5 ms·
When I studied media science one of the most lasting experiences I had was a talk with one lady of the viennese film museum (on of the few film museums that sto
by atoav 7y ago
When I studied media science one of the most lasting experiences I had was a talk with one lady of the viennese film museum (on of the few film museums that store actual films instead of film props).
As a digital native I never gave it a thought, but she told me that there is a collective memory gap in films that have been shot or stored digitally. With stuff that has been stored on film, there was always soem copy in some cellar and they could make a new working copy from whatever they found. With digital technology this became much much harder and costly for them, because it often means cobbling together the last working tape players and maintaining both the machines and the knowledge of how to maintain them. With stuff on harddrives a hundred different codecs that won’t run on just any machine etc this combined to something she called the digital gap.
I had never thought about technology in that way. Nowadays this kind of robustness, archiveability and futureproofing has become a factor that drives many of my decisions when it comes to file formats, software etc. This is one of the main reasons why I dislike relying soly on cloud based solutions for many applications. What if that fancy startup goes south? What happens to my data? Even if they allow me to get it in a readable format, couldn’t I just have avoided that by using something reliable from the start?
I grew to both understand and like the unix mantra of small independent units of organizations — trying as hard as possible not to make software and other things into a interlinked ball of mud that falls apart once of the parts stops working for one or the other reasons. Thinking about how your notes, texts, videos, pictures, software, tools etc. will look in a quasi post apocalyptic scenario can be a healthy exercise.
- blackoil 7y agoAsk Whovians (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_Who_missing_episodes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_Who_missing_episodes). Post internet, most content is globally replicated. Someone somewhere will find time and energy to make an Amiga simulator with exactly correct bugs, to run the program you want. Amount of content lost proportion to amount of content created must have gone down dramatically.
- Twisell 7y agoSorry for cross interfering with this post timeline ;)
- Twisell 7y agoOn this subject you can dive into the story of the missing "Doctor Who" TV serials. Some tape of master's were infamously reused to store other contents. Beside the whole archive problem come from the reusable nature and scarcity of the chosen storage. I think I've read something about reusing paper as well in medieval time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_Who_missing_episodes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Doctor_Who_missing_episodes
- vlz 7y ago> I think I've read something about reusing paper as well in medieval time. This mostly happened with parchment, not paper, but otherwise you are right. It is called a palimpsest.[1] Sometimes the writing under the writing can be reconstructed as happened with the oldest copy of Cicero's Republic.[2] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palimpsest https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palimpsest [2]: https://www.historyofinformation.com/detail.php?entryid=3059 https://www.historyofinformation.com/detail.php?entryid=3059
- rusk 7y ago> With digital technology this became much much harder and costly for them, because it often means cobbling together the last working tape players I think something might be getting lost in translation. Could she have meant “electronic” rather than “digital” (which to me suggests digital media such as DVD etc) This whole anecdote makes more sense to me with this substitution.
- atoav 7y agoShe was refering to both, she said they have similar problems with CDs and even stuff on hard disks, because often the used Video Codecs are hard to get running without the right knowledge and resources, especially because some of the non-consumer-codecs were often also proprietary and sort of made fore specific plattforms, but I don't know too much on that, so take this as speculation.
- rusk 7y agoYes when you equate it with “both”it all makes more sense! Just that digital as I’m used to the term excludes the analogue stuff like VHS as well
- mmsimanga 7y agoInteresting analogy. I am having opposite problem. I have a shoe box half filled with miniDV tapes. Camera is long gone. I would like to transfer these to hard drive. Services that offer service digitize your tapes just too expensive for me. Most of the tapes probably just goofing around and there is issue of privacy. With current camcorder I just plug the SD card into computer and copy across.
- ant6n 7y agoGet an old minidv player which can transit the video over FireWire: https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-best-way-to-transfer-mini-DV-tapes-to-digital https://www.quora.com/What-is-the-best-way-to-transfer-mini-...
- b0rsuk 7y agoThere is an old observation that I found striking at the time: Newer methods of storing information tend to be progressively easier to write, and progressively less durable. (The following is not really in chronological order) You'll never look at stone tablets the same way again. As primitive as they are, their longevity can be amazing. Ancient emperors and tyrants knew what they were doing. Trajan's column from 113 AD is our main source on roman legionary's iconic equipment. Cuneiform tablets were heavy and awkward, but they were 3D so there was no paint to worry about. Parchment tends to be more durable than papyrus, and paper. Perhaps the best known among the Dead Sea Scrolls was made out of copper. Iron Age culture artifacts are harder to find than Bronze Age one, because bronze is more resistant to corrosion. CD's, especially(?) from home burners, are reported to oxidize after several years. That may still be better than tapes, hard drives and other magnetic media (SSD?) which can be wiped by an EMP pulse. The internet era information storage appears to come with an upkeep cost! Slack practically doesn't archive messages by default. Until Gmail, it was typical for email servers to delete old messages. People get used to novelty and things being ephemeral. Capitalism supposedly requires low durability goods so people keep buying them, including tools and clothes. Houses are poorly built break down pretty quickly. I find it amazing people used to decorate their homes, tools, clothes with ornaments, engravings etc. You'd be a fool to do that today, you don't even know how long that thing is going to last.
- djhaskin987 7y agoObligatory xkcd entitled "Digital Resource Lifespan" https://www.xkcd.com/1909/ https://www.xkcd.com/1909/