3 ms·
Not that it shouldn't be, or wasn't, treated seriously. But it was very far from operational parameters. It was a previously flown capsule that had been dunked
by gpm 7y ago
Not that it shouldn't be, or wasn't, treated seriously. But it was very far from operational parameters. It was a previously flown capsule that had been dunked in sea water. Crew capsules are not re-used.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThere's no indication in the post-mortem that the issue had anything to do with reuse or immersion. > "We believe that we had a liquid slug of the (NTO) in the pressurization system," Koenigsmann said. "When we opened the valves and pressurized the propellant system, we think that this slug was driven back into the check valve. ... That basically destroyed the check valve and caused an explosion." Hence the redesign. There's also been discussion of reusing Crew Dragon on unmanned CRS missions. https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-no-crew-dragon-spaceship-reuse-nasa-astronaut-launches/ https://www.teslarati.com/spacex-no-crew-dragon-spaceship-re... > Although the OIG report in question never specifically states it, some of the language used to describe Dragon 2’s cargo configuration does seem to imply that Cargo Dragon 2s will predominately (if not exclusively) be derived as slightly-modified Crew Dragon capsules, seemingly indicating that SpaceX’s CRS-2 missions may only ever launch flight-proven Crew Dragon capsules.
- mannykannot 7y agoThat might or might not have been relevant, and the fact that something was changed as a consquence of the investigation argues strongly for the latter. I do not understand the effort being put into arguing that this failure was largely inconsequential because it was a test. Clearly - and rightly - neither SpaceX nor NASA took it that way.
- gpm 7y ago> I do not understand the effort being put into arguing that this failure was largely inconsequential because it was a test. That's not what I'm attempting to argue... and why my post starts with a disclaimer that I'm not trying to argue that. I just think it's important to keep the facts straight.
- mannykannot 7y agoIt is also important to identify which facts are relevant.
- gpm 7y agoAnd yet it's still important to not misstate facts regardless of whether or not they are relevant, because other people will take those supposed facts and apply them in other ways then you did.
- mannykannot 7y agoAnd yet it's still important to not merely present facts regardless of whether or not they are relevant, because other people will take those facts and suppose they are relevant. Note the issue that unites these two statements - it is relevance. A test does not have to be a simulation of actual use to be relevant.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gpm 7y agoLet me say this in a different way. As soon as you misstate a fact in a public forum where people might not know the truth of the matter, that misstatement becomes relevant to many readers. Because otherwise people will read your supposed fact, assume it is true, and apply it elsewhere. That doesn't make it necessarily relevant to the original point of whether or not it was an issue that needed to be taken seriously, but that's why I explicitly started my post by stating so. I honestly can't believe that you're defending a serious misstatement of the conditions of the test on the internet by saying "well it doesn't matter that the premise of my post was wrong". Of course it matters, even if I agree with your conclusion anyways.
- ceejayoz 7y agoCould you clarify what fact I misstated? The capsule blew up. True. The capsule blew up after already having visited the ISS. Also true. Wasn't much more to my post.