4 ms·
Yes, you've hit the nail on the head here. Some of them will refer to the "white power" movement, a term which they appropriated from "black power". Because i
by lisper 7y ago
Yes, you've hit the nail on the head here. Some of them will refer to the "white power" movement, a term which they appropriated from "black power". Because if "black power" is OK, why not "white power"?
This is the thing that drives me absolutely bananas about the Left: they think they're so smart, but they don't even understand what game they are playing, and as a result the Right runs roughshod over them simply by being masters of the language. How could any reasonable person possibly object to, say, "making America great again"?
- trianglem 7y agoBecause it implies America is not as great as it used to be when for a vast majority of minorities and women, it’s never been better.
- mc32 7y agoI think an issue is a difference or dichotomy in perceived symbology. For many people it means progressive economic growth and certainty. For some people it’s negatively interpreted as a return to regressive social policies. For most people (but not all) elections are about pocket/kitchen table issues. Anti/globalization is about the impact on household economics, primarily (a minority about wealth transfer, pollution and other secondary issues.)
- lisper 7y agoAnd here you have walked straight into the trap. If you are an uneducated white male who has been unemployed since the steel factory went under, the economic ascendancy of women and minorities is not a measure of the country's greatness, it is a symptom of its moral decay. Our infrastructure is crumbling. Our military is impotent. Our factories are shuttered. Why? Because of affirmative action, which propels people into positions they are not competent to hold simply because they lack a Y chromosome or have dark skin. It's such an obviously stupid policy. It amplifies incompetence, and today we are paying the price. (Please note: this is not my point of view. I'm channeling the Right simply to demonstrate how their rhetorical techniques work.)
- trianglem 7y agoIt’s not really effective in my opinion because for someone to gain power, someone’s got to give up some and no one wants that. So it’s going to have to be a continuous battle.
- coldtea 7y agoFor a vast majority of minorities and women, it’s never been better regarding sex preferences and racism. Which are a part of life, but not 100% of it. It still worse off for a vast majority of people (including minorities and women) in many areas - financially, loneliness/lack of community, ruthless commercialism, neglected towns/infrastructure, rising healthcare/education/housing costs, shitty work conditions, etc. You can be both black (and better off as black) or gay (and better of as gay) and still be in a shitty job, in a broken community, in dire financial situation, worse neighbourhood, etc compared to people in previous decades.
- lidHanteyk 7y agoTo be fair, you need an argument from the outside for your second point. It requires an understanding of fascism to recognize that "make America great again" is a fascist resurrection myth. Classical liberals get caught up on the idea that it's reasonably-phrased and worth debating; neoliberals get overfocused on economic metrics and ignore social implications. Word games are hard.
- lisper 7y ago> Word games are hard. Yes. But playing them well is often necessary in order to be effective in today's world. This is the problem with the people complaining about "quantum supremacy". They don't even realize that they being played because they don't even realize that they are playing a game. They think they are doing the somber work of Serious People. They are wrong.
- coldtea 7y ago>It requires an understanding of fascism to recognize that "make America great again" is a fascist resurrection myth Well, way before fascism was even a thing countries had great periods and bad periods. Wanting to make your country back great has little to do with fascism - even if it was one of the 100+ slogans the actual fascists used. If only that was what Hitler was after, to merely get Germany back up, instead of e.g. take over neighborhood countries, exterminate the jews and other minorities, stifle free speech and politics, etc...