3 ms·
There's no way that wireless links will ever be faster than backbone fiber - the whole notion makes very little sense. Starlink may be useful in other ways, of
by zozbot234 7y ago
There's no way that wireless links will ever be faster than backbone fiber - the whole notion makes very little sense. Starlink may be useful in other ways, of course.
- jethro_tell 7y agoThere's also no way that it won't have backbone fiber in that network. It's gotta cross connect with the rest of the internet at some point.
- pitaj 7y agoWireless links could absolutely be faster than fiber links in latency. Unlikely they'll be faster in bandwidth though that's also possible if they are able to convince regulatory agencies that their beam-forming is good enough to allow them to use large swaths of bandwidth.
- ethbro 7y ago> There's no way that wireless links will ever be faster than backbone fiber - the whole notion makes very little sense. Why? Wireless signals propagate faster linearly than fiber signals, no? I don't have time to do napkin math, but if 2x orbital height + curvature path multiple < linear speed difference, wireless comes out ahead. From memory, I think this held true for transoceanic distances.
- LMYahooTFY 7y agoSo is the high latency reputation from satellite links just due to low end hardware on the satellite?
- NOT_JON 7y agoTypical satellites are at geostationary orbit (35,786km). Starlink satellites will be at 340km/550km/1150km. Lower orbits = less latency, but require a lot more satellites to cover the same area.
- jws 7y agoTraditional satellite internet providers used satellites in geosynchronous orbit (that whole “aiming your dish” thing). That’s a 270ms hop up and another back. Starlink is the other “not here yet” services are going to use low earth orbits for something like a 25-35ms latency to the satellite.
- MayeulC 7y agoNo, typical communication satellites operate in geostationary orbit, 36,000 km high. Signal must go up that far, then down again. The earth's circumference is 40,000 km, so you've traveled more already (and yet, are still in the same area because I didn't count transmitting to another satellite -- which AFAIK is never done: the satellite transmits back down to somewhere where the data can be transmitted trough fiber). Assuming light travels at 2c/3 in fiber, it would still take less time for a signal to go around the equator back to the same spot than for it to arrive anywhere on earth if using a satellite link. Spacex's satellites are a game-changer because they sit in low orbit.
- walrus01 7y agoThe bandwidth available for a single DWDM channel in fiber is multiple terahertz wide.
- ethbro 7y agoI sort of assumed parent was using "fast" in terms of throughput rather than speed, but wanted to clarify.
- tpmx 7y agoI posted this link to an interesting paper on this particular topic about two months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21324653 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21324653 "Starlink has the potential to provide lower latency around the globe than terrestrial fiber because light travels faster in vacuum than in optical silica fiber. "Delay is Not an Option: Low Latency Routing in Space" ... "We conclude that a network built in this manner can provide lower latency communications than any possible terrestrial optical fiber network for communications over distances greater than about 3000 km.""
- rocqua 7y agoThe speed of light in glass-fiber is about 1.5 times slower than the speed of light in a vacuum. Hence the extra distance for lower-orbit systems can be canceled out by the extra speed of signals. This is only talking about latency. Bandwidth is a different game. Sure, any given fiber link will probably have better bandwidth than any satellite link. Cause the medium in between is much more consistent, leading to less signal degradation. However, fiber needs to be placed, connected, maintained. Moreover, fiber needs a physical space. Meanwhile wireless just needs access-points at both ends, well-aimed antennas, and little interference in between. Notably, I believe star-link will use laser communication for inter-satelite communication, which essentially means perfect directional antennas. This stuff might be able to scale faster. It can certainly scale further because you don't need the space for all those cables.
- djsumdog 7y agoThe idea with Starlink is that it will be low enough in the atmosphere and the satellite density will be high enough that the satellites should be able to route site-to-site. For some applications (high frequency trading) you could get potentially lower latency than with fiber.