5 ms·
> there's still zero indication that vaping is harmful, so at the very least it's not as bad as smoking since it's been around for a decade at least now and not
by pdonis 7y ago
> there's still zero indication that vaping is harmful, so at the very least it's not as bad as smoking since it's been around for a decade at least now and nothing obvious has come up
Do you know how long smoking was around before we had actual evidence that it was harmful?
(Hint: The rough order of magnitude of the time is centuries.)
- schrodinger 7y agoTo be fair we’re much better at evaluating these things now.
- allovernow 7y agoModern medical care has advanced exponentially in the last 100 years. There weren't regular, organized, multithousand data point case studies back then.
- pdonis 7y ago> There weren't regular, organized, multithousand data point case studies back then. Case studies can't spot harm faster than the harm occurs. The main harm from smoking is a significantly increased risk of lung cancer and other illnesses which can take decades to show up. That's why even with modern medicine advancing over the last century it took so long to nail down the health risks of smoking.
- quickthrowman 7y agoOther commenters already pointed out that we didn’t have modern laboratory science when tobacco was brought over to Europe, not to mention that mechanized cigarette production is a much more recent development that the use of tobacco by western cultures. I used to smoke, and now I vape. My lungs function so much better now that it’s easily discernible to me that smoking irritates lungs far more than vaping.
- duud 7y agoMy experience is that vaping feels easier on the body than smoking but both cause coughing and congestion. It probably isn't a good idea to inhale large quantities of anything other than oxygen.
- petre 7y agoYou probably mean air. Inhaling pure oxygen is generally bad, sometimes even harmful.
- pdonis 7y ago> we didn’t have modern laboratory science when tobacco was brought over to Europe Modern laboratory science is no help in figuring out fast whether vaping is harmful, because we don't understand how the human body works well enough to do laboratory tests that will tell us. So we're reduced to basically what we used to show that smoking was harmful: long-term data collection and analysis. > My lungs function so much better now that it’s easily discernible to me that smoking irritates lungs far more than vaping. Saying that vaping is less harmful than smoking (which is probably true) is a much weaker statement than saying that there's zero indication that vaping is harmful, so there's no reason to worry about it, which is the claim I was responding to.
- tempestn 7y agoI think it's pretty unquestionable that smoking is worse for the lungs, and almost certainly worse overall than vaping. But smoking was on the decline; if vaping had never existed or gone mainstream, eventually very few people would have smoked. Instead now, there are many young people becoming addicted to nicotine via vaping. That's almost certainly better than if they were smoking instead, but it's likely worse than if they weren't using a nicotine product at all. Now, you could argue that there's little evidence of nicotine being harmful aside from being highly addictive (although even then there would be an economic argument to be made), but if there is any harm, the addictive nature will make sure that harm is long-lasting.
- TheCoelacanth 7y agoHow long did it take for us to figure out that washing your hands was beneficial?