3 ms·
> Only a programmer would think that going back to keyboards is a good idea. He goes too far and his suggestions are nebulous. But it sure would be nice to go
by mlyle 7y ago
> Only a programmer would think that going back to keyboards is a good idea.
He goes too far and his suggestions are nebulous.
But it sure would be nice to go back somewhat to the keyboard.
There are so many apps with broken tab-orders; so many common operations without common shortcuts; so many badly tuned completion engines; bad interactions with autofill, etc. There's a whole lot of stuff that I could do faster on the keyboard, but I am being constantly trained to not dare assuming I can fly through and the right things will happen. In any application that I am not positive will do the "right things", I am slow and tentative.
It's bad for accessibility, too. A vision deficit or dexterity deficit impacts mouse use harshly.
We need to go back to making the keyboard experience good. Not just in individual applications, but across the board. While we're at it, we should realize that being too free in design choices has negative impacts to user. There was a time that Apple really cared about this stuff, for instance, and usability on Apples excelled because you knew that there was a lot of effort in the developer community to do the right things and conform to common standards.
- hindsightbias 7y agoAnd you have to have 3 browsers because 2 of them are broken on some field. I wonder how often updates cratered green consoles back in the day. Curses could be tricky at times. The path for many commercial UIs seems to be to map out complex processes into the most linear common path so that anyone off the street could do it. All that mouse action kneecaps productivity, and as soon as you come to an exception you enter a hell of popups or bazaar of UI elements. Then of course they chop out all the keyboard ahortcuts. Great UX is sort of like fusion, it’s always 30 years away.
- sudosysgen 7y agoGreat UX is worse than fusion - at least once we get fusion done it'll be worked out, but UX will always be on the brink of regression.