3 ms·
> I doubt she will ever know what a "light" is, or what she is doing when she turns it "on". You mean Alexa may never know what we mean by "light" or "turning
by naasking 7y ago
> I doubt she will ever know what a "light" is, or what she is doing when she turns it "on".
You mean Alexa may never know what we mean by "light" or "turning it on". Neither would an intelligent alien that doesn't rely on sight. That doesn't entail that such a creature isn't intelligent, or doesn't have a mental life, or its operations doesn't operate on a model consisting of a set of propositions.
> There is no "logic" which can specify such things in a limited set of propositions: the effect of the world on animals is not merely to add propositions to their "set of beliefs".
That's conjecture, although I think the way you've framed it is misleading. Instincts are also "beliefs" in this model, and the operation of a mind can have multiple layers with inconsistent sets of "beliefs" that sometimes drive seemingly inconsistent behaviour.
- QuanticSausage 7y ago> An intelligent alien that doesn't rely on sight. You don't have to go that far. A person blind from birth is enough an example.