3 ms·
Honest question: What is the point of all these specialized hosting sites? At least some are succeeding so I assume there is some value being delivered to some
by jerf 16y ago
Honest question: What is the point of all these specialized hosting sites? At least some are succeeding so I assume there is some value being delivered to some customers, but I am curious what that is. From where I sit it seems like Node.js, Rails, etc are just apps on an OS and while there may some tuning opportunities it's not like the difference between a specialized Node.js/Rails/etc optimizer is going to get ten times the performance of a general purpose skilled optimizer out of a stack. (I assume that if you're building a business on one of these stacks that we can safely assume that we're not talking the totally unoptimized case.)
I explain my assumptions so you can better answer my question; as I say, I am assuming there's a positive answer, I just don't know what it is.
- rst 16y agoIt's not performance --- it's reduced setup overhead. The main upside of something like Heroku is that if you want to get something up quickly, you don't have to bother configuring a VPS for it; run three shell commands[1], and there's your app, running on the public internet. The main downside of something like heroku is that if you want to do something that would require custom config on a VPS (e.g., installing some oddball software package), you can't. There are also restrictions on what directories you can write to, and so forth, and some fairly common gems require workarounds to deal with them. But enough people find it a net win that they've had, I believe, the largest YC exit to date. [1] Walkthrough here: http://docs.heroku.com/quickstart http://docs.heroku.com/quickstart
- simonw 16y agoConfiguring and maintaining a deployment environment is really, really hard. You need to set the thing up in the first place. You need to secure it. You need to configure monitoring. When something breaks, you need to know how to fix it. Virtual servers don't help that much - at least you don't have to build the thing with your own hands, but the sysadmin angle is pretty much the same. It's a ton of very specialised knowledge which a great deal of web application developers don't have - and if they do have it, they may still not feel confident being the person on call. There's a good reason the Heroku guys earned $200 million for making that set of problems go away.