2 ms·
The claimants successfully argued that software in question was buggy, and these bugs caused them financial problems: > This situation, however unsatisfactory,
by throw0101a 7y ago
The claimants successfully argued that software in question was buggy, and these bugs caused them financial problems:
> This situation, however unsatisfactory, is still far better than the payment disputes I see in practice. In the Post Office trial, a large proportion of the eye-watering costs were spent on forcing Post Office Limited to disclose documentation on Horizon’s bugs, which technical experts could then summarise to the judge. Every payment system dispute I’ve seen has made do with bland assertions that the computer system is working properly, which is the presumption in English law.[1] The Post Office trial demonstrates how wrong the presumption can be, that overturning it in litigation is so expensive that little compensation is left, and even then the resulting situation gives nobody much satisfaction.
[1] states:
> In 1997, the [UK] Law Commission decided that writers of software code wrote perfect code, because it introduced the presumption, that included computers by implication (or more accurately, digital data), that, ‘In the absence of evidence to the contrary, the courts will presume that mechanical instruments were in order at the material time’. Politicians decided to replicate the presumption for criminal proceedings by passing section 129(2) of the Criminal Justice Act 2003.
> No evidence was put forward by the Law Commission to substantiate the assertion that computers were ‘reliable’ (this is the word that is often used), and proposals for reform have not been take up.
[1] https://ials.blogs.sas.ac.uk/2019/06/25/the-use-of-the-word-robust-to-describe-software-code/ https://ials.blogs.sas.ac.uk/2019/06/25/the-use-of-the-word-...