3 ms·
I upvoted it, but I have mixed feelings about it. I agree with the overall sentiment that it's ludicrous how much slower everything feels on computers these day
by kibwen 7y ago
I upvoted it, but I have mixed feelings about it. I agree with the overall sentiment that it's ludicrous how much slower everything feels on computers these days: we're able to do more complex things than ever, which is great, but it's hard to rationalize why even the simple things that we've been doing forever have become so sluggish.
My first job out of college was to migrate an internal inventory management system from a in-terminal keyboard-based application (which nobody could be hired to maintain, as they stopped teaching IBM-RPG to college grads twenty years before) to a webapp. As part of gathering requirements I learned how to use it, and god damn was it fast. I watched salespeople and warehouse stockers alike fly through the menus so fast that they didn't even need to wait for screens to draw before advancing (and the screens were snap-quick to draw!), they just conjured the paths they needed from muscle memory and batched up a dozen keypresses and boom, done. I felt awful imposing this new laggy webapp on them, though I did make sure to at least leave the familiar keyboard shortcuts.
But at the same time I think the author is somewhat overselling the idea that keyboard interfaces are just as intuitive as mouse interfaces. To use the application above as an example, when we showed the new webapp to people who only had cause to use this system occasionally, they were able to navigate it more easily and professed to prefer it over the old one. Contrast this with people who used the system all day, who grumbled at the loss of productivity and need to re-learn things.
Keyboard shortcuts are great for power users who have cause to master an application thoroughly. For occasional users who don't need to master it and don't want to learn anything, a mouse will get them up and running faster. And, of course, there's still no excuse for how much lag and slowness we willingly endure in our modern UIs.
- feanaro 7y agoI feel like a large part of the unintuitiveness of keyboard interfaces is not actually an intrinsic quality of keyboard interfaces since they're so often conflated with command-line or TUI interfaces. There might be an alternative but yet undiscovered paradigm which combines the best of both worlds: keyboard control and intuitive, beautiful, graphical widgets. To motivate this with a somewhat blunt example, what if we had a typical GUI but named each control (button, field, etc) with a short code (1-2 letters), in the style of Vimperator/Tridactyl/Vimium? You lose none of the intuitiveness and discoverability, but suddenly you can select the control much more quickly and precisely than clumsily trying to point a mouse pointer onto it. And that's just a silly example I came off the top of my head now. There may be much better keyboard-centric yet intuitive paradigms.
- naravara 7y ago>To motivate this with a somewhat blunt example, what if we had a typical GUI but named each control (button, field, etc) with a short code (1-2 letters), in the style of Vimperator/Tridactyl/Vimium? Excel basically does this. If you hold down alt it hovers the companion hotkey above each function on the ribbon. It is very handy for learning your way around. I think this is actually the big challenge with keyboard interfaces is that there is a learning curve. The advantage of mouse (or even mores touchscreens) is that a literal monkey can figure it out. But they're also limited in what they can do and how quickly they can do it. Meanwhile, keyboard based inputs take some time to learn but become extremely powerful once you're adept at them. But for non-power users who aren't that comfortable navigating a computer, it can feel like trying to learn a musical instrument for them. We nerds can flit from one interface to another because a lot of the general mechanics and muscle memory can carry over. But for people who haven't trained that skill it's much harder to learn these things, similar to playing video games. People who have never done it have no clue what they're doing when you put a controller in their hands.
- feanaro 7y agoI mostly agree with your point: keyboard interfaces are often harder to learn than the standard graphical mouse interface. But I'd like to argue that a mouse also takes a bit of time to grok when you first encounter it. A simple interface like "each thing on the screen has a two-letter code; type the code to select it" doesn't sound intrinsically harder to explain to me than teaching someone how to use a mouse the first time. Especially when you consider that there's often a lot of subtlety in when to use the right or the left button. I find this is something that often trips up people that are encountering a mouse for the first time.
- josinalvo 7y ago> no clue what they're doing when you put a controller in their hands. May I agree to that? I am a power user by any measure (CS major and program for a living) but still fail to grasp the controls of the simplest video game, to the point that, after hours of play, I still confuse (say) jump and attack
- 7y ago