4 ms·
I don't think the idea that the brain can do anything a sufficiently fast computer can't deserves any credence. Those who argue this point always descend into h
by michaelmrose 7y ago
I don't think the idea that the brain can do anything a sufficiently fast computer can't deserves any credence. Those who argue this point always descend into hand wavy nonsense.
- 0xBA5ED 7y agoIf by computer, you mean a binary computer using transistors, there's no reason to think you can make it do anything a brain can do. Alternatively, if computer means any hypothetical hardware, it may very well end up looking like a brain, in which case you might just call it an artificial brain rather than a computer.
- michaelmrose 7y agoWhy couldn't a traditional computer fast enough simulate the brain you imagine?
- disem_brane 7y agoAnd how about you make the case for silicon becoming self aware or having subjective experience without descending into hand wavy nonsense? Primates, which are very similar to us, do not have a comparable subjective experience. We know that because we can communicate with them and they don't have that much to say. There are also brains in other animals that share a lot of similarities and are larger than ours. Yet no beings (that's were aware of) have a subjective experience as rich as humans or can self-referentially communicate about that experience. But turn up the clock speed on my gaming rig far enough and I get to debate the meaning of existence with it? You have to ignore so much that is obvious to come to a reductive, materialistic conclusion like that. [Edit] Not sure if it's worth adding this but I do think we can build a computer that passes the Turing test. I also believe (sooner rather than later) we'll have a Siri-like AI that will provide enough companionship that a relationship can be formed with it. We could even teach that AI to discuss subjective experience in a believable way.
- michaelmrose 7y agoI'm not saying that your particular software running on your machine would produce a subjective experience. Quake at 3 billion frames per second doesn't equal self awareness. I'm saying that your hypothetical gaming rig because it can simulate any type of classical computation including running a simulation of your brain and thus would be sufficient given a programmer.
- antonvs 7y agoIt depends what you my mean by "do anything". If that includes "have a conscious experience," then you're the one who's going to have to descend into hand wavy nonsense to explain how that's possible. Unless you've solved the hard problem of consciousness.
- michaelmrose 7y agoIt's not clear that a computer storing input data and then modifying future computations based on that data and storing the results of that computation and using it to modify further computations is at all remarkable to start with. If there is nothing inherently remarkable beyond scale then no hand waving needed.
- antonvs 7y agoThe description you doesn't addresses consciousness. The remarkable aspect is that of conscious awareness. You (presumably) have an experience of the world, in a way that a computer does not. Paraphrasing Nagel, "there is something it is like to be you." Most people don't think that this is true of an executing computer program, for example - it executes whatever its instructions are, and even a self-modifying program, as you described, doesn't change that. There is no known way to write a computer program which has conscious awareness, and no plausible reason that scale should affect this. If you scale up a computer program, or a computational neural network, there's no reason to believe that it wouldn't just be a very big machine, blindly executing its instructions with no conscious awareness. The proposed explanations that do exist are all nothing but handwaving at this point, hence my original comment. The burden of explanation here is on those who claim that the brain is nothing but a computing device, since our current models of computing devices can't explain consciousness.