5 ms·
If Apple trusts the security of its own operating system, it should be able to sandbox the apps just like any other app. While the US doesn’t force companies t
by scarface74 7y ago
If Apple trusts the security of its own operating system, it should be able to sandbox the apps just like any other app.
While the US doesn’t force companies to install apps, it does force companies to support E911 and the system used for Amber alerts and other mandated alerts.
- Retric 7y agoThey should not trust their sandboxing, even if it happens to be flawless today that can change at any time. Their defense in depth strategy involves inspecting apps before they get onto the App Store for completely rational reasons. If they are not allowed to do this then it’s probably in Apples interest to abandon the Russian market.
- scarface74 7y agoIf that’s the case and the apps are allowed on the App Store, they still have the same issue.
- Retric 7y agoForcing the apps to go through their approval process likely discourages some malicious behavior. Even if Apple approves an app they can still yank it at any time should the discover an issue. Require Apple to include apps and anything goes.
- scarface74 7y agoFrom the article, it will be able to be deleted just like any other app. I doubt that Apple is going to let the Russian government create the image or use some type of nationwide MDM or Enterprise. certificate. It could go through the same app review process. On the other hand, this should be an excellent test of Apple’s security and review process....
- johnnycab 7y ago>I doubt that Apple is going to let the Russian government create the image or use some type of nationwide MDM or Enterprise. >On the other hand, this should be an excellent test of Apple’s security and review process.... In between your two contrasting comments, lies the rub of how much further Apple is willing to capitulate to the demands of nation states ─ who demand nothing less. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/28/world/europe/crimea-apple-maps-russia.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/28/world/europe/crimea-apple...
- scarface74 7y agoAnd that’s political not imposing technical changes on their devices.
- johnnycab 7y agoI don't follow..pray tell, what are these arbitrary rules?
- scarface74 7y agoWhat rules? Has Apple ever made a technical change to iOS that made it less secure in response to a government request?
- johnnycab 7y agoThe entire premise of the article is to highlight the fact that a government has expressly requested Apple into allowing pre-approved apps to be installed and make use of the ecosystem, on their terms. I ask once again, where is the separation or distinction being made between the political and technical, in this case?
- scarface74 7y agoThe difference is that if an app that has to be installed by mandate only has the same rights as any other apps that can be downloaded from the App Store, it doesn’t change the security of the underlying system. If the app is restricted to the same permission and sandboxing model. Heck, Apple could theoretically make the sandbox more restrictive. On top of that, changing the name of a country is a server side change and changes data. That’s no different technically if France mandates that all movies had to have French subtitles.
- michaelt 7y agoDepends if the law says "Apple must install what we provide, so long as it complies with their policies and is in their judgement secure" or if it merely says "Apple must install what we provide"
- scarface74 7y agoI would hope that Apple is not depending on the review process to keep the platform secure instead of depending on the security of the operating system. If Apple does find that the app breaches its security process during a review, they should treat it as any other security vulnerability and fix the problem.
- jdavis703 7y agoWhy do you trust the security of US emergency alerts? We know about security flaws in SMS, MMS and iMessage. I’m guessing not as many people outside the government know about the flaws in emergency alerts, but in this case I’d be most worried about them.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m saying just the opposite. The threat model of an app that Apple has to install that goes through the security and review is the same as any other app on the App Store.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoI trust iMessage a hell of a lot more than naked SMS. Also emergency alerts in the US are now fairly well secured with a PKI (iirc). Doesn’t stop a dumb or rogue operator, but it does provide some authenticity regarding if the alert came from a legitimate authority or not.
- lern_too_spel 7y agoDevice management apps are given access to (almost) everything by the operating system by design. Further, it seems Russia wants the same unrestricted access to iCloud data that China got. Apple has already set a precedent with China, so expect more of this.
- scarface74 7y agoIt wasn’t stated that Russia was mandating device management. And just like if a regular app can cause security issues, it’s the fault of the operating system and should be fixed, if your data on the cloud can be read by an adversary, instead of only having the private keys on the device, that’s a flaw in the implementation that Apple needs to fix. Yes si realize that everything stored on iCloud is not E2E encrypted. That’s the real issue, not that the data is in China. I don’t trust the US government anymore than I trust the Chinese government.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> That’s the real issue, not that the data is in China. In the US, data requests have to be for individual accounts and go through a judge and sent to the company, who might file an appeal. This is not the case in China. The government can simply get the data it wants without any company appeal. > It wasn’t stated that Russia was mandating device management Nor was it stated that it isn't. My point was that the sandbox doesn't automatically imply that these apps are safe, as you had claimed.
- scarface74 7y agoYou trust government transparency more than I do. But wasn’t there just a case where Google gave our location data of anyone who was in a certain area. I would much rather that Apple designer a system where it couldn’t give out the information because it didn’t have an unencrypted version of the data in the first place.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago
- gruez 7y ago>While the US doesn’t force companies to install apps, it does force companies to support E911 and the system used for Amber alerts and other mandated alerts. There's a huge difference between "implement this standard on your phones" and "execute this binary blob".
- scarface74 7y agoThere are millions of “binary blobs” written by third parties on iOS. Its Apple’s responsibility to write an operating system that can run in hostile environments.
- tinus_hn 7y agoStill there’s a difference between things Apple chose to include and things they were forced to include.
- zepto 7y agoWe all know that so far nobody has ever created an unassailable operating system. A key tool Apple uses to mitigate the risk is the ability to remove those binary blobs from distribution and to prevent them from running.
- scarface74 7y agoBut that’s still after the fact and after the damage has been done. I’m not aware of any time that Apple has a removed an app from devices instead of removing it from the App Store v
- zepto 7y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2019/7/10/20689644/apple-zoom-web-server-automatic-removal-silent-update-webcam-vulnerability https://www.theverge.com/2019/7/10/20689644/apple-zoom-web-s... https://www.theverge.com/2019/7/16/20696529/apple-mac-silent-update-zoom-ringcentral-zhumu-vulnerabilty-patched https://www.theverge.com/2019/7/16/20696529/apple-mac-silent...
- coldtea 7y ago>While the US doesn’t force companies to install apps The US doesn't need to. Most companies dominating the field are US based. If they weren't, the US would turn protectionist and require specific favors from them to let them operate in the USA pronto... A lot of the grandstanding "we would never do that" stems from this dominance...
- nexuist 7y ago> If they weren't, the US would turn protectionist and require specific favors from them to let them operate in the USA pronto... This is already the case. They're not called favors, they're called federal laws. However, there are no federal laws requiring the installation of software on almost anything (maybe military applications?) There is no need. The government can just go through ISPs & carriers & companies for surveillance purposes. Russia's government can do the same thing. This move is an attempt to energize the Russian software market and not much else.
- codedokode 7y agoUnlike US court, Russian government or courts cannot order Apple or Google to disclose or remove information (ok, they can, but Google simply ignores their lawful requests). So the situation is non-symmetric. Although I am against this law because probably it is there to allow spying for Russian citizens and prevent them from using secure messengers like Telegram or Tox.
- codedokode 7y agoThat's right. Apple and Android firmware is already written by US companies complying with US laws and US court orders. They will do everything court orders so there is no need for an additional law. And, by coincidence, companies that sell equipment with non-US firmware, are not very welcome in the country.
- pkaye 7y ago> And, by coincidence, companies that sell equipment with non-US firmware, are not very welcome in the country. This maybe the case for military equipment. In terms of infrastructure, I think currently its just Huawei equipment that is banned. An other countries are considering that ban too. But we use plenty of equipment from South Korea, Taiwan, EU. I bet the BIOS of most PCs are developed overseas.
- johannes1234321 7y agoIt's not only about integrity of the phone. Imagine a state requested application tracks location and sends that up (yeah, need is little as devices can be tracked over cell towers relatively good) when installing they'd certainly require permissions to be set accordingly. Also from Apple's perspective it's about the brand. They don't want to have preloaded crap on a fresh device, where the user can't distinguish whether it comes from Apple or the state.
- scarface74 7y agoIf Apple imposes the same restrictions as any other app - that an app doesn’t get location data without the user’s consent - it’s not different than what any other app on the store can do.
- johannes1234321 7y agoIf the law requires to install some software, the law certainly requires to install them in a "working" fashion. Maybe lawmakers miss this in the first iteration. Second iteration however will contain this.
- scarface74 7y agoAnd then Apple could put up a huge warming “This app tracks your location. You can delete this app by doing X”. The proposed law will allow an app to be deleted by end users. Apple puts all sorts of scary warnings on certain apps - they did that for a year to 32 bit apps.