it's minimizing or completely ignoring the tangible and intangible benefits of minimally restricted gun ownership. The cost/benefit analysis is treated only as a cost analysis.
- jvanderbot 7y agoI beleive I'm as prepared as I can be against random stabbings or hammers. Also, I often carry a knife. I'm genuinely curious about the benefits of minimally restricted gun ownership. In a game theoretic sense, theres only two stable power dynamics. 1. Nobody has weapons 2. Everyone does. Otherwise, the power dynamic is so skewed as to be trivially exploitable.
- pixl97 7y agoSince 1 is not possible 2 must be the only option. Firearms are trivially easy to build with any machining experience. Takes a little more chemistry to make gunpowder. That said we've been doing it in far more primitive situations for hundreds of years. If people want to kill you. Simply put, you are dead. Our focus should be on building a world where we dont want to kill each other.
- jvanderbot 7y agoBut thats not actually what I asked. What are the benefits of minimally restricted availability of weapons or how do I find a "canonical list" of such benefits? (also, option 2 is not possible either. What you propose is trending towards 2 has some scaling of benefit, and I believe the opposite: that removing as much as possible the possibility of gun violence will have far reaching de-escalating effects on police, politics, health, etc etc.) I just dont have a clear picture of how proliferation of guns helps to prevent gun violence except perhaps in the limiting, unobtainable case where everyone fears immediate lethal reprisal for any violent act?
- slowhand09 7y ago"benefits of minimally restricted availability of weapons"? Seriously? There are over 2000 laws on firearm ownership over the US. It like there is a new law every time there is a shooting. In Maryland, if I want to purchase pistol, I have to take a course (min 8 hrs), pass a test, prove marksmanship ability, get fingerprinted, and pass a background investigation. This, to qualify for an HQL - Handgun Qualifying License. This is usually $150 or more for the training, plus $45 for the license, plus $55 for the fingerprinting. Then I can select handguns approved by the state of MD, which are on a list. Then I can order or purchase one from a licensed dealer, or an individual. Then I fill out additional paperwork, and another background check. BTW, if I have been convicted of a misdemeanor which might have a possible sentence of 2 years I'd be disqualified. MD laws are written such that almost any misdemeanor COULD cost you 2 years. When the firearm arrives, there is a 7 business day waiting period before you can claim it. Of course you have to pay for the firearm, so figure $350-$500 for a reliable firearm which hopefully will not jam when used in self-defense. At this point, you've spent $600-$1000 dollars to purchase a handgun. And you can only use it at a gunrange (public or private) or in your home for self-defense. You cannot carry it in your pocket. You cannot carry it in your car except to and from a gun range. and you can't carry it loaded then. This is what legal firearms owers go thru. Gang-bangers in downtown Baltimore or St Louis... not so much.
- jvanderbot 7y agoI'd like to keep this conversation going. Maybe email me or find me on keybase from my bio. I understand that regulation is enormously inconvenient for owners. But making it easy to acquire firearms isnt a benefit of more people owning firearms, its a prerequisite. I want to understand why people should own firearms at the level of scenario 2 above.
- CapricornNoble 7y ago>but simply have no recourse against most gun violence https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/06/small-virginia-retailer-corners-the-market-on-fashionable-bulletproof-suits/372178/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2014/06/small... Those suits will stop most commonly-used pistol rounds. If you desire protection against rifle rounds, you can purchase SAPI plates from China for fairly cheap, but them, and their plate carriers, are fairly bulky....worse than wearing an armored motorcycle jacket, for comparison. Aliexpress example: https://tinyurl.com/quy7edr https://tinyurl.com/quy7edr
- jvanderbot 7y agoA $3500 suit (sold only to feds) is not a recourse against random acts of violence. Body plating is not either. This is lunacy to recommend as a common man / everyday solution that takes the place of regulation and enforcement.
- slowhand09 7y agoYou are more likely to trip, fall into a ditch or puddle and drown than be shot. So you can lament your perceived need for body armor, or forgo walking in exceptionally high crime areas.